Π“ΠžΠ‘Π£Π”ΠΠ Π‘Π’Π’Πž, Π“Π ΠΠ–Π”ΠΠΠ‘ΠšΠžΠ•
ΠžΠ‘Π©Π•Π‘Π’Π’Πž Π˜ξ˜ŸΠ‘Π’ΠΠ‘Π˜Π›Π¬ΠΠžΠ‘Π’Π¬
STATE, CIVIL SOCIETY AND STABILITY
Научная ΡΡ‚Π°Ρ‚ΡŒΡ / Research Article
Π£Π”Πš 338.242
DOI: 10.14258/SSI(2024)3-04
ΠžΡΠ½ΠΎΠ²Π½Ρ‹Π΅ экономичСскиС Π΄Π΅Ρ‚Π΅Ρ€ΠΌΠΈΠ½Π°Π½Ρ‚Ρ‹ формирования
уровня ΠΆΠΈΠ·Π½ΠΈ насСлСния: Π΄Π°Π»ΡŒΠ½Π΅Π²ΠΎΡΡ‚ΠΎΡ‡Π½Ρ‹ΠΉ кСйс
ΠΠ°Ρ‚Π°Π»ΡŒΡ ΠœΠΈΡ…Π°ΠΉΠ»ΠΎΠ²Π½Π° Полянская
Бурятский государствСнный унивСрситСт ΠΈΠΌ. Π”ΠΎΡ€ΠΆΠΈ Π‘Π°Π½Π·Π°Ρ€ΠΎΠ²Π°, Π£Π»Π°Π½-Удэ, Россия;
natali_mz@mail.ru, https://orcid.org/0000-0002-6387-6494
Аннотация. ξ˜—ξ˜ˆξšξ˜Šξš‚ ξ˜Œξšξšƒξšξ˜ξ˜ˆξ˜ξ˜‚, ξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜‰ξ˜„ξ˜ξšξšξš†ξ™Ώ ξš’ξ˜†ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξ˜ˆξ˜ξšξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜‹ ξ˜’ξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Œξ˜Œ ξšξ˜ξšƒξšξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ˆξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Šξš€ξš­ξ˜Œξ˜ ξ˜ƒξ˜Šξ˜ˆξš†,
ξš€ξ˜‰ξ˜„ξš€ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ξš€ ξšξ˜Šξ˜‰ξš†ξš‘ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξ˜ ξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξšξš€ ξš‹ξ˜Œξšξšξ˜Œ ξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Œξš‚ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Œξ™Ώ ξ˜ƒξ˜†ξ˜ξš‹ξ˜ˆξ˜ξš ξ˜Œξšƒξ˜ŠξšŠξ˜ξ˜ξšξ˜ξ˜‚ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξ˜ ξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ ξš„ξ˜Žξ˜Šξšξ˜Šξ˜‹ξ˜Œξ˜Žξ˜Œ.
ξš‡ξ˜„ξš€ ξ˜ξ˜Šξšξ˜ˆξ˜ξšξ˜Œξš€ ξšξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ˆξšξ˜Šξ˜ξš†ξ˜„ξ˜Šξ˜Ž ξšξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Šξš‚ξ˜‚ξ˜Œξ˜‰ξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Š, ξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Œξ˜‰ξšξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Š ξ˜ξ˜Šξ˜…ξ˜Œξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜Š-ξš„ξ˜Žξ˜Šξšξ˜Šξ˜‹ξ˜Œξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Š ξ˜†ξ˜ξšξ˜‰ξ˜Œ-
ξ˜‡ξ˜Œξš€ ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜†ξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜†ξ˜Œξš‚ ξšξ˜ξ˜ŠξšŠξ™Ώξ˜Šξ˜ˆξ˜Œξ˜‹ξš† ξšξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜Œξš€, ξ˜‰ξ˜ξš‹ξšξ˜ξš‚ξš‘ξ˜Œξ˜‹ ξ˜Œξšξšƒξ˜Žξ˜Šξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜†ξš†ξ™Ώ ξš€ξ˜‰ξ˜„ξš€ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ξš€ ξ˜ξ˜Šξ™Ώξ˜†ξ˜ξšξ˜ξšξ˜Œξ˜ ξ˜Œξšƒξšξ˜†ξ˜Œξšξ˜‹-
ξšξ˜Šξš‹ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξ˜ ξ˜„ξš ξ˜ˆξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Œξ™Ώ ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ξšξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜Šξ˜‰, ξ˜Œξ˜„ξ˜Œ ξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜ξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Š ξ˜Žξ˜ξšξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜.  ξ˜Œξšƒξ˜Œξ™Ώ ξšŠξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜Šξšξ˜Šξ˜„ξšξ˜‚ξ˜Œξ˜ξšƒβ€” ξ˜ƒξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜‰ξšξš†ξ˜
ξ˜…ξ˜ξšξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œ ξ˜„ξš ξšŠξ˜Šξš‚ ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜ξšξš†. ξš‡ξ˜ξšξšξ˜ξš€ ξ˜†ξ˜ξšŠξ˜Šξ˜‡ξ˜ ξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‰ξš€ξš­ξ˜ξšξ˜ ξ˜Œξ˜ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξš  ξ˜Šξ˜ξšξ˜Šξ˜‰ξšξš†ξ™Ώ ξš„ξ˜Žξ˜Šξšξ˜Šξ˜‹ξ˜Œξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Œξ™Ώ
ξ˜ˆξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜‹ξ˜Œξšξ˜ξšξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜‰ ξšξ˜Šξ˜†ξ˜‹ξ˜Œξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξš€ ξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξšξš€ ξš‹ξ˜Œξšξšξ˜Œ ξšξ˜ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξš€. ξ˜’ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‹ξ˜Šξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜ξšξš† ξ˜Šξ˜ξšξ˜Šξ˜‰ξšξš†ξ˜ ξ˜ξ˜ξšξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜‡ξš†
ξ˜Šξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜‰ξ˜Šξš‚ ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξšξ˜Žξ˜‡ξšξ˜†ξš† ξš„ξ˜Žξ˜Šξšξ˜Šξ˜‹ξ˜Œξ˜Žξ˜Œ   ξšξ˜Šξ˜†ξ˜‹ξ˜Œξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξš€ ξ˜‰ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜†ξ˜ ξ˜ξ˜Šξ˜…ξ˜Œξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜Š-ξš„ξ˜Žξ˜Šξšξ˜Šξ˜‹ξ˜Œ-
ξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Š ξ˜†ξ˜ξšξ˜‰ξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜Œξš€; ξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜ξ˜ˆξ˜ξšξ˜ ξ˜Šξ˜…ξ˜ξšξ˜Žξ˜ ξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξšξš€ ξš‹ξ˜Œξšξšξ˜Œ ξšξ˜ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξš€ ξ˜ˆξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜ξ˜‰ξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜‚ξšξš†ξ™Ώ ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜Œξ˜Šξšξ˜Šξ˜‰.
ξš’ξ˜Šξšƒξ˜‹ξšξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Œξ˜‹ ξšξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜‹ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜‹ ξ˜ξ˜Šξ˜…ξ˜Œξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜Š-ξš„ξ˜Žξ˜Šξšξ˜Šξ˜‹ξ˜Œξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Š ξ˜†ξ˜ξšξ˜‰ξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜Œξš€ ξš‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜Œξš‚ ξ˜Ÿξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜Ž ξšξšξ˜ξ˜‚ξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜Š
ξ˜Šξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ ξ˜Šξ˜‡ξšƒ ξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ˆξšξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Œξš‚ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Š ξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξšξš€: ξ˜‰ξ˜Šξšƒ ξ˜‹ξšξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Œξ™Ώ ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜Œξ˜Šξšξ˜ξ™Ώ ξ˜ŠξšŠξš­ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜ξšξšξ˜ξš€ ξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜Œξšξ˜‰ξ˜Šξ˜ˆξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆ-
ξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξšˆ ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξšξ˜ˆξ˜ ξ˜ξšξš­ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜ξšξšξ˜Š ξšξ˜Œξš‹ξ˜, ξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜‹ ξ˜‰ξšƒξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξš†ξ™Ώ ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜Œξ˜Šξšξ˜ξ™Ώ ξ˜Œξšƒξ˜‰ξšƒξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ˆξšξ˜ξ˜‹ ξšξ˜Šξšƒξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜ξšξ˜; ξ˜‰ξšƒξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξšξ˜Ž-
ξ˜‡ξšξ˜†ξ˜ ξ˜Œξšξ˜‰ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œξ˜…ξ˜Œξš‚ ξ˜‰ξšƒξ˜Šξ˜ξšξ˜Šξ˜‰ξšξ˜Šξš‚ ξ˜Žξ˜ξšξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„ ξ˜ξ˜Šξ˜…ξ˜Œξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜Š ξšξšξ˜ξ˜‚ξ˜Œξ˜‹ξš†ξ˜ ξ˜Šξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜Œ ξšξ˜ξ˜‹ξ˜ξ˜‡ξšξ˜Š Β«ξšξš­ξ˜ξ˜‹ξ˜„ξ˜ξšξš†Β».
ξš›ξ˜‡ξ˜Š ξ˜‰ξ˜„ξ˜Œξš€ξ˜ξ˜‡ ξšξ˜ξšƒξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œξ˜ƒξšξšξ˜‡ξš†ξš‚ ξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜ξšξšˆ ξš‹ξ˜Œξšξšξ˜Œ, ξ˜‰ξšƒξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œ, ξšξ˜ξšƒξ˜ŠξšŠξ˜ξ˜ξšξ˜ξ˜‚ξ˜ξšξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξšˆ ξš‹ξ˜Œξ˜„ξšˆξ˜ξ˜‹ ξ˜Œξšƒξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜Š
ξšŠξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜Šξšξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜ξšξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξšˆ, ξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ˆξšξ˜ξ˜ˆξšξš‘ξ˜ξ˜‰ξš†ξ˜ ξ˜ˆξ˜ξšξ˜ξš‹ξšξš†ξ˜ ξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ™Ώξ˜Šξ˜ˆξš†, ξšξ˜Šξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜ξšŠξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Œξ˜ ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ξ™Ώξ˜Šξ˜ˆξš† ξšξ˜ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξš€
ξ˜Œξšƒξ˜Œξ™Ώ ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξšξ˜Žξ˜‡ξšξ˜†ξš, ξ˜ξšƒξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜Žξš‹ξ˜ ξšξ˜ξšƒξš„ξ˜Žξ˜Šξšξ˜Šξ˜‹ξ˜Œξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Žξšξš  ξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξšξšξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξšˆ ξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜Šξ˜„ξšˆξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜Œξš€. ξ˜›ξ˜ξ˜ŠξšŠξ™Ώξ˜Šξ˜ˆξ˜Œξ˜‹ξš† ξ˜Žξ˜Šξ˜‹-
ξšξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜ξšξš†ξ˜ ξ˜‹ξ˜ξ˜†ξš† ξšξ˜Šξšƒξšξ˜Šξ˜‰ξš†ξš‘ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξš  ξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜Œξšξ˜‰ξ˜Šξ˜ˆξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œ ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξšξ˜ˆξ˜, ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ™Ώξšξ˜Œξ˜Žξ˜Š-ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ™Ώξšξ˜Šξ˜„ξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Œξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Šξš‚ -
Society andξ˜›Security Insights β„– 3 2024 68
ξš­ξ˜ξšξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œ ξ˜Œξšƒξ˜‰ξšƒξ˜…ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜Šξ˜‹ ξšξ˜Šξšƒξ˜ŠξšŠξ˜ξ˜ξšξ˜ξ˜‚ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξš  ξ˜Šξšξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜ξš‹ξ˜ξš ξš­ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜Š ξ˜ξ˜Šξ˜…ξ˜Œξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜Š-ξš„ξ˜Žξ˜Šξšξ˜Šξ˜‹ξ˜Œξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Š ξ˜†ξ˜ξšξ˜‰ξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜Œξš€
ξ˜ˆξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜ξ˜‰ξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜‚ξšξš†ξ™Ώ ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜Œξ˜Šξšξ˜Šξ˜‰, ξ˜ξ˜Šξ™Ώξ˜†ξ˜ξšξ˜ξšξ˜Œξš€ ξ˜Œξšƒ ξšξ˜†ξ˜Œξšξ˜‹ξšξ˜Šξš‹ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξš€ ξšξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜ˆξ˜Šξšξ˜ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξš€ ξ˜Œξšƒ ξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œξš‹ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξš€
ξ˜‰ξš†ξ˜ξ˜Šξ˜Žξ˜Œξ™Ώ ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ξšξ˜ˆξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜‰ ξš‹ξ˜Œξšξšξ˜Œ. ξš‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜Œξš‚ ξ˜Ÿξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜Ž ξšξšξš‹ξ˜ˆξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ξš€ ξ˜‰ξšƒξ˜Žξ˜Šξ˜‹ξšξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜ξšξ˜Šξš‚ ξšξ˜Šξ˜ˆξ˜ˆξ˜ξ˜†ξš‹ξ˜Žξ˜ ξ˜ƒξ˜Šξ˜ξšξ˜ˆξ˜ξ˜†-
ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜ ξšξ˜Šξšƒξšξ˜„ξšξ˜‚ξš‘ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξš  ξšξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜Œξš‚ ξš‹ξ˜Œξšξšξ˜ξ˜ˆξ˜ξš€ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œ ξ˜„ξš ξ˜ˆξ˜ξš‚.
ΠšΠ»ΡŽΡ‡Π΅Π²Ρ‹Π΅ слова: ξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜ξšξšˆ ξš‹ξ˜Œξšξšξ˜Œ, ξ˜ξ˜Šξ˜…ξ˜Œξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜Š-ξš„ξ˜Žξ˜Šξšξ˜Šξ˜‹ξ˜Œξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Šξ˜ ξ˜†ξ˜ξšξ˜‰ξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜Œξ˜, ξšξ˜ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξ˜, -
ξ˜‹ξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜†ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξš€, ξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜Œξšξ˜‰ξ˜Šξ˜ˆξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξšˆ ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξšξ˜ˆξ˜, ξ˜Šξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜‰ξ˜ξš€ ξš„ξ˜Žξ˜Šξšξ˜Šξ˜‹ξ˜Œξ˜Žξ˜, ξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜ξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Œξš‚ ξ˜Žξ˜ξšξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„, ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜Œ-
ξ˜Šξšξš†, ξšŠξ˜ξ˜ˆξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξšˆ, ξ˜ƒξ˜Šξ˜ξšξ˜ˆξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜ξšξšξ˜Šξ˜ ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ƒξšξ˜„ξ˜Œξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξ˜, ξšξšξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜‰ξ˜„ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξ˜, ξš‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜Œξš‚ ξ˜Ÿξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜Ž
ЀинансированиС: ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜‡ξšˆξš€ ξšξ˜Šξ˜ˆξ˜ƒξ˜Šξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜„ξ˜ξšξ˜ ξšξ˜†ξ˜Œ ξšξ˜Šξ˜ˆξ˜ˆξ˜ξ˜†ξš‹ξ˜Žξ˜ ξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜‡ξ˜ 24-05-01 Β«ξ˜™ξ˜ξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜ξš-
 ξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜Šξ˜„ξšˆξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜ξšξšξ˜Šξ˜ ξ˜ŠξšŠξ˜ξ˜ξšξ˜ξ˜‚ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξ˜  ξšξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜† ξšξ˜Šξ˜‰ξš†ξš‘ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξš€ ξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξšξš€ ξš‹ξ˜Œξšξšξ˜Œ ξšξ˜ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξš€
ξ˜’ξ˜ξ˜ξšξšξšŠξ˜„ξ˜Œξ˜Žξ˜Œ ξš…ξšξ˜†ξš€ξ˜‡ξ˜Œξš€Β», ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜Œξšξšξ˜ξ˜‹ξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Š ξ˜‰ξšƒ ξš…ξšξ˜†ξš€ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Šξ˜‹ ξ˜ƒξ˜Šξ˜ξšξ˜ˆξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜ξšξšξ˜Šξ˜‹ ξšξšξ˜Œξ˜‰ξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ ξ˜Œξ˜‹ξ˜ξšξ˜Œ
ξš‡ξ˜Šξ˜†ξš‹ξ˜Œ ξš…ξ˜ξšξšξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜.
Для цитирования: Полянская Н. М. ΠžΡΠ½ΠΎΠ²Π½Ρ‹Π΅ экономичСскиС Π΄Π΅Ρ‚Π΅Ρ€ΠΌΠΈΠ½Π°Π½Ρ‚Ρ‹ Ρ„ΠΎΡ€ΠΌΠΈΡ€ΠΎΠ²Π°-
ния уровня ΠΆΠΈΠ·Π½ΠΈ насСлСния: Π΄Π°Π»ΡŒΠ½Π΅Π²ΠΎΡΡ‚ΠΎΡ‡Π½Ρ‹ΠΉ кСйс // Society andξ˜›Security Insights. 2024. Π’. 7,
β„– 3. Π‘.ξ˜›67–88. doi: 10.14258/ssi(2024)3-04.
e Main Economic Determinants ofthe Formation ofthe
Standard ofLiving ofthe Population: the Far Eastern Case
Natalya M. Polyanskaya
Banzarov Buryat state University, Ulan-Ude, Russia;
natali_mz@mail.ru, https://orcid.org/0000-0002-6387-6494
Abstract: One ofξšƒthe tasks set by the President ofξšƒRussia for the coming years is to improve
the standard ofξšƒliving ofξšƒRussian citizens andξšƒensure economic growth. To create prerequisites for
sustainable, progressive socio-economic development ofξšƒterritories, conditions are necessary, the
most important ofξšƒwhich is the preservation andξšƒenhancement ofξšƒhuman resources, or human
capital. People andξšƒtheir well–being are the main values ofξšƒany country. is work is devoted to
the study ofξšƒthe main economic determinants ofξšƒthe formation ofξšƒthe standard ofξšƒliving ofξšƒthe pop-
ulation. e main aspects ofξšƒthe sectoral structure ofξšƒthe economy as the basis for the formation
ofξšƒa vector ofξšƒsocio-economic development are considered; an assessment ofξšƒthe standard ofξšƒliving
ofξšƒthe population ofξšƒthe Far Eastern regions is carried out. In many parameters ofξšƒsocio-economic
development, the Far East lags far behind the average Russian level. us, inξšƒmany regions, social
labor productivity is signiξš™cantly lower than inξšƒother regions andξšƒon average inξšƒthe country; so-
cially signiξš™cant industries are noticeably β€œdisadvantaged” inξšƒthe structure ofξšƒinvestments inξšƒξš™xed
assets. is aξš•ects the achieved standard ofξšƒliving, inξšƒparticular, the provision ofξšƒhousing andξšƒits
well-being, per capita income, consumer spending ofξšƒthe population andξšƒtheir structure, as well as
the economic accessibility ofξšƒfood. Comprehensive measures are needed to increase labor produc-
tivity, technical andξšƒtechnological equipment, andξšƒinξšƒgeneral, inξšƒthe ξš™eld ofξšƒadvanced socio-eco-
nomic development ofξšƒthe Far Eastern regions, the preservation andξšƒincrease ofξšƒthe population
andξšƒthe achievement ofξšƒhigh standards ofξšƒliving. e Far East needs comprehensive state support
inξšƒimproving people’s living conditions.
Государство, граТданскоС общСство ΠΈξ˜›ΡΡ‚Π°Π±ΠΈΠ»ΡŒΠ½ΠΎΡΡ‚ΡŒ 69
Keywords: standard ofξšƒliving, socio-economic development, population, demography, labor
productivity, sectoral economy, human capital, regions, poverty, management, state regulation,
Far East
Financial Support: the article was prepared with the support ofξšƒ the project 24-05-01
β€œHigh-quality food supply as a factor inξšƒimproving the standard ofξšƒliving ofξšƒthe population ofξšƒthe
Republic ofξšƒBuryatia”, implemented at the Buryat State University named aer D. Banzarov.
For citation: Polyanskaya, N. M. (2024). The Main Economic Determinants ofξ˜›the Formation ofξ˜›the
Standard ofξ˜›Living ofξ˜›the Population: the Far Eastern Case. Society andSecurity Insights, 7(3), 67–88.
(Inξ˜›Russ.). doi: 10.14258/ssi(2024)3-04.
Π’Π²Π΅Π΄Π΅Π½ΠΈΠ΅
 ξ˜Œξšƒ ξ˜Œξ™Ώ ξšŠξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜Šξšξ˜Šξ˜„ξšξ˜‚ξ˜Œξ˜ξšƒβ€” ξ˜ƒξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜‰ξšξš†ξ˜ ξ˜…ξ˜ξšξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œ ξ˜„ξš ξšŠξ˜Šξš‚ ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜ξšξš†. ξ˜ξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Šξš€ξšξ˜Œξ˜ξ˜‹
ξšξ˜ξ˜Œξ™Ώξ˜Šξš„ξ˜‹ξ˜Šξ˜…ξ˜Œξ˜Šξšξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Š, ξ˜ˆξšξ™Ώξ˜Šξ˜‰ξšξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Š ξ˜Œξšƒ ξšξ˜Œξšξ˜Œξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Š ξšξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξšˆξš€ ξ˜ƒξ˜†ξ˜ξš‹ξ˜ˆξ˜ξš ξ˜‰ξ˜Šξšƒ ξ˜‹ξšξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Šξ˜‹
ξ˜Šξšξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ˆξ˜ξ˜„ξš€ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ξš€ ξ˜Œξ™Ώ ξ˜‰ξ˜Šξ˜ξšξ˜†ξ˜Œξš€ξ˜‡ξ˜Œξ˜ ξ˜‹ξ˜Œξ˜†ξ˜, ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξšξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ˜ξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜ŠξšŠξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξšˆ, ξšξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜Šξ˜†ξ˜ξšξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξšˆ ξšξ˜†ξ˜Š-
ξšξ˜ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Œξ˜ξš‚, ξ˜Šξšξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Šξš‚ ξ˜ξ˜‰ξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜Š ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξšξ˜ˆξ˜ ξ˜Œξšƒξ˜‰ξšƒξ˜…ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜Šξ˜‹ ξ˜ξ˜‰ξ˜Šξ˜ξš‚ ξš‹ξ˜Œξšξšξšˆξš . ξš›ξ˜‡ξ˜Š ξ˜‰ξ˜„ξ˜Œξš€ξ˜ξ˜‡ ξšξ˜ξšƒξšξ˜Šξ˜†ξ˜‹ξ˜Œ-
ξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξ˜ ξ˜ƒξ˜†ξ˜ξš‹ξ˜ˆξ˜ξšξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Š ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‹ξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜Šξšξšξ˜ξšξ˜Œξš€, ξšξ˜Šξ˜‡ξ˜ξšξ˜…ξ˜Œξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜ ξ˜ŠξšŠξš­ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜ξšξšξ˜Šξš‚ ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξšξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ˜Šξ˜‡ξ˜ˆξ˜-
ξ˜‚ξ˜Œ (ξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜Œξšξ˜‰ξ˜Šξ˜ˆξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œ ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξšξ˜ˆξ˜), ξ˜ŠξšŠξš­ξ˜ξš‚ Β«ξ˜‡ξ˜Šξšξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ŒΒ» ξ˜ŠξšŠξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ξšξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜Žξ˜Œ ξ˜‰ξšƒ ξ˜ŠξšŠξš­ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜
ξ˜Œξšƒξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜ξšξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ˜‰ ξ˜†ξ˜ξšξ˜‰ξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜Œξš€ ξš„ξ˜Žξ˜Šξšξ˜Šξ˜‹ξ˜Œξ˜Žξ˜Œ. ξ˜ξ˜ξš‹ξ˜ˆξš ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜‹ ξšξ˜Œξšξ˜Œξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Šξ˜ ξ˜Œξšƒξ˜‹ξ˜ξšξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜Šξ˜ ξšξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξšˆξ˜
ξ˜ƒξ˜†ξ˜ξš‹ξ˜ˆξ˜ξš ξšξ˜ξ˜‰ξ˜Œξ˜ξ˜Œξ˜‡ ξ˜Šξ˜‡ξšƒξ˜ξ˜Šξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξš€ ξ˜‹ξšξ˜Šξš‹ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜ ξ˜ŠξšŠξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Šξš€ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξšƒβ€” ξš„ξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜‹ξ˜ξšξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜†ξšξ˜Šξš‚ -
ξšξ˜ξ˜ξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œ ξš‹ξ˜Œξšξšξ˜ξ˜ˆξ˜ξš€ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œ, ξšξ˜†ξ˜Œξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜ˆξšξ˜Š-ξ˜Žξ˜„ξ˜Œξ˜‹ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Œξ™Ώ ξšξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜Œξš‚, ξ˜Žξ˜ξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜ ξ˜‰ξ˜Šξš-
ξ˜ˆξšξ™Ώξ˜ ξ˜Œξšƒξ˜‰ξ˜Šξ˜ˆξš†, ξ˜Žξ˜Šξ˜‹ξšξ˜Šξ˜†ξ˜‡ξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œ ξš‹ξ˜Œξ˜„ξšˆξš€ ξ˜ŒξšƒξšŠξš†ξ˜‡ξ˜, ξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξšξšξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œ ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜…ξ˜Œξ˜Šξšξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Š ξšξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξš€,
ξ˜‹ξ˜ξ˜ˆξ˜Œξ˜…ξ˜Œξšξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Š ξ˜ŠξšŠξ˜ξ˜„ξšξš‹ξ˜Œξ˜‰ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξš€, ξ˜Šξ˜‡ξ˜ˆξš†ξ™Ώξ˜ ξ˜Œξšƒξšξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Š ξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ˜ξšξ˜ƒξ˜.  ξš„ξ˜‡ξ˜Œ ξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜…ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜ξš† ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜ξšξ˜Š
ξ˜‰ξšξ˜ξ˜Œξ˜‹ξ˜Š ξ˜ξ˜‰ξš€ξšξ˜ξšξš†: ξ˜‚ξ˜‡ξ˜ŠξšŠξš† ξ˜ŠξšŠξ˜ξ˜ξšξ˜ξ˜‚ξ˜Œξ˜‡ξšˆ ξ˜‰ξš†ξ˜ξ˜Šξ˜Žξ˜Œξš‚ ξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜ξšξšˆ ξš‹ξ˜Œξšξšξ˜Œ ξ˜ŠξšŠξš­ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜, ξšξ˜ξ˜ŠξšŠξ™Ώξ˜Š-
ξ˜ˆξ˜Œξ˜‹ξ˜Š ξšξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Šξš‚ξ˜‚ξ˜Œξ˜‰ξ˜Šξ˜, ξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Œξ˜‰ξšξ˜Šξ˜ ξ˜†ξ˜ξšξ˜‰ξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜Œξ˜ ξš„ξ˜Žξ˜Šξšξ˜Šξ˜‹ξ˜Œξ˜Žξ˜Œ, ξ˜Žξ˜Šξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜, ξ˜‰ξšƒξ˜ξ˜‰ξ˜Šξš  ξ˜Šξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ˆξšˆ,
ξ˜‰ξ˜Šξšξ˜‹ξ˜Šξš‹ξšξ˜Š ξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜„ξšˆξ˜Žξ˜Š ξšξ˜†ξ˜Œ ξšξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜Œξ˜‚ξ˜Œξ˜Œ ξšξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Š, ξ˜Žξ˜ξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜ξšξšξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Š ξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜ξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Š ξ˜Žξ˜ξšξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜,
ξ˜ξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜ŠξšŠξšξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Š ξ˜ŠξšŠξ˜ξ˜ξšξ˜ξ˜‚ξ˜Œξ˜‡ξšˆ  ξš„ξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜‡ ξ˜‰ξš†ξ˜ξ˜Šξ˜Žξ˜Œξš‚ ξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜ξšξšˆ ξš‹ξ˜Œξšξšξ˜Œ.
ξš¨ξ˜Œξšξšξ˜ξšξšξ˜ξš€ ξšξšξ˜ξ˜‚ξ˜Œξ˜‹ξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξšˆ ξ˜ŠξšŠξ˜Šξšξšξ˜ξ˜‚ξ˜ξšξšξš†ξ™Ώ ξšξ˜†ξ˜ŠξšŠξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜‹ ξ˜Œξšƒξ˜Œξ™Ώ ξ˜ŠξšŠξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξ˜ ξ˜‰ξšƒξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜ˆξšξ˜Œξ˜
ξ˜ƒξ˜Šξ˜ˆξš† ξ˜‰ξšξ˜Šξ˜„ξšξ˜ ξ˜ŠξšŠξššξš€ξ˜ξšξš€ξš ξ˜‡ ξ˜Œξ˜ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Œξš‚ ξ˜Œξšξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ ξ˜Žξšƒξ˜‰ξ˜Šξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‹ ξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜ξšξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜ξš-
ξšξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Š ξ˜Œξšƒ ξ˜Šξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜‰ξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Š (ξ˜œξ˜†ξ˜Šξšξ˜Œξ˜‹ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜, 2ξš‰23; ξ˜’ξ˜Šξ˜ˆξšξ˜Œξšξ˜, 2ξš‰23), ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ™Ώξšξ˜Šξ˜„ξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Œξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Š (ξ˜™ξ˜Šξ˜‚ξ˜-
ξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜, 2ξš‰24), ξ˜ˆξ˜ξ˜‹ξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜†ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Š (ξšžξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜ξšξ˜ξšξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜, 2ξš‰21) ξ˜Œξšƒξ˜‰ξšƒξ˜…ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜Šξ˜‹ ξ˜ξ˜Šξ˜…ξ˜Œξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜Š-ξš„ξ˜Žξ˜Šξšξ˜Šξ˜‹ξ˜Œ-
ξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Š (ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜ξ™Ώξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜, 2ξš‰23; ξš‡ξšˆξš€ξ˜‚ξ˜ξšξ˜Žξ˜Š, 2ξš‰22) ξ˜†ξ˜ξšξ˜‰ξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜Œξš€ ξš‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜Š ξ˜Ÿξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜Žξ˜ ξ˜Œξšƒξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜ξšξš†
ξ˜‰ξšƒξ˜…ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜Šξ˜‹. ξ˜“ξ˜‚ξ˜ξšξš†ξ˜ ξ˜Œξšƒξ˜ξšξ˜ξ˜…ξ˜Œξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜Œξ˜ξ˜‡ξš†-ξšξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜‡ξ˜Œξ˜Žξ˜Œ ξ˜Šξšξ˜ξ˜ˆξ˜ξ˜‚ξ˜ξšξš† ξ˜Œξšξšξ˜‚ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξ˜ξ˜‹ ξ˜‹ξšξ˜Šξš‹ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜ ξš‹ξ˜Œ-
ξ˜„ξ˜Œξš­ξšξš†ξ™Ώ (ξ˜›ξ˜Šξšξ˜ˆξ˜†ξ˜Œξšξ˜, 2ξš‰21; ξšŒξšξ˜ξš‚ξ˜ˆξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜‹ξ˜ξš, 2ξš‰23), ξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜Šξ˜„ξšˆξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜ξšξšξš†ξ™Ώ (ξš‡ξ˜ξ˜‹ξ˜ξšξ˜‡ξšˆξ˜ξ˜‰ξ˜,
2ξš‰23) ξ˜Œξšƒξ˜ˆξ˜†ξšξ˜ƒξ˜Œξ™Ώ ξ˜ξ˜ξšξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜‰ ξ™Ώξ˜Šξšξš€ξš‚ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜ξšξšξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Š ξ˜†ξ˜ξšξ˜‰ξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜Œξš€, ξ˜‰ξ˜„ξ˜Œξš€ξš ξš­ξ˜Œξ™Ώ ξšξ˜ξšƒξšξ˜Šξ˜†ξ˜‹ξ˜Œξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξ˜
ξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξšξš€ ξš‹ξ˜Œξšξšξ˜Œ ξšξ˜ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξš€ ξ˜ˆξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜ξ˜‰ξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜‚ξšξš†ξ™Ώ ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜Œξ˜Šξšξ˜Šξ˜‰.
 ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜Œξ˜Œ ξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜ξšξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜ξšξšξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Š ξ˜†ξ˜ξšξ˜‰ξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜Œξš€ ξ˜’ξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Œξ˜Œ1 ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜Œξ˜Šξšξš† ξš‡ξš–ξ˜— ξšξ˜†ξ˜Œξšξšξ˜ξšξš†
ξšξ˜†ξ˜Œξ˜Šξ˜†ξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜‡ξšξš†ξ˜‹ξ˜Œ ξ˜ƒξ˜ξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜Œξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Œξ˜‹ξ˜Œ ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜†ξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜†ξ˜Œξš€ξ˜‹ξ˜Œ,  ξšξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ˆξšξ˜ξ˜‹ξ˜Šξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜ξšξ˜Š -
 ξ˜…ξ˜ξšξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜‰ ξš„ξ˜Žξ˜Šξšξ˜Šξ˜‹ξ˜Œξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Š ξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ ξ˜Œξšƒ ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜†ξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜†ξ˜Œξš‚ ξ˜Šξšξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜ξš‹ξ˜ξš ξš­ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜Š ξ˜ξ˜Šξ˜…ξ˜Œξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜Š-ξš„ξ˜Žξ˜Š-
ξšξ˜Šξ˜‹ξ˜Œξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Š ξ˜†ξ˜ξšξ˜‰ξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜Œξš€ (ξ˜œξ˜—ξ˜’), ξšξ˜Šξ˜„ξšˆξšξšξš ξš­ξ˜Œξ™Ώξ˜ξš€ ξ˜†ξ˜ξšξšξš†ξ˜‹ξ˜Œ ξšξ˜†ξ˜ξšξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜ξšξ˜…ξ˜Œξš€ξ˜‹ξ˜Œ (ξ˜„ξšˆξ˜ƒξ˜Šξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜‹ξ˜Œ).
1 Об ΡƒΡ‚Π²Π΅Ρ€ΠΆΠ΄Π΅Π½ΠΈΠΈ Π‘Ρ‚Ρ€Π°Ρ‚Π΅Π³ΠΈΠΈ пространствСнного развития Российской Π€Π΅Π΄Π΅Ρ€Π°Ρ†ΠΈΠΈ Π½Π°ξ˜› ΠΏΠ΅Ρ€ΠΈ-
ΠΎΠ΄ Π΄ΠΎξ˜›2025 Π³ΠΎΠ΄Π° : РаспоряТСниС ΠŸΡ€Π°Π²ΠΈΡ‚Π΅Π»ΡŒΡΡ‚Π²Π° Π Π€ ΠΎΡ‚ξ˜›13.02.2019 β„– 207-Ρ€. URL: https://www.
consultant.ru (Π΄Π°Ρ‚Π° обращСния: 25.08.24)
Society andξ˜›Security Insights β„– 3 2024 70
ξ˜Ÿξ˜‹ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ ξ˜ξšƒξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜‹ ξ˜Œξ˜ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξš€ ξšξ˜Šξ˜Žξ˜ξšξš†ξ˜‰ξ˜ξš ξ˜‡, ξ˜‚ξ˜‡ξ˜Š ξšξ˜†ξ˜Œξšξš€ξ˜‡ξš†ξ˜ ξ˜Œξšƒξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜Œξšξšξ˜ξ˜‹ξš†ξ˜ ξ˜‰ξšƒξšξ˜-
ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Šξš€ξš­ξ˜ξ˜ ξ˜‰ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜‹ξš€ ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜Œξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Œξ˜ ξšξ˜ξ˜…ξ˜Œξ˜Šξšξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξš†ξ˜ ξ˜Œξšƒ ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜Œξ˜Šξšξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξš†ξ˜ ξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜‡ξš†  -
ξ˜ξ˜ŠξšŠξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξšξš ξ˜‡ ξ˜†ξ˜ξš‘ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξš  ξ˜‰ξšƒξšξ˜Šξ˜„ξšξ˜Šξš‚ ξ˜‹ξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜ ξ˜Šξ˜ξšξ˜Šξ˜‰ξšξš†ξ™Ώ ξšξ˜ξ˜ˆξ˜ξ˜‚ ξ˜ξ˜Šξ˜…ξ˜Œξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜Š-ξš„ξ˜Žξ˜Šξšξ˜Šξ˜‹ξ˜Œξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Š
ξ˜†ξ˜ξšξ˜‰ξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜Œξš€. ξš…ξ˜Šξ˜„ξšˆξš‘ξ˜Œξšξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜Š ξ˜Œξ˜ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜ξš‚ ξ˜ξ™Ώξ˜Šξ˜ˆξš€ξ˜‡ξ˜ξš€ ξ˜‰ξ˜Šξšƒ ξ˜‹ξšξ˜ξšξ˜Œξ˜Œ, ξ˜‚ξ˜‡ξ˜Š ξ˜‰ξšƒ ξšξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Šξš€ξš­ξ˜ξ˜
ξ˜‰ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜‹ξš€ ξšξ˜ξšξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜ ξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜ξš€ ξšξ˜ξ˜ŠξšŠξ™Ώξ˜Šξ˜ˆξ˜Œξ˜‹ξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξšˆ ξ˜‰ξš†ξ˜†ξ˜ξšŠξ˜Šξ˜‡ξ˜Žξ˜Œ ξ˜Œξšƒξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜Œξšξ˜ξ˜…ξ˜Œξ˜Œ ξšŠξ˜Šξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜ ξ˜ˆξ˜ξš‚ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜ξš-
ξšξš†ξ™Ώ ξ˜Žξ˜Šξ˜‹ξšξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜ξšξš†ξ™Ώ ξ˜‹ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜†ξ˜Šξš„ξ˜Žξ˜Šξšξ˜Šξ˜‹ξ˜Œξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Œξ™Ώ ξ˜‹ξ˜ξ˜†, ξšξ˜ξšξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜‰ξ˜„ξ˜ξšξšξš†ξ™Ώ ξšξ˜ξšƒξšξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ƒξšξ˜„ξ˜Œξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξ˜
ξ˜ξ˜Šξ˜…ξ˜Œξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜Š-ξš„ξ˜Žξ˜Šξšξ˜Šξ˜‹ξ˜Œξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Œξ™Ώ ξ˜ˆξ˜Œξ˜ξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξšξ˜Šξ˜†ξ˜…ξ˜Œξš‚, ξ˜‰ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‹ξ˜ξ˜†ξšξ˜Šξ˜ ξšξ˜Šξ˜‰ξš†ξš‘ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξ˜ ξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξšξš€ ξš‹ξ˜Œξšξšξ˜Œ
ξ˜„ξš ξ˜ˆξ˜ξš‚ ξ˜Œξšƒξ˜‰ξšƒξ˜…ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜Šξ˜‹ ξ˜ξ˜Šξ™Ώξ˜†ξ˜ξšξ˜ξšξ˜Œξ˜ ξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜ξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Š ξ˜Žξ˜ξšξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜.
ξ˜–ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆ ξ˜ˆξ˜ξšξšξ˜Šξš‚ ξ˜†ξ˜ξšŠξ˜Šξ˜‡ξš†ξšƒβ€” ξ˜Œξ˜ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜ξ˜‡ξšˆ ξ˜Šξ˜ξšξ˜Šξ˜‰ξšξš†ξ˜ ξš„ξ˜Žξ˜Šξšξ˜Šξ˜‹ξ˜Œξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Œξ˜ ξ˜ˆξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜‹ξ˜Œξšξ˜ξšξ˜‡ξš†
ξšξ˜Šξ˜†ξ˜‹ξ˜Œξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξš€ ξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξšξš€ ξš‹ξ˜Œξšξšξ˜Œ ξšξ˜ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξš€. ξš‡ξ˜„ξš€ ξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œξš‹ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξš€ ξ˜…ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜Œ ξ˜†ξ˜ξš‘ξ˜ξšξš† ξšξ˜ξ˜ˆξ˜ξ˜‚ξ˜Œ:
β€’ ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‹ξ˜Šξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜ξšξš† ξ˜Šξ˜ξšξ˜Šξ˜‰ξšξš†ξ˜ ξ˜ξ˜ξšξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜‡ξš† ξ˜Šξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜‰ξ˜Šξš‚ ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξšξ˜Žξ˜‡ξšξ˜†ξš† ξš„ξ˜Žξ˜Šξšξ˜Šξ˜‹ξ˜Œξ˜Žξ˜Œ  
ξšξ˜Šξ˜†ξ˜‹ξ˜Œξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξš€ ξ˜‰ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜†ξ˜ ξ˜ξ˜Šξ˜…ξ˜Œξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜Š-ξš„ξ˜Žξ˜Šξšξ˜Šξ˜‹ξ˜Œξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Š ξ˜†ξ˜ξšξ˜‰ξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜Œξš€ ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜Œξ˜Šξšξ˜Šξ˜‰;
β€’ ξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜ξ˜ˆξ˜ξšξ˜ ξ˜Šξ˜…ξ˜ξšξ˜Žξ˜ ξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξšξš€ ξš‹ξ˜Œξšξšξ˜Œ ξšξ˜ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξš€ ξš‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜ξ˜‰ξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜‚ξšξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Š ξšξ˜ξ˜ˆξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Š
ξ˜Šξ˜Žξ˜†ξšξ˜ƒξ˜ ξ˜‰ξšƒξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜‰ξšξ˜ξšξ˜Œξ˜Œ ξ˜ξšƒξ˜ŠξšŠξš­ξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Œξš‚ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Œξ˜‹ξ˜Œ ξšξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜‹ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜‹ξ˜Œ;
β€’ ξ˜Šξšξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ˆξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜ξšξš† ξ˜Šξ˜ξšξ˜Šξ˜‰ξšξš†ξ˜ ξšξ˜ξšξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜‰ξ˜„ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξš€ ξšξ˜Šξ˜‰ξš†ξš‘ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξš€ ξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξšξš€ ξš‹ξ˜Œξšξšξ˜Œ ξšξ˜ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξš€.
 ξ™Ώξ˜Šξ˜ˆξ˜ ξ˜Œξ˜ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξš€ ξ˜Œξ˜ξšξ˜Šξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜ξšξš† ξ˜ŠξšŠξš­ξ˜ξšξ˜ξšξ˜‚ξšξš†ξ˜ ξ˜‹ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜ˆξš†. ξ˜šξšξšξ˜Šξ˜†ξ˜‹ξ˜ξ˜…ξ˜Œξ˜Šξš-
  ξ˜ξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜‰ξ˜Œξ˜„ξ˜Œ ξšξ˜ξšξ˜‚ξšξš†ξ˜ ξšξšξšŠξ˜„ξ˜Œξ˜Žξ˜ξ˜…ξ˜Œξ˜Œ, ξšξ˜Šξ˜†ξ˜‹ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œξ˜‰ξšξš†ξ˜ ξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ˜Žξšξ˜‹ξ˜ξšξ˜‡ξš† ξ˜Œξšƒξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œ-
ξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Œξ˜ ξ˜ˆξ˜ξšξšξš†ξ˜.
ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜Œξ˜ξ˜„ξš† ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜‡ξšˆξ˜Œ ξ˜‹ξ˜Šξ˜ƒξšξ˜‡ ξšŠξš†ξ˜‡ξšˆ ξ˜Œξšξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ξšξš† ξ˜Œξšƒ ξšξ˜Šξ˜„ξ˜ξšξšξš†  ξ˜Œξ˜ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξš€ξ˜‹
ξšξ˜Šξšƒ ξ˜ˆξ˜ξšξšξ˜Šξš‚ ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜‹ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œξ˜Žξ˜, ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜Ž ξ˜Œξšƒ ξšξšξ˜Šξ˜„ξšξ˜Šξ˜‹ξ˜Šξ˜‚ξ˜ξšξšξš†ξ˜‹ ξ˜ξšξ˜ξ˜…ξ˜Œξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜Œξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜‹ ξ˜ƒξ˜Šξ˜ξšξ˜ˆξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜ξšξšξš†ξ™Ώ
ξ˜Œξšƒξ˜‹ξšξšξ˜Œξ˜…ξ˜Œξšξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξš†ξ™Ώ ξ˜Šξ˜†ξ˜ƒξ˜ξšξ˜Šξ˜‰, ξ˜Šξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜ξšξšξš†ξ˜‹ ξšξ˜ξšƒξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ƒξšξ˜„ξ˜Œξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξ˜ ξ˜ξ˜Šξ˜…ξ˜Œξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜Š-ξš„ξ˜Žξ˜Šξšξ˜Š-
ξ˜‹ξ˜Œξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Š ξ˜†ξ˜ξšξ˜‰ξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜Œξš€ ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜Œξ˜Šξšξ˜Šξ˜‰.
ΠžΡ‚Ρ€Π°ΡΠ»Π΅Π²Π°Ρ структура экономики, ΠΏΡ€Π΅Π΄ΠΎΠΏΡ€Π΅Π΄Π΅Π»ΡΡŽΡ‰Π°Ρ ΠΏΠ°Ρ€Π°ΠΌΠ΅Ρ‚Ρ€Ρ‹ ΡΠΎΡ†ΠΈΠ°Π»ΡŒ-
Π½ΠΎ-экономичСского развития Ρ€Π΅Π³ΠΈΠΎΠ½ΠΎΠ²
ξš‡ξ˜„ξš€ ξ˜ŠξšŠξ˜ξ˜ξšξ˜ξ˜‚ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξš€ ξšŠξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Šξš€ξšξ˜Œξš€ ξ˜„ξš ξ˜ˆξ˜ξš‚ ξ˜ŠξšŠξššξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜‡ξ˜Œξ˜‰ξšξ˜Š ξšξ˜ξ˜ŠξšŠξ™Ώξ˜Šξ˜ˆξ˜Œξ˜‹ξ˜Š 
ξš„ξ˜Žξ˜Šξšξ˜Šξ˜‹ξ˜Œξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Œξ™Ώ ξšξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜Œξš‚, ξ˜ξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜ŠξšŠξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξšξš ξš­ξ˜Œξ™Ώ ξšξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜Šξ˜†ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξš  ξ˜Œξ™Ώ ξšξ˜Šξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜ξšŠξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ξš‚
ξ˜‰ξšƒ ξ˜†ξ˜ξšξ˜„ξ˜Œξ˜‚ξšξš†ξ™Ώ ξšŠξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜ξ™Ώ (, ξš‹ξ˜Œξ˜„ξšˆξ˜, ξ˜Šξ˜ˆξ˜ξš‹ξ˜ˆξ˜, ξšξ˜Šξ˜ˆξ˜ˆξ˜ξ˜†ξš‹ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξ˜Œ ξ˜Œξšƒ ξ˜ξ˜Šξ™Ώξ˜†ξ˜ξšξ˜ξšξ˜Œξ˜Œ ξšξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ˜†ξ˜Š-
ξ˜‰ξšˆξš€, ξšŠξš†ξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜Šξ˜‹ ξ˜Žξ˜Šξ˜‹ξšξ˜Šξ˜†ξ˜‡ξ˜, ξ˜Šξ˜‡ξ˜ˆξš†ξ™Ώξ˜, ξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ˜ξšξ˜ƒξ˜, ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜ξšξ˜ξšξ˜Šξ˜†ξ˜‡ξ˜ ξ˜Œξšƒξ˜ˆξ˜†.). ξš›ξ˜‡ξ˜Œ ξšξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜Œξš€ ξšξ˜Šξ˜†ξ˜‹ξ˜Œ-
ξ˜†ξšξš ξ˜‡ξ˜ξš€ ξ˜‰ξšƒ ξ˜†ξ˜ξšξšξ˜„ξšˆξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ ξ˜…ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜ξšξ˜ξšξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜‰ξ˜„ξ˜ξšξšξ˜Šξš‚, ξ˜Šξ˜†ξ˜ƒξ˜ξšξ˜Œξšξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜ξšξšξ˜Šξš‚ ξ˜ˆξ˜ξš€ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œ ξ˜„ξš ξ˜ˆξ˜ξš‚,
ξ˜‡.. ξ˜‰ξšƒ ξ˜†ξ˜ξšξšξ˜„ξšˆξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ ξ˜Œξ™Ώ ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξšξ˜ˆξ˜. ξ˜ξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜ξšξ˜Š ξšξ˜Šξ˜„ξ˜Šξš‹ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξš€ξ˜‹ ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξšξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜Šξš‚ ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜Šξ˜†ξ˜Œξ˜Œ ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜Œξ˜‹ξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œ
ξ˜˜ξ˜ˆξ˜ξ˜‹ξ˜ ξ˜ξ˜‹ξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜ ξ˜Œξšƒξš‡ξ˜ξ˜‰ξ˜Œξ˜ˆξ˜ ξ˜’ξ˜Œξ˜Žξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜ˆξ˜Š, ξ˜‰ξšƒξ˜Šξ˜ξšξ˜Šξ˜‰ξš ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜Œξ˜‹ξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œ ξ˜„ξš ξšŠξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Š ξšŠξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜ ξšξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜Šξš‹ξ˜ξš ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξšξ˜ˆ,
ξ˜‰ξ˜„ξ˜Šξš‹ξ˜ξšξšξš†ξš‚ ξ˜‰ξšƒ  ξ˜ˆξ˜ξšξšξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Š ξšŠξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜. ξš’ξ˜Šξš„ξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜‹ξš ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξšξ˜ˆ ξš€ξ˜‰ξ˜„ξš€ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ξš€ ξš„ξ˜Žξ˜Šξšξ˜Šξ˜‹ξ˜Œξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Šξš‚
ξ˜Šξ˜ξšξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜Šξš‚ ξšŠξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Šξš€ξšξ˜Œξš€. ξ˜›ξ˜Š  ξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Š ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξšξ˜ˆ  ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜Šξš‚, ξ˜ξšƒξ˜‡ξ˜†ξšξ˜ˆ ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜…ξ˜Œξ˜Šξšξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξš†ξš‚
ξ˜Œξšƒξš„ξšξšξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜‡ξ˜Œξ˜‰ξšξš†ξš‚. Π Π°Ρ†ΠΈΠΎΠ½Π°Π»ΡŒΠ½ΠΎΡΡ‚ΡŒ ξšξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ˆξšξ˜Šξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ ξ˜†ξ˜ξšξšξ˜‹ξšξšξš  ξ˜ŠξšŠξ˜Šξ˜ξšξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜ξšξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξšˆ ξ˜Œξšƒξ˜…ξ˜-
ξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Šξ˜ŠξšŠξ˜†ξ˜ξšξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξšˆ. ξ˜›ξ˜ξšξ˜†ξ˜Œξ˜‹ξ˜ξ˜†, ξšξ˜ξ˜…ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Šξ˜ŠξšŠξ˜†ξ˜ξšξšξš†ξ˜‹ ξš€ξ˜‰ξ˜„ξš€ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ξš€ ξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‰ ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‹ξš€ξš ξ˜Žξšξ˜Žξšξ˜†ξšξšξš†
ξ˜‰ξšƒξšξ˜Šξšξ˜ ξ˜‰ξ˜ξ˜‚ξšξ˜Šξš‚ ξ˜‹ξ˜ξ˜†ξšξ˜„ξ˜Šξ˜‡ξš† ξ˜‰ξšƒ ξšξ˜ξ˜ˆξ˜ξš‹ξ˜ˆξ˜ ξšξ˜Šξ˜„ξšξ˜‚ξ˜Œξ˜‡ξšˆ ξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξš‹ξ˜ξš‚, ξ˜Œξ˜„ξ˜Œ ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜Š ξšŠξ˜Šξ˜„ξšˆ-
ξš‘ξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Š ξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜†ξ˜ƒξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Š ξ˜…ξ˜ξšξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜ ξ˜‰ξšƒξ˜Šξ˜‡ξ˜ˆξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜ξšξšξ˜Šξ˜‹ ξ˜‹ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜Šξ˜‹ ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜, ξ˜Œξ˜„ξ˜Œ ξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜Œξšξ˜‰ξ˜Šξ˜ˆξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜Š ξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜ˆξšξ˜Žξ˜…ξ˜Œξ˜Œ,
ξšξ˜ξ˜‰ξ˜ξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ˜‹ξ˜Š  ξ˜‰ξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜ξšŠξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜ξšξšξ˜Šξš‚ ξšξ˜Šξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜ξšŠξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξš€ξ˜‹ξ˜Œ. Π­Ρ„Ρ„Π΅ΠΊΡ‚ΠΈΠ²Π½ΠΎΡΡ‚ΡŒ ξšξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ˆξšξ˜Šξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ ξšξ˜†ξ˜Š-
ξ˜ˆξšξ˜Žξ˜‡ξ˜Œξ˜‰ξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξšˆ ξ˜Œξšƒξ˜ξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜ŠξšŠξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξšˆ ξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œξ˜ƒξ˜ξ˜‡ξšˆ ξš‹ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‹ξš†ξ™Ώ ξ˜†ξ˜ξšξšξ˜„ξšˆξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜‰ ξ˜ξšƒξšξ˜ξ˜Œξ˜‹ξ˜ξšξšˆξš‘ξ˜Œξ˜‹ξ˜Œ -
ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜‹ξ˜Œ ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ξšξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜Šξ˜‰ ξ˜„ξ˜ŒξšŠξ˜Š ξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œξ˜ƒξ˜ξ˜‡ξšˆ ξšξ˜ξ˜Œξ˜„ξšξ˜‚ξš‘ξ˜Œξ™Ώ ξ˜†ξ˜ξšξšξ˜„ξšˆξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜‰ ξšξ˜†ξ˜Œ ξšξ˜ξ˜ˆξ˜ξšξšξ˜Šξ˜‹ ξ˜ŠξšŠξššξ˜ξ˜‹ξ˜
ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ξšξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜Šξ˜‰. ξ˜›ξ˜ξšξ˜†ξ˜Œξ˜‹ξ˜ξ˜†, ξš„ξšξšξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜‡ξ˜Œξ˜‰ξšξš†ξ˜‹ ξš€ξ˜‰ξ˜„ξš€ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ξš€ ξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜Œξšξ˜‰ξ˜Šξ˜ˆξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜Š ξ˜‡ξ˜Šξšξšξš† ξ˜‹ξ˜Œξšξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξš†ξ™Ώ
ξšξ˜ˆξ˜ŠξšŠξ˜†ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξš‚ ξ˜ξšƒξšξ˜ξ˜Œξ˜‹ξ˜ξšξšˆξš‘ξ˜Œξ˜‹ξ˜Œ ξšξ˜ˆξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξš†ξ˜‹ξ˜Œ ξšξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜‹ξ˜Œ; ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜Š ξ˜Šξšξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ˆξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜ξšξšξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Š
Государство, граТданскоС общСство ΠΈξ˜›ΡΡ‚Π°Π±ΠΈΠ»ΡŒΠ½ΠΎΡΡ‚ΡŒ 71
ξšξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Žξ˜ ξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Œ ξ˜‰ξš†ξ˜ξ˜Šξ˜Žξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Š ξ˜Žξ˜ξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜ ξ˜ξšƒξ˜Œξ˜ξšξ˜Šξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξ˜ξ˜‹ ξšξ˜ξšξ˜„ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜ξšξšξš†ξ™Ώ ξ˜ŠξšŠξššξ˜ξ˜‹ξ˜Šξ˜‰
ξšŠξš ξ˜ˆξš‹ξ˜ξ˜‡ξšξš†ξ™Ώ ξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ˆξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ ( ξšξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ξ™Ώξ˜Šξ˜ˆξ˜); ξšξ˜Šξ˜„ξšξ˜‚ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξ˜ ξšŠξ˜Šξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜ ξ˜‰ξš†ξ˜ξ˜Šξ˜Žξ˜Œξ™Ώ ξšξ˜ξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‰ ξ˜‹ξ˜Šξ˜„ξ˜Šξ˜Žξ˜
ξšξ˜†ξ˜Œ ξ˜Œξ˜‹ξ˜ξš ξš­ξ˜ξ˜‹ξ˜ξš€ ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ξšξ˜†ξ˜ξšξ˜Šξ˜‹ ξšξ˜Šξ˜‡ξ˜ξšξ˜…ξ˜Œξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜. ξ˜šξ˜‹ξ˜ξšξšξ˜Š ξš„ξ˜‡ξ˜Œ ξ˜ξ˜‰ξ˜Šξš‚ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜ξšƒβ€” ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜…ξ˜Œξ˜Šξšξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξšˆ
ξ˜Œξšƒξš„ξšξšξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜‡ξ˜Œξ˜‰ξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξšˆξšƒβ€” ξ˜ξ˜Šξšξ˜ˆξ˜ξš ξ˜‡ ξ˜Šξ˜ξšξ˜Šξ˜‰ξš ξ˜Žξ˜Šξšξ˜Žξšξ˜†ξ˜ξšξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜ξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜ŠξšŠξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œ  ξ˜‰ξ˜ξš‹ξšξ˜ξš‚ξš‘ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜Š -
ξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜ ξ˜ξšξšŠξššξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜‰ ξ˜‰ξšƒξšξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜Œξš€ξ™Ώ ξ˜†ξš†ξšξ˜Šξ˜‚ξšξ˜Šξš‚ ξš„ξ˜Žξ˜Šξšξ˜Šξ˜‹ξ˜Œξ˜Žξ˜Œ, ξ˜‰ξ˜ξ˜ˆξšξš­ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜Š ξ˜Žξšƒξšξ˜ξšξ˜ξš‘ξšξ˜Šξš‚, ξšŠξ˜ξšξšξšŠξš†-
ξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜‚ξšξ˜Šξš‚ ξ™Ώξ˜Šξšξš€ξš‚ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜ξšξšξ˜Šξš‚ ξ˜ˆξ˜ξš€ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œ.
ξšžξ˜‡ξ˜ŠξšŠξš† ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξšξ˜ˆ ξšŠξš†ξ˜„ ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜…ξ˜Œξ˜Šξšξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξš†ξ˜‹ ξ˜Œξšƒ ξš„ξšξšξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜‡ξ˜Œξ˜‰ξšξš†ξ˜‹,  ξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ˜„ξš‹ξ˜ξš ξšŠξš†ξ˜‡ξšˆ ξ˜Šξ˜†ξ˜ƒξ˜ξšξ˜Œ-
ξšξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜ξš ξ˜Œξšƒ  ξ˜ξ˜Šξ˜Šξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξšξš ξš­ξ˜Œξ˜‹ ξ˜ŠξšŠξ˜†ξ˜ξšξ˜Šξ˜‹. ξ˜Ÿξšƒ ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Šξš‚ ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜ξšξ˜,  ξ˜’ξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Œξš€, ξš„ξ˜‡ξ˜Š
ξ˜ŠξšŠξ˜ξ˜ξšξ˜ξ˜‚ξ˜Œξ˜‡ξšˆ ξ˜Žξ˜†ξ˜ξš‚ξšξ˜ ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜Šξš‹ξšξ˜Š, ξšξ˜‚ξ˜Œξ˜‡ξš†ξ˜‰ξ˜ξš€  ξ˜ŠξšŠξš‘ξ˜Œξ˜†ξšξšξš  ξ˜ƒξ˜ξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜†ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Žξšξš  ξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜‡ξš€ξš‹ξ˜ξš-
ξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξšˆ, ξ˜ξšξš­ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜ξšξšξšξš  ξšξ˜†ξ˜Œξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜ˆξšξ˜Š-ξ˜Žξ˜„ξ˜Œξ˜‹ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Žξšξš , ξ˜ˆξ˜ξ˜‹ξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜†ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Žξšξš , ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ξšξ˜†ξ˜ξšξšξš 
ξ˜ˆξ˜Œξšξšξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜ξšξ˜…ξ˜Œξ˜ξ˜…ξ˜Œξš , ξ˜ξšƒ ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜Žξš‹ξ˜ ξ˜Žξ˜†ξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜Œξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Žξšξš  ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ™Ώξšξ˜Œξ˜Žξ˜Š-ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ™Ώξšξ˜Šξ˜„ξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Œξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Žξšξš  ξ˜Šξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξšˆ
ξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜‹ξš†ξš‘ξ˜„ξ˜ξšξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œ ξ˜Œξšƒξ˜ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Š ξ™Ώξ˜Šξšξš€ξš‚ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜ ξ˜‹ξšξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Œξ™Ώ ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜Œξ˜Šξšξ˜Šξ˜‰ (ξ˜™ξ˜Šξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜, 2ξš‰24; ξ˜’ξ˜Šξ˜ˆ-
, 2ξš‰23). ξ˜›ξ˜ξ˜‹ξ˜ξ˜„ξš†ξ˜ ξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜†ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξ˜‚ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξš€ ξ˜ξ˜Šξ˜…ξ˜Œξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜Š-ξš„ξ˜Žξ˜Šξšξ˜Šξ˜‹ξ˜Œξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Š ξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ ξ˜ŠξšŠξšξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜„ξ˜-
ξšξš† ξ˜Œξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜†ξ˜Œξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Œ ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜Šξš‹ξ˜Œξ˜‰ξš‘ξ˜Œξ˜‹ξ˜Œξ˜ξš€ ξ˜ˆξ˜Œξ˜ξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξšξ˜Šξ˜†ξ˜…ξ˜Œξš€ξ˜‹ξ˜Œ ξ˜Šξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜‰ξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Š ξ˜†ξ˜ξšξ˜‰ξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜Œξš€ ξšξ˜ξ˜…ξ˜Œξ˜Š-
ξšξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜Šξš‚ ξš„ξ˜Žξ˜Šξšξ˜Šξ˜‹ξ˜Œξ˜Žξ˜Œ.
ξ˜—ξ˜ξšξ˜Šξ˜‰ξšξ˜Šξš‚ ξšξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ˆξšξ˜Šξ˜ξš†ξ˜„ξ˜Žξ˜Šξš‚ ξšξ˜Šξ˜†ξ˜‹ξ˜Œξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξš€ ξ˜‰ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜†ξ˜ ξ˜ξ˜Šξ˜…ξ˜Œξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜Š-ξš„ξ˜Žξ˜Šξšξ˜Šξ˜‹ξ˜Œξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Š-
ξ˜ƒξ˜Š ξ˜†ξ˜ξšξ˜‰ξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜Œξš€ ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜Œξ˜Šξšξ˜ ξš€ξ˜‰ξ˜„ξš€ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ξš€ ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜Š ξ˜Šξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜‰ξ˜ξš€ ξšξ˜ξšξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜‰ξ˜„ξ˜ξšξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξšˆ, ξ˜‡.. ξ˜‰ξ˜Œξ˜ˆξš† ξš„ξ˜Žξ˜Šξšξ˜Š-
ξ˜‹ξ˜Œξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Šξš‚ ξ˜ˆξ˜ξš€ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œ, ξšξ˜†ξ˜Œξšξ˜Šξ˜ξš€ξš­ξ˜Œξ˜ ξšξ˜ξ˜ŒξšŠξ˜Šξ˜„ξšˆξš‘ξ˜Œξš‚ ξ˜‰ξ˜Žξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜ˆ ξ˜‰ξšƒξ˜ξ˜Šξšξ˜ˆξ˜ξšξ˜Œξ˜ ξ˜ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜Šξ˜Žξšξšξšξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Š
ξ˜‰ξšξšξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜ξšξšξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜Š ξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜ˆξšξ˜Žξ˜‡ξ˜, ξšξ˜ξšƒξ˜Žξ˜Šξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜†ξš†ξ™Ώ ξ˜‰ξšƒξšŠξ˜Šξ˜„ξšˆξš‘ξ˜ξš‚ ξ˜‹ξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜ ξ˜ξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜‚ξ˜ξšξš† ξšξ˜ξšξš€ξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξšˆ -
ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξš€ ξ˜Œξšƒξ˜Œξšξ˜‰ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œξ˜…ξ˜Œξ˜Œ. ξ˜—ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜‰ξ˜ξš€ ξšξ˜ξšξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜‰ξ˜„ξ˜ξšξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξšˆ ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜ˆξš†ξ˜‰ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ξš€ ξ˜Œξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜†ξ˜Œξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Œ,
ξšξ˜ξšƒξ˜Šξ˜ξšξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜ ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜Œξšξšξ˜ξ˜‹ξš†ξ™Ώ ξšξ˜†ξ˜Œξ˜Šξ˜†ξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜‰ ξ˜ξ˜Šξ˜…ξ˜Œξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜Š-ξš„ξ˜Žξ˜Šξšξ˜Šξ˜‹ξ˜Œξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Šξš‚ ξšξ˜Šξ˜„ξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜Œξ˜Žξ˜Œ ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜-
ξšξš† ξ˜Œξšƒ ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜Œξ˜Šξšξ˜Šξ˜‰. ξ˜—ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜‰ξ˜ξš€ ξšξ˜ξšξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜‰ξ˜„ξ˜ξšξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξšˆ ξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξš€ξ˜‰ξ˜„ξš€ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ξš€ ξ˜‰ξšƒ ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξšξ˜Žξ˜‡ξšξ˜†ξ˜ ξ˜‰ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Š
ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜Œξ˜Šξšξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Š ξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜ˆξšξ˜Žξ˜‡ξ˜ (ξ˜Ÿξ˜’ξš’), ξ˜‰ξš†ξ˜†ξ˜ξš‹ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‹ξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Š ξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜ξš ξ˜‰ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξšξš  ξ˜ˆξ˜ŠξšŠξ˜ξ˜‰ξ˜„ξ˜ξšξšξšξš  ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜Œ-
ξ˜‹ξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξšˆ. ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξšξ˜Žξ˜‡ξšξ˜†ξ˜ ξ˜‰ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜Šξš‚ ξ˜ˆξ˜ŠξšŠξ˜ξ˜‰ξ˜„ξ˜ξšξšξ˜Šξš‚ ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜Œξ˜‹ξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œ ξ˜‰ξšƒ ξ˜†ξ˜ξšξ˜†ξ˜ξšξ˜ ξ˜‰ξ˜Œξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ˜‰ ξš„ξ˜Žξ˜Šξšξ˜Šξ˜‹ξ˜Œξ˜‚ξ˜-
ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Šξš‚ ξ˜ˆξ˜ξš€ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œ ξšξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ˆξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜‰ξ˜„ξ˜ξšξ˜ ξ˜‰ξšƒξ˜‡ξ˜ξšŠξ˜„ξ˜Œξ˜…ξ˜ 1.
ξ˜œξ˜ξšŠξ˜„ξ˜Œξ˜…ξ˜ 1.
ξ˜—ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜‰ξ˜ξš€ ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξšξ˜Žξ˜‡ξšξ˜†ξ˜ ξ˜‰ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜Šξš‚ ξ˜ˆξ˜ŠξšŠξ˜ξ˜‰ξ˜„ξ˜ξšξšξ˜Šξš‚ ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜Œξ˜‹ξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œ (2ξš‰22 ξ˜ƒ., ξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜…ξ˜ξšξ˜‡ ξ˜Žξšƒξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜ƒξš)1
Table 1.
Industry structure ofξšƒgross value added (2ξš‰22, percent ofξšƒtotal)
НаимСнованиС Российская
ЀСдСрация Π”Π€Πž
ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Šξ˜, ξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜ξšξ˜Šξ˜ ξ™Ώξ˜Šξšξš€ξš‚ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜Š, ξ˜Šξ™Ώξ˜Šξ˜‡ξ˜, ξ˜†ξš†ξšŠξ˜Šξ˜„ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜Š ξ˜Œξšƒξ˜†ξš†ξšŠξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜Šξ˜ˆ-
ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜Š 4,5 5,9
ξš‡ξ˜ŠξšŠξš†ξ˜‚ξ˜ ξšξ˜Šξ˜„ξ˜ξšξšξš†ξ™Ώ ξ˜Œξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Šξšξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‹ξš†ξ™Ώ 14,4 31,3
ξ˜—ξšŠξ˜†ξ˜ξšŠξ˜ξ˜‡ξš†ξ˜‰ξ˜ξš ξš­ξ˜Œξ˜ ξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜Œξšξ˜‰ξ˜Šξ˜ˆξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜ 17,2 4,9
ξ˜—ξšŠξ˜ξ˜ξšξ˜ξ˜‚ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξ˜ ξš„ξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜Œξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Šξš‚ ξš„ξšξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜ƒξ˜Œξ˜ξš‚, ξ˜ƒξ˜ξšξ˜Šξ˜‹ 2,5 2,9
ξ˜Ÿξ˜Šξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ˜ξšξ˜ξšŠξš‹ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξ˜; ξ˜‰ξ˜Šξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ˜Šξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜ξ˜ˆξ˜ξšξ˜Œξ˜ 0,6 0,4
ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜Š 5,1 7,0
1 Π’Π°Π±Π»ΠΈΡ†Ρ‹ ΠΈξ˜› рисунки (Π³Ρ€Π°Ρ„ΠΈΠΊΠΈ) составлСны Π°Π²Ρ‚ΠΎΡ€ΠΎΠΌ ΠΏΠΎξ˜› Π΄Π°Π½Π½Ρ‹ΠΌ Росстата (Π Π΅Π³ΠΈΠΎΠ½Ρ‹ России.
Π‘ΠΎΡ†ΠΈΠ°Π»ΡŒΠ½ΠΎ-экономичСскиС ΠΏΠΎΠΊΠ°Π·Π°Ρ‚Π΅Π»ΠΈ. 2023: Π‘Ρ‚Π°Ρ‚. сб. М., 2023. 1126 с.).
Society andξ˜›Security Insights β„– 3 2024 72
НаимСнованиС Российская
ЀСдСрация Π”Π€Πž
ξ˜œξ˜Šξ˜†ξ˜ƒξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜„ξš€ ξ˜Šξšξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜ξš€ ξ˜Œξšƒξ˜†ξ˜Šξšξšξ˜Œξ˜‚ξšξ˜ξš€; ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜‹ξ˜Šξšξ˜‡ ξ˜ξ˜‰ξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜ξšξ˜ξšξ˜Šξ˜†ξ˜‡ξšξš†ξ™Ώ
ξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ˆξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ ξ˜Œξšƒξ˜‹ξ˜Šξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜…ξ˜Œξ˜Žξ˜„ξ˜Šξ˜‰ 14,5 8,5
ξ˜œξ˜†ξ˜ξšξ˜ξšξ˜Šξ˜†ξ˜‡ξ˜Œξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜Žξ˜ ξ˜Œξšƒξ™Ώξ˜†ξ˜ξšξ˜ξšξ˜Œξ˜ 6,5 10,0
ξš‡ξ˜ξš€ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξšˆ ξ˜ƒξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œξšξ˜Œξ˜… ξ˜Œξšƒξšξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ˆξšξ˜†ξ˜Œξš€ξ˜‡ξ˜Œξš‚ ξ˜ŠξšŠξš­ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜ 0,9 0,9
ξš‡ξ˜ξš€ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξšˆ ξ˜‰ξšƒξ˜ŠξšŠξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œ ξ˜Œξšξšξ˜Šξ˜†ξ˜‹ξ˜ξ˜…ξ˜Œξ˜Œ ξ˜Œξšƒξ˜ξ˜‰ξš€ξšξ˜Œ 3,2 1,2
ξš‡ξ˜ξš€ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξšˆ ξšξ˜Œξšξ˜ξšξ˜ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜ξš€ ξ˜Œξšƒξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜ξ™Ώξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜ξš€ 0,6 0,1
ξš‡ξ˜ξš€ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξšˆ ξšξ˜Šξšƒξ˜Šξšξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜…ξ˜Œξš€ξ˜‹ ξ˜ξšƒξšξ˜ξ˜ˆξ˜‰ξ˜Œξš‹ξ˜Œξ˜‹ξš†ξ˜‹ ξ˜Œξ˜‹ξšξš­ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜Šξ˜‹ 10,5 6,7
ξš‡ξ˜ξš€ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξšˆ ξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξšξ˜ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Œξ˜Šξšξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜ξš€, ξšξ˜ξšξ˜‚ξšξ˜ξš€ ξ˜Œξšƒξ˜‡ξ˜ξ™Ώξšξ˜Œξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜ξš€ 4,3 1,5
ξš‡ξ˜ξš€ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξšˆ ξ˜ξ˜ˆξ˜‹ξ˜Œξšξ˜Œξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œξ˜‰ξšξ˜ξš€ ξ˜Œξšƒξ˜ξ˜Šξšξšξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξšξš ξš­ξ˜Œξ˜ ξ˜ˆξ˜Šξšξ˜Šξ˜„-
ξšξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξš†ξ˜ ξšξ˜ξ˜„ξšξ˜ƒξ˜Œ 2,3 1,9
ξ˜‘ξ˜Šξ˜ξšξ˜ˆξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜ξšξšξ˜Šξ˜ ξšξšξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜‰ξ˜„ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξ˜ ξ˜Œξšƒξ˜ŠξšŠξ˜ξ˜ξšξ˜ξ˜‚ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξ˜ ξ˜‰ξ˜Šξ˜ξšξšξ˜Šξš‚ -
ξšξ˜ξ˜ξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œ; ξ˜ξ˜Šξ˜…ξ˜Œξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜Šξ˜ ξ˜ŠξšŠξ˜ξ˜ξšξ˜ξ˜‚ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξ˜ 5,0 7,6
ξ˜—ξšŠξ˜†ξ˜ξšξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξ˜ 2,7 3,4
ξš‡ξ˜ξš€ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξšˆ ξ˜‰ξšƒξ˜ŠξšŠξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œ ξšξ˜ˆξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜‰ξ˜Šξ˜Šξ™Ώξ˜†ξ˜ξšξ˜ξšξ˜Œξš€ ξ˜Œξšƒξ˜ξ˜Šξ˜…ξ˜Œξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξš†ξ™Ώ ξšξ˜ξ˜„ξšξ˜ƒ 3,8 4,6
ξš‡ξ˜ξš€ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξšˆ ξ˜‰ξšƒξ˜ŠξšŠξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œ ξ˜Žξšξ˜„ξšˆξ˜‡ξšξ˜†ξš†, ξ˜ξšξ˜Šξ˜†ξ˜‡ξ˜, ξ˜Šξ˜†ξ˜ƒξ˜ξšξ˜Œξšξ˜ξ˜…ξ˜Œξ˜Œ
ξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ˜ξšξ˜ƒξ˜ ξ˜Œξšƒξ˜†ξ˜ξšξ˜‰ξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜‚ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξš‚ 0,9 0,8
ξš’ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜‰ξ˜„ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξ˜ ξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜‚ξ˜Œξ™Ώ ξ˜‰ξ˜Œξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ˜‰ ξšξ˜ξ˜„ξšξ˜ƒ 0,5 0,4
 ξ˜…ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜Šξ˜‹ ξšξ˜Šξšƒξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜ξšξ˜ ξšξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ŠξšŠξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜ˆξ˜ξš ξš­ξ˜ξš€ ξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ˜„ξš€ ξ˜‰ξšƒξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜Œξšξ˜‰ξ˜Šξ˜ˆξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜ ξ˜‰ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Š ξ˜ŠξšŠξš­ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜ξš-
ξšξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Š ξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜ˆξšξ˜Žξ˜‡ξ˜ ξšξ˜†ξ˜Œξ™Ώξ˜Šξ˜ˆξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜ξš€ ξšξ˜ξšƒξ˜ŠξšŠξ˜†ξ˜ξšŠξ˜ξ˜‡ξš†ξ˜‰ξ˜ξš ξš­ξ˜Œξ˜ ξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜Œξšξ˜‰ξ˜Šξ˜ˆξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜, ξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜†ξ˜ƒξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜„ξš  ξ˜Œξšƒξ˜ˆξ˜ŠξšŠξš†ξ˜‚ξš
ξšξ˜Šξ˜„ξ˜ξšξšξš†ξ™Ώ ξ˜Œξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Šξšξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‹ξš†ξ™Ώ, ξ˜‰ξšƒξš‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜ξ˜‰ξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜‚ξšξ˜Šξ˜‹ ξ˜Šξ˜Žξ˜†ξšξ˜ƒξ˜ξšƒβ€” ξšξ˜ξšƒξ˜ˆξ˜ŠξšŠξš†ξ˜‚ξš ξšξ˜Šξ˜„ξ˜ξšξšξš†ξ™Ώ -
ξ˜ξ˜‹ξš†ξ™Ώ, ξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜†ξ˜ƒξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜„ξš , ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜ξšξ˜ξšξ˜Šξ˜†ξ˜‡ξ˜Œξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜Žξš ξ˜Œξšƒξ™Ώξ˜†ξ˜ξšξ˜ξšξ˜Œξ˜.
ξ˜—ξšŠξ˜†ξ˜ξšŠξ˜ξ˜‡ξš†ξ˜‰ξ˜ξš ξš­ξ˜Œξ˜ ξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜Œξšξ˜‰ξ˜Šξ˜ˆξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜ ξšξ˜ξšƒ ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜†ξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜†ξ˜Œξ˜Œ ξ˜ˆξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜ξ˜‰ξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜‚ξšξš†ξ™Ώ ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜Œξ˜Šξšξ˜Šξ˜‰
ξ˜†ξ˜ξšξ˜‰ξ˜Œξ˜‡ξš† ξ˜‰ξšƒξšξšξ˜ξ˜‚ξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜Š ξ˜‹ξ˜ξšξšˆξš‘ξ˜ξš‚ ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ξšξ˜ξšξ˜Œ, ξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜‹ ξ˜‰ξšƒξ˜…ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜Šξ˜‹ ξšξ˜Šξšƒξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜ξšξ˜. ξ˜œξ˜ξ˜Žξš‹ξ˜ ξ˜‰ξšƒξ˜†ξ˜ξšξš†
ξ˜‹ξ˜ξšξšˆξš‘ξšξš  ξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ˜„ξš  ξ˜‰ξšƒξ˜Ÿξ˜’ξš’  ξ˜Œξ˜‹ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ ξ˜ˆξ˜ŠξšŠξ˜ξ˜‰ξ˜„ξ˜ξšξšξ˜ξš€ ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜Œξ˜‹ξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξšˆ, ξ˜ξ˜Šξšξ˜ˆξ˜ξšξšξ˜ξš€ ξ˜‰ξšƒξ˜ŠξšŠξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œ
ξ˜Œξšξšξ˜Šξ˜†ξ˜‹ξ˜ξ˜…ξ˜Œξ˜Œ ξ˜Œξšƒξ˜ξ˜‰ξš€ξšξ˜Œ, ξšξ˜Œξšξ˜ξšξ˜ξ˜Šξ˜‰ ξ˜Œξšƒξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜ξ™Ώξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξš€, ξ˜‰ξšƒξšξ˜ξšξ˜‚ξšξ˜Š-ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ™Ώξšξ˜Œξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Šξš‚ ξ˜ξšξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜.
ξ˜šξšξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ ξ˜‰ξš†ξšξš†ξ˜‰ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξšξ˜Žξ˜‡ξšξ˜†ξ˜ ξšξ˜ξšξš€ξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œ ξ˜‰ξšƒξ˜Šξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜‰ξ˜Šξ˜‹ ξ˜†ξ˜ξšξ˜†ξ˜ξšξ˜. ξ˜™ξ˜ξ˜Ž ξ˜‰ξšƒξ˜…ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜Šξ˜‹
ξšξ˜Šξšƒξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜ξšξ˜, ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜Ž ξ˜Œξšƒξ˜‰ξšƒξ˜ˆξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜ξ˜‰ξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜‚ξšξš†ξ™Ώ ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜Œξ˜Šξšξ˜ξ™Ώ ξšξ˜Šξšƒξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ˜„ξ˜ ξšξ˜ξšξš€ξ˜‡ξš†ξ™Ώ ξ˜‰ξšƒξ˜ŠξšŠξš­ξ˜ξš‚ ξ˜Œξ™Ώ ξ˜‚ξ˜Œξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜ξš-
ξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œ ξ˜„ξ˜Œξ˜ˆξ˜Œξ˜†ξšξš ξ˜‡ ξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜†ξ˜ƒξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜„ξš€ ξ˜Œξšƒξ˜ˆξ˜†ξšξ˜ƒξ˜Œξ˜ ξ˜‰ξ˜Œξ˜ˆξš† ξ˜ˆξ˜ξš€ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œ. ξ˜—ξšŠξ˜†ξ˜ξšŠξ˜ξ˜‡ξš†ξ˜‰ξ˜ξš ξš­ξ˜Œξ˜ ξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜Œξš-
ξ˜‰ξ˜Šξ˜ˆξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜ ξ˜‰ξšƒξš‡ξš–ξ˜— ξ˜Žξ˜Šξšξ˜…ξ˜ξšξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜Œξ˜†ξšξš ξ˜‡ ξ˜‰ξšƒξ˜ξ˜ξšŠξ˜ 8,ξš‰% ξšξ˜ξšξš€ξ˜‡ξš†ξ™Ώ, ξ˜‰ξšƒξ˜‡ξ˜Š ξ˜‰ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜‹ξš€  ξšξ˜Šξšƒξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜ξšξ˜ξšƒβ€”
14,ξš‰% (ξ˜‡ξ˜ξšŠξ˜„. 2).
ξ˜›ξ˜ξ˜‰ξš†ξ˜ξ˜Šξ˜Žξ˜Œξš‚ ξšξ˜ˆξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξš†ξš‚ ξ˜‰ξ˜ξ˜ ξšξ˜ξšξš€ξ˜‡ξš†ξ™Ώ ξ˜‰ξšƒξ˜Šξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜Œ ξ˜ˆξ˜ŠξšŠξš†ξ˜‚ξ˜Œ ξšξ˜Šξ˜„ξ˜ξšξšξš†ξ™Ώ ξ˜Œξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Šξšξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‹ξš†ξ™Ώ
ξ˜‹ξ˜Šξš‹ξšξ˜Š ξ˜ŠξšŠξššξš€ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξ˜‡ξšˆ ξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜ŠξšŠξ˜ξšξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξš€ξ˜‹ξ˜Œ ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Šξš‚ ξ˜‹ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ˜„ξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Œξ˜Œ, ξšξ˜Šξšƒξ˜Žξ˜Šξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜†ξ˜Šξš‚ ξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ξšˆ
ξšξ˜ξšξš€ξ˜‡ξš†ξ™Ώ ξ˜Šξ˜‡ξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜ξš€ ξ˜Žξšƒξ˜Žξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜Šξ˜†ξ˜Œξ˜Œ Β«ξš‡ξ˜†ξšξ˜ƒξ˜Œξ˜ ξ˜‰ξ˜Œξ˜ˆξš† ξ˜ˆξ˜ξš€ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ŒΒ». ξ˜ξ˜ξš‹ξ˜ˆξš ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜‹ ξ˜‰ξšƒξš‡ξš–ξ˜—
ξšξ˜ξšƒξ˜ˆξ˜ŠξšŠξš†ξ˜‚ξš ξšξ˜Šξ˜„ξ˜ξšξšξš†ξ™Ώ ξ˜Œξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Šξšξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‹ξš†ξ™Ώ ξšξ˜†ξ˜Œξ™Ώξ˜Šξ˜ˆξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜ξš€ ξ˜‰ξšƒξ˜†ξ˜ξšξš† ξšŠξ˜Šξ˜„ξšˆξš‘ξ˜ξš€ ξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ˜„ξš€ ξšξ˜ξšξš€ξ˜‡ξš†ξ™Ώ, ξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜‹
ξ˜‰ξšƒξ˜…ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜Šξ˜‹ ξšξ˜Šξšƒξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜ξšξ˜.
ξ˜•ξšξ˜ξ˜‚ξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξšξš  ξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ˜„ξš  ξ˜‰ξšƒ ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξšξ˜Žξ˜‡ξšξ˜†ξ˜ ξšξ˜ξšξš€ξ˜‡ξš†ξ™Ώ ξ˜‰ξšƒ ξ˜ˆξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜ξ˜‰ξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜‚ξšξš†ξ™Ώ ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜Œξ˜Šξšξ˜ξ™Ώ -
ξšξ˜Œξ˜‹ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜ξšξ˜ξšξ˜Šξ˜†ξ˜‡ξ˜Œξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜Žξ˜ ξ˜Œξšƒξ™Ώξ˜†ξ˜ξšξ˜ξšξ˜Œξ˜. ξš›ξ˜‡ξ˜Š ξ˜ŠξšŠξšξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜„ξ˜ξšξ˜Š ξšξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜Œξ˜‚ξ˜Œξ˜ξ˜‹ ξš‘ξ˜Œξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜Žξ˜Šξš‚ ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œ
ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜ξšξ˜ξšξ˜Šξ˜†ξ˜‡ξ˜ξšƒβ€” ξ˜‰ξ˜Šξ˜ˆξšξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Š (21 ξ˜‹ξ˜Šξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Šξš‚ ξ˜Œξšƒ17 ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜‚ξšξš†ξ™Ώ ξšξ˜Šξ˜†ξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜‰), ξ˜‰ξ˜Šξšξ˜ˆξšξš‘ξšξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Š (8ξš‰ ξ˜ξš„ξ˜†ξ˜Šξšξ˜Šξ˜†-
Государство, граТданскоС общСство ΠΈξ˜›ΡΡ‚Π°Π±ΠΈΠ»ΡŒΠ½ΠΎΡΡ‚ΡŒ 73
ξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜‰ ξ˜Œξšƒξ˜ξš„ξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜ˆξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜‹ξ˜Šξ˜‰), ξš‹ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜ξšξšξ˜Šξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ˜†ξ˜Šξš‹ξšξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Š ( ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜†ξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜†ξ˜Œξ˜Œ ξš‡ξš–ξ˜— ξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξ™Ώξ˜Šξ˜ˆξš€ξ˜‡ ξ˜ƒξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜‰ξšξš†ξ˜ -
ξšξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜‰ξ˜„ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξš€ ξ˜œξ˜†ξ˜ξšξ˜ξ˜ξ˜ŒξšŠξ˜Œξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Šξš‚ ξ˜‹ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜Œξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜Œ, ξš‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜ξ˜‰ξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜‚ξšξ˜Šξš‚ ξ˜Œξšƒξ˜•ξ˜ξšŠξ˜ξš‚ξ˜Žξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Šξš‚ ξš‹ξ˜-
ξ˜„ξ˜ξšξšξš†ξ™Ώ ξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜ƒ) ξ˜Œξšƒξ˜ξ˜‰ξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜‹ξ˜ŠξšŠξ˜Œξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Š (ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ξšˆ ξ˜ξ˜‰ξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜ƒ ξ˜ŠξšŠξš­ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜Š ξšξ˜Šξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξš€ξšƒξ˜ξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜‰ξ˜„ξš€ξ˜ξ˜‡
ξ˜Šξ˜Žξ˜Šξ˜„ξ˜Š 13ξš‰ ξ˜‡ξš†ξ˜. ξ˜Žξ˜‹). ξ˜™ξ˜ξ˜Ž ξ˜Œξšƒξ˜‰ξšƒξ˜…ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜Šξ˜‹ ξšξ˜Šξšƒξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜ξšξ˜, ξšξ˜ξšƒξš‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜ξ˜‹ ξ˜Ÿξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜Žξ˜ ξ˜ξšξš­ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜ξšξšξ˜ξš€
ξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ˜„ξš€ ξšξ˜ξšξš€ξ˜‡ξš†ξ™Ώ ξšξ˜†ξ˜Œξšξ˜ξ˜ˆξ˜„ξ˜ξš‹ξ˜Œξ˜‡ ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξš, ξ˜‚ξ˜‡ξ˜Š ξ˜ξ˜‰ξš€ξšξ˜ξšξ˜Š ξ˜ξšƒ ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜Œξšξ˜ξ˜…ξ˜Œξ˜ξš‚ ξ˜Žξ˜†ξšξšξšξ˜Š-
ξ˜‹ξ˜ξ˜ξš‘ξ˜‡ξ˜ξšŠξšξš†ξ™Ώ ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜Œξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Œξ™Ώ ξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜‰. ξ˜Ÿξšƒξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜Šξ˜‹ ξ˜Šξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜‰ξ˜ξš€ ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξšξ˜Žξ˜‡ξšξ˜†ξ˜ ξšξ˜ξšξš€-
ξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œ ξ˜‰ξšƒξ˜…ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜Šξ˜‹ ξšξ˜Šξšƒξ˜’ξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Œξ˜Œ ξ˜Œξšƒξ˜‰ξšƒξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜Œξ˜Šξšξ˜ξ™Ώ ξš‡ξš–ξ˜— ξ˜ξ™Ώξ˜Šξš‹ξ˜.
ξ˜œξ˜ξšŠξ˜„ξ˜Œξ˜…ξ˜ 2.
ξ˜—ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜‰ξ˜ξš€ ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξšξ˜Žξ˜‡ξšξ˜†ξ˜ ξšξ˜ξšξš€ξ˜‡ξš†ξ™Ώ ξ˜‰ξšƒξš„ξ˜Žξ˜Šξšξ˜Šξ˜‹ξ˜Œξ˜Žξ˜ (2ξš‰22 ξ˜ƒ.,
ξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜…ξ˜ξšξ˜‡ ξ˜Šξ˜‡ξšƒξ˜ŠξšŠξš­ξ˜ξš‚ ξ˜‚ξ˜Œξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜ξšξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œ ξšξ˜ξšξš€ξ˜‡ξš†ξ™Ώ)
Table 2.
e sectoral structure ofξšƒthe employed inξšƒthe economy
(2ξš‰22, percent ofξšƒthe total number ofξšƒemployed)
НаимСнованиС Российская
ЀСдСрация Π”Π€Πž
ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Šξ˜, ξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜ξšξ˜Šξ˜ ξ™Ώξ˜Šξšξš€ξš‚ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜Š, ξ˜Šξ™Ώξ˜Šξ˜‡ξ˜, ξ˜†ξš†ξšŠξ˜Šξ˜„ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜Š ξ˜Œξšƒξ˜†ξš†ξšŠξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜Šξ˜ˆ-
ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜Š 6,3 6,4
ξš‡ξ˜ŠξšŠξš†ξ˜‚ξ˜ ξšξ˜Šξ˜„ξ˜ξšξšξš†ξ™Ώ ξ˜Œξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Šξšξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‹ξš†ξ™Ώ 1,7 4,1
ξ˜—ξšŠξ˜†ξ˜ξšŠξ˜ξ˜‡ξš†ξ˜‰ξ˜ξš ξš­ξ˜Œξ˜ ξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜Œξšξ˜‰ξ˜Šξ˜ˆξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜ 14,0 8,0
ξ˜—ξšŠξ˜ξ˜ξšξ˜ξ˜‚ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξ˜ ξš„ξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜Œξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Šξš‚ ξš„ξšξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜ƒξ˜Œξ˜ξš‚, ξ˜ƒξ˜ξšξ˜Šξ˜‹ 2,2 3,8
ξ˜Ÿξ˜Šξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ˜ξšξ˜ξšŠξš‹ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξ˜; ξ˜‰ξ˜Šξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ˜Šξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜ξ˜ˆξ˜ξšξ˜Œξ˜ 1,0 0,9
ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜Š 9,2 9,0
ξ˜œξ˜Šξ˜†ξ˜ƒξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜„ξš€ ξ˜Šξšξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜ξš€ ξ˜Œξšƒξ˜†ξ˜Šξšξšξ˜Œξ˜‚ξšξ˜ξš€; ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜‹ξ˜Šξšξ˜‡ ξ˜ξ˜‰ξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜ξšξ˜ξšξ˜Šξ˜†ξ˜‡ξšξš†ξ™Ώ
ξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ˆξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ ξ˜Œξšƒξ˜‹ξ˜Šξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜…ξ˜Œξ˜Žξ˜„ξ˜Šξ˜‰ 18,6 17,1
ξ˜œξ˜†ξ˜ξšξ˜ξšξ˜Šξ˜†ξ˜‡ξ˜Œξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜Žξ˜ ξ˜Œξšƒξ™Ώξ˜†ξ˜ξšξ˜ξšξ˜Œξ˜ 8,1 9,8
ξš‡ξ˜ξš€ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξšˆ ξ˜ƒξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œξšξ˜Œξ˜… ξ˜Œξšƒξšξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ˆξšξ˜†ξ˜Œξš€ξ˜‡ξ˜Œξš‚ ξ˜ŠξšŠξš­ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜ 2,6 2,4
ξš‡ξ˜ξš€ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξšˆ ξ˜‰ξšƒξ˜ŠξšŠξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œ ξ˜Œξšξšξ˜Šξ˜†ξ˜‹ξ˜ξ˜…ξ˜Œξ˜Œ ξ˜Œξšƒξ˜ξ˜‰ξš€ξšξ˜Œ 2,3 1,7
ξš‡ξ˜ξš€ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξšˆ ξšξ˜Šξšƒξ˜Šξšξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜…ξ˜Œξš€ξ˜‹ ξ˜ξšƒξšξ˜ξ˜ˆξ˜‰ξ˜Œξš‹ξ˜Œξ˜‹ξš†ξ˜‹ ξ˜Œξ˜‹ξšξš­ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜Šξ˜‹ 2,6 2,4
ξ˜—ξšŠξ˜†ξ˜ξšξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξ˜ 7,4 8,8
ξš‡ξ˜ξš€ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξšˆ ξ˜‰ξšƒξ˜ŠξšŠξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œ ξšξ˜ˆξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜‰ξ˜Šξ˜Šξ™Ώξ˜†ξ˜ξšξ˜ξšξ˜Œξš€ ξ˜Œξšƒξ˜ξ˜Šξ˜…ξ˜Œξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξš†ξ™Ώ ξšξ˜ξ˜„ξšξ˜ƒ 6,2 7,1
ξš‡ξ˜†ξšξ˜ƒξ˜Œξ˜ ξ˜‰ξ˜Œξ˜ˆξš† ξ˜ˆξ˜ξš€ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œ 17,8 18,6
ξ˜“ξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜ξšξšˆ ξ˜†ξ˜ξšξ˜‰ξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜Œξš€ ξš„ξ˜Žξ˜Šξšξ˜Šξ˜‹ξ˜Œξ˜Žξ˜Œ ξ˜‰ξ˜Šξšƒξ˜‹ξšξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Šξ˜‹ ξ™Ώξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜Œξšξšξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ξš€ ξ˜ξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Šξš€ξšξ˜Œξ˜ξ˜‹ ξ˜†ξš†ξšξ˜Žξ˜
ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξšξ˜ˆξ˜, ξ˜‰ξ˜ξš‹ξšξ˜ξš‚ξš‘ξ˜Œξ˜‹ξ˜Œ ξšξ˜Šξ˜Žξ˜ξšξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξš€ξ˜‹ξ˜Œ ξ˜Žξ˜Šξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Š ξš€ξ˜‰ξ˜„ξš€ξš ξ˜‡ξ˜ξš€ ξšξ˜ξšξš€ξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξšˆ ξ˜ŒξšƒξšŠξ˜ξšξ˜†ξ˜ξšŠξ˜Šξ˜‡ξ˜Œξ˜…ξ˜
(ξ˜‡ξ˜ξšŠξ˜„. 3).
Society andξ˜›Security Insights β„– 3 2024 74
ξ˜œξ˜ξšŠξ˜„ξ˜Œξ˜…ξ˜ 3.
ξšžξ˜Œξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜ξšξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξšˆ ξšξ˜ξšξš€ξ˜‡ξš†ξ™Ώ ξ˜Œξšƒξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜ξšξšˆ ξšŠξ˜ξšξ˜†ξ˜ξšŠξ˜Šξ˜‡ξ˜Œξ˜…ξš† ξ˜‰ξšƒξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜Œξ˜Šξšξ˜ξ™Ώ
Table 3.
e number ofξšƒemployed andξšƒthe unemployment rate inξšƒthe regions
Π Π΅Π³ΠΈΠΎΠ½Ρ‹ На Π½Π°Ρ‡Π°Π»ΠΎ Π³ΠΎΠ΄Π°
2011 2016 2021 2022 2023
БрСднСгодовая Ρ‡ΠΈΡΠ»Π΅Π½Π½ΠΎΡΡ‚ΡŒ занятых вэкономикС, тыс. Ρ‡Π΅Π»)
ξ˜’ξ˜ξ˜ξšξšξšŠξ˜„ξ˜Œξ˜Žξ˜ ξš…ξšξ˜†ξš€ξ˜‡ξ˜Œξš€ 401,0 398,0 352,8 370,9 366,2
ξ˜’ξ˜ξ˜ξšξšξšŠξ˜„ξ˜Œξ˜Žξ˜ ξ˜ξ˜ξ™Ώξ˜ (ξš£ξ˜Žξšξ˜‡ξ˜Œξš€) 482,2 482,7 492,4 495,7 509,2
ξ˜•ξ˜ξšŠξ˜ξš‚ξ˜Žξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Œξš‚ ξ˜Žξ˜†ξ˜ξš‚ 488,2 475,4 452,5 456,8 446,3
ξ˜™ξ˜ξ˜‹ξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Œξš‚ ξ˜Žξ˜†ξ˜ξš‚ 169,5 170,1 167,0 172,0 164,5
ξš’ξ˜†ξ˜Œξ˜‹ξ˜Šξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Œξš‚ ξ˜Žξ˜†ξ˜ξš‚ 975,9 965,3 924,7 936,2 928,3
ξ˜”ξ˜ξšŠξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Œξš‚ ξ˜Žξ˜†ξ˜ξš‚ 692,1 683,0 666,5 674,4 669,8
ξ˜˜ξ˜‹ξšξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜ξš€ ξ˜ŠξšŠξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ξšˆ 423,2 393,2 381,2 381,4 383,1
ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜ξ˜ˆξ˜ξšξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜ξš€ ξ˜ŠξšŠξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ξšˆ 98,6 94,9 88,8 90,2 86,7
ξ˜ξ˜ξ™Ώξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜Œξšξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜ξš€ ξ˜ŠξšŠξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ξšˆ 292,4 287,7 275,4 270,8 275,7
ξ˜žξ˜‰ξ˜†ξ˜ξš‚ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜ξš€ ξ˜ξ˜‰ξ˜‡ξ˜Šξšξ˜Šξ˜‹ξšξ˜ξš€ ξ˜ŠξšŠξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ξšˆ 76,9 70,3 63,9 62,2 62,7
ξšžξšξ˜Žξ˜Šξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Œξš‚ ξ˜ξ˜‰ξ˜‡ξ˜Šξšξ˜Šξ˜‹ξšξš†ξš‚ ξ˜Šξ˜Žξ˜†ξšξ˜ƒ 36,6 33,1 33,5 35,0 33,5
ξš‡ξš–ξ˜— 4136,5 4053,7 3898,6 3945,5 3926,1
ξ˜’ξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Œξš‚ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜ξš€ ξš–ξ˜ξ˜ˆξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜…ξ˜Œξš€ 71493,1 72424,9 69550,3 70817,9 71216,9
Π£Ρ€ΠΎΠ²Π΅Π½ΡŒ Π±Π΅Π·Ρ€Π°Π±ΠΎΡ‚ΠΈΡ†Ρ‹, %
ξ˜’ξ˜ξ˜ξšξšξšŠξ˜„ξ˜Œξ˜Žξ˜ ξš…ξšξ˜†ξš€ξ˜‡ξ˜Œξš€ 10,4 9,2 16,0 13,0 11,5
ξ˜’ξ˜ξ˜ξšξšξšŠξ˜„ξ˜Œξ˜Žξ˜ ξ˜ξ˜ξ™Ώξ˜ (ξš£ξ˜Žξšξ˜‡ξ˜Œξš€) 8,9 7,3 10,5 8,9 8,3
ξ˜•ξ˜ξšŠξ˜ξš‚ξ˜Žξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Œξš‚ ξ˜Žξ˜†ξ˜ξš‚ 11,1 10,4 12,8 11,4 11,3
ξ˜™ξ˜ξ˜‹ξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Œξš‚ ξ˜Žξ˜†ξ˜ξš‚ 7,0 4,5 6,5 5,1 4,4
ξš’ξ˜†ξ˜Œξ˜‹ξ˜Šξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Œξš‚ ξ˜Žξ˜†ξ˜ξš‚ 9,5 6,9 8,1 6,4 5,3
ξ˜”ξ˜ξšŠξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Œξš‚ ξ˜Žξ˜†ξ˜ξš‚ 8,9 5,3 5,4 4,7 3,6
ξ˜˜ξ˜‹ξšξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜ξš€ ξ˜ŠξšŠξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ξšˆ 6,9 5,8 8,8 7,5 6,2
ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜ξ˜ˆξ˜ξšξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜ξš€ ξ˜ŠξšŠξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ξšˆ 5,6 4,3 6,8 5,8 5,8
ξ˜ξ˜ξ™Ώξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜Œξšξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜ξš€ ξ˜ŠξšŠξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ξšˆ 8,9 6,3 8,2 6,7 5,7
ξ˜žξ˜‰ξ˜†ξ˜ξš‚ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜ξš€ ξ˜ξ˜‰ξ˜‡ξ˜Šξšξ˜Šξ˜‹ξšξ˜ξš€ ξ˜ŠξšŠξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ξšˆ 9,3 7,9 11,9 10,4 8,5
ξšžξšξ˜Žξ˜Šξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Œξš‚ ξ˜ξ˜‰ξ˜‡ξ˜Šξšξ˜Šξ˜‹ξšξš†ξš‚ ξ˜Šξ˜Žξ˜†ξšξ˜ƒ 4,5 4,0 5,4 2,8 1,9
ξš‡ξš–ξ˜— 8,6 6,3 9,4 7,8 6,9
ξ˜’ξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Œξš‚ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜ξš€ ξš–ξ˜ξ˜ˆξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜…ξ˜Œξš€ 7,3 5,6 7,8 6,4 5,2
Государство, граТданскоС общСство ΠΈξ˜›ΡΡ‚Π°Π±ΠΈΠ»ΡŒΠ½ΠΎΡΡ‚ΡŒ 75
ξ˜•ξ˜ ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‹ξ˜Šξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜ξšξšξš†ξš‚ ξšξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜Œξ˜Šξ˜ˆ ξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜Œξšξ˜Šξš‘ξ˜„ξ˜Š ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξš‹ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξ˜ ξ˜‚ξ˜Œξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜ ξšξ˜ξšξš€ξ˜‡ξš†ξ™Ώ  ξ˜‰ξšƒ ξ˜…ξ˜-
ξ˜„ξ˜Šξ˜‹ ξšξ˜Šξšƒξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜ξšξ˜, ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜Ž ξ˜Œξšƒξ˜‰ξ˜Š ξ˜‰ξ˜ξ˜ξ™Ώ ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜Œξ˜Šξšξ˜ξ™Ώ ξš‡ξš–ξ˜—, ξšξ˜ξšƒξ˜Œξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜„ξš ξ˜‚ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξ˜ξ˜‹ ξ˜’ξ˜ξ˜ξšξšξšŠξ˜„ξ˜Œξ˜Žξ˜Œ ξ˜ξ˜ξ™Ώξ˜,
ξ˜‚ξ˜‡ξ˜Š ξ˜ξ˜‰ξš€ξšξ˜ξšξ˜Š ξ˜ξšƒξ˜Šξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜‰ξ˜Šξš‚ ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξšξ˜Žξ˜‡ξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξš‚  ξš„ξ˜Žξ˜Šξšξ˜Šξ˜‹ξ˜Œξ˜Žξ˜Œ. ξ˜›ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Šξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜ ξšξ˜‰ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜Œξ˜‚ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξ˜ -
ξ˜„ξ˜Œξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜ ξšξ˜ξšξš€ξ˜‡ξš†ξ™Ώ ξ˜Œξšƒξ˜ξšξ˜Œξš‹ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξ˜ ξšŠξ˜ξšξ˜†ξ˜ξšŠξ˜Šξ˜‡ξ˜Œξ˜…ξš† ξšξ˜ξšŠξ˜„ξš ξ˜ˆξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜Šξ˜ξšˆ ξ˜‰ξšƒΒ«ξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξšξ˜ξšξ˜ˆξ˜ξ˜‹ξ˜Œξš‚ξšξš†ξ˜Β»
2ξš‰21–2ξš‰22ξšƒξ˜ƒξ˜ƒ.,  ξ˜‰ξšƒξ˜†ξš€ξ˜ˆξ˜ ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜Œξ˜Šξšξ˜Šξ˜‰ ξ˜ξ˜Œξ˜‡ξšξ˜ξ˜…ξ˜Œξš€ ξ˜ξšƒξšŠξ˜ξšξ˜†ξ˜ξšŠξ˜Šξ˜‡ξ˜Œξ˜…ξ˜ξš‚ ξ˜‰ξ˜ξ˜  ξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ξš€
ξšξ˜ξšŠξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜Šξšξ˜†ξ˜Œξš€ξ˜‡ξšξ˜Šξš‚ (ξ˜‰ ξ˜•ξ˜ξšŠξ˜ξš‚ξ˜Žξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Šξ˜‹ ξ˜Žξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜, ξ˜’ξ˜ξ˜ξšξšξšŠξ˜„ξ˜Œξ˜Žξ˜ ξš…ξšξ˜†ξš€ξ˜‡ξ˜Œξš€ ξ˜Œξšƒξ˜žξ˜‰ξ˜†ξ˜ξš‚ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Šξš‚ ξ˜ξ˜‰ξ˜‡ξ˜Š-
ξšξ˜Šξ˜‹ξšξ˜Šξš‚ ξ˜ŠξšŠξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œ).
ξš›ξ˜‡ξ˜Œ ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜Œξ˜Šξšξš† ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜Žξš‹ξ˜ ξ™Ώξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜Œξšξšξš ξ˜‡ξ˜ξš€ ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‹ξš†ξ˜‹ ξšξ˜Œξšξ˜Žξ˜Œξ˜‹ ξ˜‰ξšƒξšξ˜ξ˜ˆξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜Šξ˜‹ ξ˜Šξ˜Žξ˜†ξšξ˜ƒξ˜
ξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ˆξšξ˜ξ˜ˆξšξš‘ξ˜ξ˜‰ξš†ξ˜‹ ξ˜ŠξšŠξššξ˜ξ˜‹ξ˜Šξ˜‹ ξ˜Ÿξ˜’ξš’, ξšξ˜ξ˜‹ξ˜ξ˜‡ξšξ˜Š ξšŠξ˜Šξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜ ξšξ˜Œξšξ˜Žξ˜Œξ˜‹, ξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜‹ ξ˜‰ξšƒξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ˆξšξ˜ξ˜‹ ξšξ˜Šξšƒξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜ξšξ˜
(ξ˜†ξ˜Œξ˜. 1).
ξ˜’ξ˜Œξ˜ξšξšξ˜Šξ˜Ž 1ξšƒβ€” ξ˜Ÿξ˜’ξš’ ξšξ˜ξšƒξ˜ˆξšξš‘ξš ξšξ˜ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξš€ ξšξ˜ξšƒξšξ˜ξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜Š 2ξš‰22 ξ˜ƒ., ξ˜‡ξš†ξ˜. ξ˜†ξšξšŠ.
Figure 1ξšƒβ€” Gross regional product per capita at the beginning ofξšƒ2ξš‰22, thousand rubles
ξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ˆξšξ˜ξ˜ˆξšξš‘ξ˜ξ˜‰ξ˜Šξ˜ ξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜Œξšξ˜‰ξ˜Šξ˜ˆξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜Š ξ˜‰ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Š ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜Œξ˜Šξšξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Š ξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜ˆξšξ˜Žξ˜‡ξ˜ (ξ˜Ÿξ˜’ξš’
ξšξ˜ξšƒξ˜ˆξšξš‘ξš ξšξ˜ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξš€), ξ˜Œξ˜„ξ˜Œ ξ˜ŠξšŠξš­ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜ξšξšξ˜ξš€ ξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜Œξšξ˜‰ξ˜Šξ˜ˆξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξšˆ ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξšξ˜ˆξ˜,ξšƒβ€”  ξ˜Œξšξšƒξ˜Œξš-
ξ˜ˆξ˜Œξ˜Žξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜‰, ξ˜ξ˜‰ξ˜Œξ˜ˆξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξšξš ξš­ξ˜Œξ™Ώ  ξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξšξ˜ ξ˜†ξ˜ξšξ˜‰ξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜Œξš€ ξš„ξ˜Žξ˜Šξšξ˜Šξ˜‹ξ˜Œξ˜Žξ˜Œ ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜Œξ˜Šξšξ˜. ξš›ξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜‡ -
ξ˜ˆξ˜Œξ˜Žξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜† ξšξ˜Šξ˜Žξ˜ξšξš†ξ˜‰ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ξšξ˜ξšξšˆ ξš„ξšξšξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜‡ξ˜Œξ˜‰ξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œ ξ˜Œξ˜ξšξ˜Šξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξš€ ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ξšξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜Šξ˜‰, ξ˜ξ˜‰ξ˜ξšξ˜ξ˜Œξ˜†ξ˜Š-
ξ˜‰ξ˜ξšξšξš†ξ™Ώ ξ˜‰ξšƒξš„ξ˜Žξ˜Šξšξ˜Šξ˜‹ξ˜Œξ˜Žξš ξ˜ˆξ˜„ξš€ ξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜Œξšξ˜‰ξ˜Šξ˜ˆξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜ ξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜‰ ξ˜Œξšƒξšξ˜ξ˜„ξšξ˜ƒ, ξ˜ξšƒξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜Žξš‹ξ˜ ξš€ξ˜‰ξ˜„ξš€ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ξš€ ξ˜‹ξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜Šξš‚
ξ˜Šξ˜…ξ˜ξšξ˜Žξ˜Œ ξšξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜‹ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜‰ ξ˜ξ˜Šξ˜…ξ˜Œξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜Š-ξš„ξ˜Žξ˜Šξšξ˜Šξ˜‹ξ˜Œξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Š ξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜, ξ˜Žξ˜Šξšξ˜Žξšξ˜†ξ˜ξšξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜ξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜ŠξšŠξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œ
ξ˜Œξšƒξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξšξš€ ξš‹ξ˜Œξšξšξ˜Œ ξšξ˜ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξš€ ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜Œξ˜Šξšξ˜Šξ˜‰.
Society andξ˜›Security Insights β„– 3 2024 76
 ξ˜…ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜Šξ˜‹ ξ˜‰ξšƒ ξ˜ˆξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜ξ˜‰ξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜‚ξšξš†ξ™Ώ ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜Œξ˜Šξšξ˜ξ™Ώ ξ˜ŠξšŠξš­ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜ξšξšξ˜ξš€ ξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜Œξšξ˜‰ξ˜Šξ˜ˆξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξšˆ
ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξšξ˜ˆξ˜ ξšξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜‰ξš†ξš‘ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ ξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ˆξšξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Œξš‚ξ˜ξ˜Žξšξš . ξš›ξ˜‡ξ˜Š ξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œξ˜ƒξšξšξ˜‡ξ˜Š ξšξ˜ξšƒ ξ˜ξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜‡ ξšžξšξ˜Žξ˜Šξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Š ξ˜ξ˜‰ξ˜‡ξ˜Š-
ξšξ˜Šξ˜‹ξšξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Š ξ˜Šξ˜Žξ˜†ξšξ˜ƒξ˜, ξ˜’ξ˜ξ˜ξšξšξšŠξ˜„ξ˜Œξ˜Žξ˜Œ ξ˜ξ˜ξ™Ώξ˜, ξ˜ξ˜ξ™Ώξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜Œξšξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Šξš‚ ξ˜Œξšƒξ˜ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜ξ˜ˆξ˜ξšξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Šξš‚ ξ˜ŠξšŠξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ξš‚ ξ˜‰ξšƒξ˜ξ˜‰ξš€ξšξ˜Œ
ξ˜ξ˜Šξšƒ ξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜‰ξšξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜Š ξšξ˜ξ˜‰ξš†ξ˜ξ˜Šξ˜Žξ˜Šξš‚ ξ˜‚ξ˜Œξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜ξšξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξšˆξš  ξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Šξš€ξšξšξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Š ξšξ˜ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξš€ ξ˜Œξšƒ -
ξ˜ξ˜‡ξš€ξ˜‹ξ˜Œ ξ˜Šξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜‰ξ˜Šξš‚ ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξšξ˜Žξ˜‡ξšξ˜†ξš† ξš„ξ˜Žξ˜Šξšξ˜Šξ˜‹ξ˜Œξ˜Žξ˜Œ ξ˜‰ξšƒξš„ξ˜‡ξ˜Œξ™Ώ ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜Œξ˜Šξšξ˜ξ™Ώ. ,  ξšξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ŠξšŠξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜ˆξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡
ξ˜ˆξ˜ŠξšŠξš†ξ˜‚ξ˜ ξšξ˜Šξ˜„ξ˜ξšξšξš†ξ™Ώ ξ˜Œξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Šξšξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‹ξš†ξ™Ώ, ξ˜ƒξ˜ˆξ˜ ξšξ˜ξšξš€ξ˜‡ξš† ξšξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜Œξ˜‹ξšξš­ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜ξšξšξ˜Š ξ˜ξ˜Šξ˜‡ξ˜†ξšξ˜ˆξšξ˜Œξ˜Žξ˜Œ, ξ˜†ξ˜ξšŠξ˜Šξ˜‡ξ˜-
 ξ˜‰ξ˜ξ™Ώξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξš†ξ˜‹ ξ˜‹ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ˜‹. ξ˜ŸξšƒξšŠξ˜Šξ˜„ξšˆξš‘ξ˜Œξšξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜ ξš‹ξ˜ ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜Œξ˜Šξšξ˜Šξ˜‰ ξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ˆξšξ˜ξ˜ˆξšξš‘ξ˜ξ˜‰ξ˜Šξš‚ ξ˜Ÿξ˜’ξš’ ξšξ˜Œξš‹ξ˜,
ξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜‹ ξ˜‰ξšƒξ˜…ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜Šξ˜‹ ξšξ˜Šξšƒξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜ξšξ˜. ξ˜œξ˜ξ™Ώξšξ˜Šξ˜„ξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Œξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜ξš€ ξ˜Šξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξšˆ, ξ˜‰ξš†ξ˜ξ˜Šξ˜Žξ˜ξš€ ξ˜Œξšξšξ˜Šξš‘ξ˜ξšξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξšˆ -
ξšξ˜Šξ˜‰ξšξš†ξ™Ώ ξšξ˜Šξšξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ˜‰, ξšξ˜Œξšξ˜Žξ˜ξš€ ξšξ˜ξ˜Œξšξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜ξšξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξšˆ ξ˜†ξ˜ξšŠξ˜Šξ˜‡ξšξ˜Œξ˜Žξ˜Šξ˜‰ ξ˜‰ξšƒ ξ˜†ξ˜ξšξšξ˜„ξšˆξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ™Ώ ξ˜ξ˜‰ξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜Š
ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξšξ˜ˆξ˜, ξšξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜‰ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜Œξšξ˜Œξ˜…ξ˜Œξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜ξšξšξš†ξš‚ ξ˜‹ξ˜ξšξ˜ξ˜ˆξš‹ξ˜‹ξ˜ξšξ˜‡ ξ˜Œξšƒ ξ˜†ξš€ξ˜ˆ ξ˜ˆξ˜†ξšξ˜ƒξ˜Œξ™Ώ ξšξ˜†ξ˜Œξ˜‚ξ˜Œξš ξšξšξ˜ξ˜‚ξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜Š
ξ˜ξ˜ˆξ˜ξ˜†ξš‹ξ˜Œξ˜‰ξ˜ξš ξ˜‡ ξšξ˜Šξ˜‡ξ˜ξšξ˜…ξ˜Œξ˜ξ˜„ ξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξšξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ˜Šξ˜‡ξ˜ˆξ˜ξ˜‚ξ˜Œ.
ξš’ξ˜Š ξ˜Šξ˜…ξ˜ξšξ˜Žξ˜ ξ˜Œξ˜ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜ξš‚, ξšξ˜ξšƒξ˜ˆξ˜ξšξšξ˜Šξ˜‹ ξš„ξ˜‡ξ˜ξšξ˜ ξ˜†ξ˜ξšξ˜‰ξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜Œξš€ ξš„ξ˜Žξ˜Šξšξ˜Šξ˜‹ξ˜Œξ˜Žξ˜Œ ξ˜‰ξšƒξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Œξš‚-
ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Œξ™Ώ ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜Œξ˜Šξšξ˜ξ™Ώ Β«ξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜ξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Œξš‚ ξ˜Žξ˜ξšξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„  ξšŠξ˜ξšξ˜Šξ˜‰ξš†ξš‚ ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ξšξ˜†ξ˜ ξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Œξš‚ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Š ξ˜ŠξšŠξš­ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜
ξ˜Œξ˜ξšξ˜Šξ˜„ξšˆξšξšξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ξš€ ξšξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜…ξ˜Œξ˜Šξšξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜Š. ξš’ξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜Œξ˜ξ™Ώξ˜Šξ˜ˆξ˜Œξ˜‡ ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξš‹ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξ˜ ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜Š ξš„ξšξšξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜‡ξ˜Œξ˜‰ξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œ, ξ˜ξ˜‰ξ˜Šξ˜-
ξ˜ŠξšŠξ˜†ξ˜ξšξšξ˜Šξ˜ ξ˜Œξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Šξš­ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξ˜ ξ˜Œξšƒξ˜ˆξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ˆξ˜ξ˜…ξ˜Œξš€Β» (ξšžξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜ξšξ˜ξšξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜, 2ξš‰21: 36). ξ˜œξ˜†ξšξ˜ˆξšƒβ€” ξ˜ƒξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜‰ξšξš†ξš‚ -
ξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜† ξ˜Œξšƒξ˜ˆξ˜‰ξ˜Œξš‹ξšξš­ξ˜ξš€ ξ˜ξ˜Œξ˜„ξ˜ ξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜Œξšξ˜‰ξ˜Šξ˜ˆξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜ξšƒβ€” ξ˜‰ξšƒξšξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Šξš€ξš­ξ˜ξ˜ ξ˜‰ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜‹ξš€ ξ˜‰ξšƒξšŠξ˜Šξ˜„ξšˆξš‘ξ˜Œξšξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜ ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜Œξ˜Š-
ξšξ˜Šξ˜‰ ξšξ˜Œξšξ˜Žξ˜Šξ˜†ξ˜ξšξšξ˜„ξšˆξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œξ˜‰ξ˜ξš. ξš’ξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜Œξšξ˜‰ξ˜Šξ˜ˆξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξšˆ ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξšξ˜ˆξ˜ ξ˜‰ξšƒξšξ˜ξš‘ξ˜ξš‚ ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜ξšξ˜ ξ˜‰ξšƒξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜Œ-ξšξš€ξ˜‡ξšˆ
ξ˜†ξ˜ξš ξšξ˜Œξš‹ξ˜, ξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜‹ ξ˜‰ξšƒ ξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œξšξ˜ˆξšξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜Œξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξš†ξ™Ώ ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜ξšξ˜ξ™Ώ1. ξ˜™ξ˜ξ˜Ž ξšŠξš†ξ˜„ξ˜Š ξ˜Šξ˜‡ξ˜‹ξ˜ξ˜‚ξ˜ξšξ˜Š ξ˜‰ξš†ξš‘ξ˜, ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξš-
ξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ˜Šξ˜‡ξ˜ˆξ˜ξ˜‚ξ˜ ξšξ˜ξ˜‰ξ˜Œξ˜ξ˜Œξ˜‡ ξ˜Šξ˜‡ξšƒξ˜†ξš€ξ˜ˆξ˜ ξ˜‰ξ˜ξš‹ξšξš†ξ™Ώ ξšξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜Œξš‚ξšƒβ€” ξšξ˜ξ˜Œξ™Ώξ˜Šξš„ξ˜‹ξ˜Šξ˜…ξ˜Œξ˜Šξšξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Š, ξ˜ˆξšξ™Ώξ˜Šξ˜‰ξšξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Š
ξ˜Œξšƒξšξ˜Œξšξ˜Œξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Š ξšξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξšˆξš€ ξ˜„ξš ξ˜ˆξ˜ξš‚, ξ˜Œξ™Ώ ξ˜ƒξ˜†ξ˜ξš‹ξ˜ˆξ˜ξšξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Š ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‹ξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜Šξšξšξ˜ξšξ˜Œξš€, ξšξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜Šξ˜†ξ˜ξšξšξ˜Š-
ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œ ξ˜ξ˜‰ξ˜Šξ˜Œξ˜‹ ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξšξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ˜‹ ξ˜Œξšƒξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξšξ˜ξ˜‹ ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜Š ξ˜Šξšξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜‡ξš†. ξš‡ξ˜ŠξšŠξ˜ξ˜‰ξ˜Œξ˜‹, ξ˜‚ξ˜‡ξ˜Š ξ˜ξšξš­ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜ξšξšξ˜Šξ˜ ξšξšξ˜ξ˜‚ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξ˜
ξ˜Œξ˜‹ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜Žξš‹ξ˜ ξ˜‹ξšξ˜Šξš‹ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜Š ξ˜ˆξ˜†ξšξ˜ƒξ˜Œξ™Ώ ξ˜ŠξšŠξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Šξš€ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰: ξš„ξ˜†ξ˜ƒξ˜Šξšξ˜Šξ˜‹ξ˜Œξ˜‚ξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξšˆ ξ˜†ξ˜ξšŠξ˜Šξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜Š ξ˜‹ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜,
ξ˜ξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Šξš€ξšξ˜Œξ˜ ξ˜‹ξ˜Œξ˜Žξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜Žξ˜„ξ˜Œξ˜‹ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ ξ˜‰ξšƒξ˜‡ξ˜†ξšξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜Šξ˜‹ ξ˜Žξ˜Šξ˜„ξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜‡ξ˜Œξ˜‰ξ˜, ξ˜Žξšξ˜„ξšˆξ˜‡ξšξ˜†ξ˜ ξ˜Œξšƒξ˜†ξ˜ξš‹ξ˜Œξ˜‹ ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξšξ˜ˆξ˜ ξ˜Œξšƒξ˜Šξ˜‡-
ξ˜ˆξš†ξ™Ώξ˜, ξ˜ξšƒξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜Žξš‹ξ˜ ξšξ˜Šξšξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜Šξ˜Šξ˜†ξšξš‹ξ˜ξšξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξšˆ ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξšξ˜ˆξ˜ ξ˜Œξšƒξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜ξšξšˆ ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ™Ώξšξ˜Šξ˜„ξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Œξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Š ξ˜†ξ˜ξšξ˜‰ξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜Œξš€
(ξ˜œξ˜†ξ˜Šξšξ˜Œξ˜‹ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜, 2ξš‰23: 37). ξš’ξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜ˆξšξ˜Œξ˜ ξ˜ˆξ˜‰ξ˜ ξ˜‰ξšƒξšξšξ˜ξ˜‚ξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜Šξš‚ ξ˜‹ξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜ ξšξ˜ξ˜‰ξ˜Œξ˜ξš€ξ˜‡ ξ˜Šξ˜‡ξšƒξšξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜‹ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜‰
ξ˜Žξ˜ξšξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξš†ξ™Ώ ξ˜‰ξ˜„ξ˜Šξš‹ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξš‚ ξ˜‰ξšƒξ˜Šξ˜ξšξ˜Šξ˜‰ξšξš†ξ˜ ξšξ˜Šξšξ˜ˆξš†.
ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜Œξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Œξ˜ ξ˜ξ˜Šξ˜…ξ˜Œξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜Š-ξš„ξ˜Žξ˜Šξšξ˜Šξ˜‹ξ˜Œξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Œξ˜ ξšξ˜†ξ˜Œξ˜Šξ˜†ξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜‡ξš† ξ˜ƒξ˜Šξ˜ξšξ˜ˆξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜ ξ˜Œξšƒ -
-ξ˜ξ˜Šξ˜ŠξšŠξš­ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ ξš€ξ˜†ξ˜Žξ˜Š ξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξš€ξ˜‰ξ˜„ξš€ξš ξ˜‡ξ˜ξš€ ξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜ξš ξ˜ŠξšŠξššξ˜ξ˜‹ξš† ξ˜Œξšξ˜‰ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œξ˜…ξ˜Œξš‚ ξ˜‰ξšƒξ˜Šξ˜ξšξ˜Šξ˜‰ξšξ˜Šξš‚ ξ˜Žξ˜ξšξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„
(ξ˜‡ξ˜ξšŠξ˜„. 4).
ξ˜œξ˜ξšŠξ˜„ξ˜Œξ˜…ξ˜ 4.
ξ˜—ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜‰ξ˜ξš€ ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξšξ˜Žξ˜‡ξšξ˜†ξ˜ ξ˜Œξšξ˜‰ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œξ˜…ξ˜Œξš‚ ξ˜‰ξšƒξ˜Šξ˜ξšξ˜Šξ˜‰ξšξ˜Šξš‚
ξ˜Žξ˜ξšξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„, 2ξš‰22 ξ˜ƒ., ξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜…ξ˜ξšξ˜‡ ξ˜Šξ˜‡ξšƒξ˜ŠξšŠξš­ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜Š ξ˜ŠξšŠξššξ˜ξ˜‹ξ˜
Table 4.
Sectoral structure ofξšƒinvestments inξšƒξš™xed assets, 2ξš‰22, percent ofξšƒtotal volume
НаимСнованиС Российская
ЀСдСрация Π”Π€Πž
ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Šξ˜, ξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜ξšξ˜Šξ˜ ξ™Ώξ˜Šξšξš€ξš‚ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜Š, ξ˜Šξ™Ώξ˜Šξ˜‡ξ˜, ξ˜†ξš†ξšŠξ˜Šξ˜„ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜Š ξ˜Œξšƒξ˜†ξš†ξšŠξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜Šξ˜ˆ-
ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜Š 3,1 3,8
ξš‡ξ˜ŠξšŠξš†ξ˜‚ξ˜ ξšξ˜Šξ˜„ξ˜ξšξšξš†ξ™Ώ ξ˜Œξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Šξšξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‹ξš†ξ™Ώ 18,0 23,0
ξ˜—ξšŠξ˜†ξ˜ξšŠξ˜ξ˜‡ξš†ξ˜‰ξ˜ξš ξš­ξ˜Œξ˜ ξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜Œξšξ˜‰ξ˜Šξ˜ˆξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜ 15,3 16,1
1 https://www.kommersant.ru/doc/5915110 (Π΄Π°Ρ‚Π° обращСния: 04.06.2024)
Государство, граТданскоС общСство ΠΈξ˜›ΡΡ‚Π°Π±ΠΈΠ»ΡŒΠ½ΠΎΡΡ‚ΡŒ 77
НаимСнованиС Российская
ЀСдСрация Π”Π€Πž
ξ˜—ξšŠξ˜ξ˜ξšξ˜ξ˜‚ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξ˜ ξš„ξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜Œξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Šξš‚ ξš„ξšξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜ƒξ˜Œξ˜ξš‚, ξ˜ƒξ˜ξšξ˜Šξ˜‹ 5,9 6,5
ξ˜Ÿξ˜Šξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ˜ξšξ˜ξšŠξš‹ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξ˜; ξ˜‰ξ˜Šξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ˜Šξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜ξ˜ˆξ˜ξšξ˜Œξ˜ 1,3 0,6
ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜Š 3,5 3,6
ξ˜œξ˜Šξ˜†ξ˜ƒξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜„ξš€ ξ˜Šξšξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜ξš€ ξ˜Œξšƒξ˜†ξ˜Šξšξšξ˜Œξ˜‚ξšξ˜ξš€; ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜‹ξ˜Šξšξ˜‡ ξ˜ξ˜‰ξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜ξšξ˜ξšξ˜Šξ˜†ξ˜‡ξšξš†ξ™Ώ
ξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ˆξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ ξ˜Œξšƒξ˜‹ξ˜Šξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜…ξ˜Œξ˜Žξ˜„ξ˜Šξ˜‰ 2,7 1,7
ξ˜œξ˜†ξ˜ξšξ˜ξšξ˜Šξ˜†ξ˜‡ξ˜Œξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜Žξ˜ ξ˜Œξšƒξ™Ώξ˜†ξ˜ξšξ˜ξšξ˜Œξ˜ 20,3 32,2
ξš‡ξ˜ξš€ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξšˆ ξ˜ƒξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œξšξ˜Œξ˜… ξ˜Œξšƒξšξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ˆξšξ˜†ξ˜Œξš€ξ˜‡ξ˜Œξš‚ ξ˜ŠξšŠξš­ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜ 0,4 0,5
ξš‡ξ˜ξš€ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξšˆ ξ˜‰ξšƒξ˜ŠξšŠξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œ ξ˜Œξšξšξ˜Šξ˜†ξ˜‹ξ˜ξ˜…ξ˜Œξ˜Œ ξ˜Œξšƒξ˜ξ˜‰ξš€ξšξ˜Œ 4,1 2,2
ξš‡ξ˜ξš€ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξšˆ ξšξ˜Œξšξ˜ξšξ˜ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜ξš€ ξ˜Œξšƒξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜ξ™Ώξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜ξš€ 2,7 0,3
ξš‡ξ˜ξš€ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξšˆ ξšξ˜Šξšƒξ˜Šξšξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜…ξ˜Œξš€ξ˜‹ ξ˜ξšƒξšξ˜ξ˜ˆξ˜‰ξ˜Œξš‹ξ˜Œξ˜‹ξš†ξ˜‹ ξ˜Œξ˜‹ξšξš­ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜Šξ˜‹ 6,2 2,0
ξš‡ξ˜ξš€ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξšˆ ξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξšξ˜ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Œξ˜Šξšξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜ξš€, ξšξ˜ξšξ˜‚ξšξ˜ξš€ ξ˜Œξšƒξ˜‡ξ˜ξ™Ώξšξ˜Œξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜ξš€ 6,0 1,7
ξš‡ξ˜ξš€ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξšˆ ξ˜ξ˜ˆξ˜‹ξ˜Œξšξ˜Œξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œξ˜‰ξšξ˜ξš€ ξ˜Œξšƒξ˜ξ˜Šξšξšξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξšξš ξš­ξ˜Œξ˜ ξ˜ˆξ˜Šξšξ˜Šξ˜„-
ξšξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξš†ξ˜ ξšξ˜ξ˜„ξšξ˜ƒξ˜Œ 1,0 0,2
ξ˜‘ξ˜Šξ˜ξšξ˜ˆξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜ξšξšξ˜Šξ˜ ξšξšξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜‰ξ˜„ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξ˜ ξ˜Œξšƒξ˜ŠξšŠξ˜ξ˜ξšξ˜ξ˜‚ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξ˜ ξ˜‰ξ˜Šξ˜ξšξšξ˜Šξš‚ -
ξšξ˜ξ˜ξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œ; ξ˜ξ˜Šξ˜…ξ˜Œξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜Šξ˜ ξ˜ŠξšŠξ˜ξ˜ξšξ˜ξ˜‚ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξ˜ 2,3 1,8
ξ˜—ξšŠξ˜†ξ˜ξšξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξ˜ 2,7 1,6
ξš‡ξ˜ξš€ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξšˆ ξ˜‰ξšƒξ˜ŠξšŠξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œ ξšξ˜ˆξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜‰ξ˜Šξ˜Šξ™Ώξ˜†ξ˜ξšξ˜ξšξ˜Œξš€ ξ˜Œξšƒξ˜ξ˜Šξ˜…ξ˜Œξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξš†ξ™Ώ
ξšξ˜ξ˜„ξšξ˜ƒ 2,8 1,4
ξš‡ξ˜ξš€ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξšˆ ξ˜‰ξšƒξ˜ŠξšŠξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œ ξ˜Žξšξ˜„ξšˆξ˜‡ξšξ˜†ξš†, ξ˜ξšξ˜Šξ˜†ξ˜‡ξ˜, ξ˜Šξ˜†ξ˜ƒξ˜ξšξ˜Œξšξ˜ξ˜…ξ˜Œξ˜Œ
ξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ˜ξšξ˜ƒξ˜ ξ˜Œξšƒξ˜†ξ˜ξšξ˜‰ξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜‚ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξš‚ 1,7 0,8
ξ˜™ξ˜ξ˜Ž ξ˜‰ξšƒ ξ˜…ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜Šξ˜‹ ξšξ˜Šξšƒ ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜ξšξ˜, ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜Ž ξ˜Œξšƒ ξ˜‰ξšƒ ξ˜ˆξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜ξ˜‰ξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜‚ξšξš†ξ™Ώ ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜Œξ˜Šξšξ˜ξ™Ώ ξ˜Œξšξ˜‰ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œξ˜…ξ˜Œξ˜Šξš-
ξšξš†ξ˜ ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ξšξ˜†ξ˜ξš† ξšξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜Œξ˜‹ξšξš­ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜ξšξšξ˜Š ξ˜‰ξ˜Žξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜ˆξš†ξ˜‰ξ˜ξš ξ˜‡ξ˜ξš€ ξ˜‰ξšƒξ˜ˆξ˜ŠξšŠξš†ξ˜‚ξš ξšξ˜Šξ˜„ξ˜ξšξšξš†ξ™Ώ ξ˜Œξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Šξšξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‹ξš†ξ™Ώ,
ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜ξšξ˜ξšξ˜Šξ˜†ξ˜‡ξ˜Œξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜Žξš ξ˜Œξšƒξ™Ώξ˜†ξ˜ξšξ˜ξšξ˜Œξ˜. ξš’ξ˜†ξ˜Œξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜‹ ξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜ˆξšξ˜Œξ˜ ξ˜†ξ˜ξšξ˜‰ξ˜Œξ˜‰ξ˜ξš ξ˜‡ξ˜ξš€ ξ˜ˆξ˜„ξš€ ξ˜ŠξšŠξ˜ξ˜ξšξ˜ξ˜‚ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξš€
ξš„ξ˜Žξ˜ξšξ˜Šξ˜†ξ˜‡ξ˜ ξšξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜‰ξš†ξ™Ώ. ξ˜’ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜Œξ˜Šξšξš† ξ˜’ξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Œξ˜Œ,  ξ˜ˆξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜ξ˜‰ξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜‚ξšξš†ξ˜,ξšƒβ€” ξš„ξ˜‡ξ˜Š ξ˜ξš†ξ˜†ξšˆξ˜ξ˜‰ξš†ξ˜
ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜†ξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜†ξ˜Œξ˜Œ, ξ˜Žξ˜Šξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜†ξš†ξ˜ ξšξš‹ξ˜ ξšξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Šξ˜„ξšˆξ˜Žξ˜Š ξ˜ˆξ˜ξ˜ξš€ξ˜‡ξ˜Œξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œξš‚ ξ˜ξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜‚ξ˜Œξ˜‰ξ˜ξš ξ˜‡ ξšξšξ˜ξ˜‚ξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξš†ξ˜
ξšξ˜ξ˜Œξ˜„ξ˜Œξš€ ξšξ˜ξšƒΒ«ξ˜‰ξš†ξ˜Žξ˜ξ˜‚ξ˜Œξ˜‰ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξ˜ŒΒ» ξšξ˜†ξ˜Œξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜ˆξšξš†ξ™Ώ ξšŠξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ ξ˜Œξšƒξ˜Œξ™Ώ ξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜ˆξ˜ξš‹ξ˜. ξ˜Ÿξšƒξ˜‡ξ˜Š ξš‹ξ˜ ξ˜‰ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜‹ξš€ ξ˜‰ξšƒξ˜ξ˜Š-
ξ˜…ξ˜Œξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜Š ξšξšξ˜ξ˜‚ξ˜Œξ˜‹ξš†ξ˜, ξš‹ξ˜Œξšξšξ˜ξ˜ŠξšŠξ˜ξ˜ξšξ˜ξ˜‚ξ˜Œξ˜‰ξ˜ξš ξš­ξ˜Œξ˜ ξ˜Šξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜Œ (ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Šξ˜ ξ™Ώξ˜Šξšξš€ξš‚ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜Š, ξšξ˜ˆξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜‰ξ˜Š-
ξ˜Šξ™Ώξ˜†ξ˜ξšξ˜ξšξ˜Œξ˜, ξ˜Œξšξšξ˜Šξ˜†ξ˜‹ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œξšξ˜ξ˜…ξ˜Œξš , ξ˜ξšξ˜Šξ˜†ξ˜‡, ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜Š) ξ˜Œξšξ˜‰ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œξ˜…ξ˜Œξ˜Œ ξ˜‰ξ˜Žξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜ˆξš†ξ˜‰ξ˜ξš ξ˜‡ξ˜ξš€
ξ˜‰ξšƒξ˜ξšξš­ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜ξšξšξ˜Š ξ˜‹ξ˜ξšξšˆξš‘ξ˜Œξ™Ώ ξ˜ŠξšŠξššξ˜ξ˜‹ξ˜ξ™Ώ, ξ˜‚ξ˜‡ξ˜Š ξšξ˜ξšŠξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜Šξšξ˜†ξ˜Œξš€ξ˜‡ξšξ˜Š ξ˜Šξ˜‡ξ˜ŠξšŠξ˜†ξ˜ξš‹ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ξš€ ξšξ˜ξšƒξšξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜‹ξ˜-
ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜ξ™Ώ ξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜Šξ˜„ξšˆξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜ξšξšξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Š ξ˜ŠξšŠξ˜ξ˜ξšξ˜ξ˜‚ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξš€, ξ˜ξ˜Šξ˜…ξ˜Œξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Š ξ˜Œξšƒξ˜‹ξ˜ξ˜ˆξ˜Œξ˜…ξ˜Œξšξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Š ξ˜ŠξšŠξ˜ξ˜„ξšξš‹ξ˜Œξ˜‰ξ˜-
ξšξ˜Œξš€, ξšξ˜ξšƒξ˜Žξ˜ξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜ ξšξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξšˆξš€ ξ˜ƒξ˜†ξ˜ξš‹ξ˜ˆξ˜ξš, ξšξ˜ξšƒξ˜ξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Šξš€ξšξ˜Œξ˜Œ ξ˜‰ξ˜ξ˜ξ™Ώ ξš„ξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜‹ξ˜ξšξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜‰ ξ˜Œξšξšξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξšξ˜Žξ˜‡ξš-
ξ˜†ξš† ξ˜Œξšƒξ˜‰ξšƒξ˜…ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜Šξ˜‹ξšƒβ€” ξšξ˜ξšƒξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξšξ˜ ξš‹ξ˜Œξšξšξ˜Œ ξ˜„ξš ξ˜ˆξ˜ξš‚.
Π£Ρ€ΠΎΠ²Π΅Π½ΡŒ ΠΆΠΈΠ·Π½ΠΈ насСлСния Π΄Π°Π»ΡŒΠ½Π΅Π²ΠΎΡΡ‚ΠΎΡ‡Π½Ρ‹Ρ… Ρ€Π΅Π³ΠΈΠΎΠ½ΠΎΠ²
 ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜Œξ˜Šξšξ˜ξ™Ώ, ξ˜ƒξ˜ˆξ˜ ξ˜Šξ˜‡ξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜Š ξ˜‹ξ˜ξ˜„ ξ˜ŠξšŠξššξ˜ξ˜‹ ξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ˆξšξ˜ξ˜ˆξšξš‘ξ˜ξ˜‰ξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Š ξ˜Ÿξ˜’ξš’,  ξšξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜‰ξ˜Œξ˜„ξ˜Š,
ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜ˆξš†ξ˜‰ξ˜ξš ξ˜‡ξ˜ξš€ ξšξ˜Œξšξ˜Žξ˜Œξš‚ ξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜ξšξšˆ ξš‹ξ˜Œξšξšξ˜Œ ξ˜Œξšƒξ˜‰ξš†ξ˜ξ˜Šξ˜Žξ˜ξš€ ξšŠξ˜ξ˜ˆξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξšˆ, ξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξš€ξ˜‰ξ˜„ξš€ξš ξš­ξ˜Œξ˜ξ˜ξš€ ξšξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜Ž-
ξ˜‡ξ˜Œξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Œ ξ˜‰ξ˜Šξšƒξ˜‰ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‹. , ξš…ξšξ˜†ξš€ξ˜‡ξ˜Œξš€, ξ˜ξ˜ξ™Ώξ˜ (ξš£ξ˜Žξšξ˜‡ξ˜Œξš€), ξ˜•ξ˜ξšŠξ˜ξš‚ξ˜Žξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Œξš‚ ξ˜Žξ˜†ξ˜ξš‚ ξ˜Œξšƒξ˜žξ˜‰ξ˜†ξ˜ξš‚ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜ξš€
ξ˜ξ˜‰ξ˜‡ξ˜Šξšξ˜Šξ˜‹ξšξ˜ξš€ ξ˜ŠξšŠξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ξšˆ, ξš€ξ˜‰ξ˜„ξš€ξš€ξ˜ξšˆ ξšŠξ˜ξ˜ˆξšξ˜ξš‚ξš‘ξ˜Œξ˜‹ξ˜Œ ξšξ˜Šξšƒξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξšξš  ξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ™Ώξ˜Šξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ˜‰ ξšξ˜ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξš€ ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜Œξ˜Š-
Society andξ˜›Security Insights β„– 3 2024 78
ξšξ˜ξ˜‹ξ˜Œ, ξ™Ώξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜Œξšξšξš ξ˜‡ξ˜ξš€ ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜Žξš‹ξ˜ ξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜‰ξšξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜Š ξ˜‹ξ˜ξšξ˜ξ˜ ξšŠξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜Šξšξ˜Šξ˜„ξšξ˜‚ξšξš†ξ˜‹ξ˜Œ ξš‹ξ˜Œξ˜„ξ˜Œξš­ξšξš†ξ˜‹ξ˜Œ
ξšξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜Œξš€ξ˜‹ξ˜Œ ξšξ˜ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξš€: ξ˜Šξ˜‡ξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜Š ξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ˆξšξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Œξš‚ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Š ξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξšξš€ ξ˜ŠξšŠξ˜ξ˜ξšξ˜ξ˜‚ξ˜ξšξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξšˆ
ξš‹ξ˜Œξ˜„ξ˜Šξš‚ ξšξ˜„ξ˜Šξš­ξ˜ξ˜ˆξšˆξš  ξšξ˜ξ˜‰ξš†ξ˜ξ˜Šξ˜Žξ˜ (ξ˜†ξ˜Œξ˜. 2).
ξ˜’ξ˜Œξ˜ξšξšξ˜Šξ˜Ž 2ξšƒβ€” ξ˜—ξšŠξš­ξ˜ξš€ ξšξ˜„ξ˜Šξš­ξ˜ξ˜ˆξšˆ ξš‹ξ˜Œξ˜„ξš†ξ™Ώ ξšξ˜Šξ˜‹ξ˜ξš­ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξš‚ ξ˜‰ξšƒξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ˆξšξ˜ξ˜‹ ξšξ˜ξšƒξ˜Šξ˜ˆξšξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Š ξš‹ξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξš€, 2ξš‰22 ξ˜ƒ., ξ˜‹2
Figure 2ξšƒβ€”  e total area ofξšƒresidential premises on average per inhabitant, 2ξš‰22, m2
ξ˜™ξ˜†ξ˜ξš‚ξšξ˜  ξšŠξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜Šξšξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜ξšξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξšˆ ξš‹ξ˜Œξ˜„ξšˆξš€. ξ˜•ξšξ˜ξ˜‚ξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜ξš€ ξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ξšˆ ξ˜„ξš ξ˜ˆξ˜ξš‚, ξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξš‹ξ˜Œ-
ξ˜‰ξ˜ξš ξš­ξ˜Œξ™Ώ ξ˜‰ξšƒ ξšξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜Œξš€ξ™Ώ ξ˜ξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Š ξ˜Žξ˜„ξ˜Œξ˜‹ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜, ξ˜ˆξ˜Šξšƒξ˜ξ˜Œξ™Ώ ξšξ˜Šξ˜†  ξ˜Œξ˜‹ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ ξ˜Žξ˜Šξ˜‹ξšξ˜Šξ˜†ξ˜‡ξšξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Š ξšŠξš†ξ˜‡ξ˜
(ξ˜†ξ˜Œξ˜. 3).
 ξ˜žξ˜‰ξ˜†ξ˜ξš‚ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Šξš‚ ξ˜ξ˜‰ξ˜‡ξ˜Šξšξ˜Šξ˜‹ξšξ˜Šξš‚ ξ˜ŠξšŠξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œ, ξ˜•ξ˜ξšŠξ˜ξš‚ξ˜Žξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Šξ˜‹ ξ˜Žξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜, ξ˜’ξ˜ξ˜ξšξšξšŠξ˜„ξ˜Œξ˜Žξ˜ξ™Ώ ξš…ξšξ˜†ξš€ξ˜‡ξ˜Œξš€
ξ˜Œξšƒξ˜ξ˜ξ™Ώξ˜ ξšξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜‡ξ˜Œξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Œ ξšξ˜Šξ˜„ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜Œξšξ˜ ξš‹ξ˜Œξ˜„ξšˆξš€  ξ˜ŠξšŠξ˜Šξ˜†ξšξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜ξšξ˜ ξ˜ƒξ˜Šξ˜†ξš€ξ˜‚ξ˜Œξ˜‹ ξ˜‰ξ˜Šξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ˜ξšξ˜ξšŠξš‹ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξ˜ξ˜‹. -
ξ˜„ξ˜Œξ˜Žξ˜ ξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ˜„ξš€ ξš‹ξ˜Œξ˜„ξšˆξš€,  ξ˜Œξ˜‹ξ˜ξš ξš­ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜Š ξ˜‰ξ˜Šξ˜ˆξ˜Šξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜Šξ˜ˆξ˜ ξ˜Œξšƒξ˜Žξ˜ξšξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜Œξšξ˜ξ˜…ξ˜Œξ˜Œ. ξ˜—ξšŠξ˜ξ˜ξšξ˜ξ˜‚ξ˜ξšξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξšˆ ξš‹ξ˜Œ-
ξ˜„ξšˆξ˜ξ˜‹ ξ˜Œξšƒξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜ξšξšˆ ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜Š ξ˜Žξ˜Šξ˜‹ξšξ˜Šξ˜†ξ˜‡ξ˜ξšŠξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œξšƒβ€” ξ˜ƒξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜‰ξšξš†ξ˜ ξ™Ώξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜Œξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œξ˜Žξ˜Œ, ξ˜Šξšξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ˆξ˜ξ˜„ξš€ξš ξš­ξ˜Œξ˜
ξ˜Žξ˜ξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜Š ξš‹ξ˜Œξšξšξ˜Œ ξ˜„ξš ξ˜ˆξ˜ξš‚. ξš’ξ˜Šξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜ξšŠξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξšˆ ξ˜‰ξšƒξš‹ξ˜Œξ˜„ξšˆξ˜ ξš€ξ˜‰ξ˜„ξš€ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ξš€ ξ˜Šξ˜ˆξšξ˜Šξš‚ ξ˜Œξšξšƒξ˜Šξ˜ξšξ˜Šξ˜‰ξšξš†ξ™Ώ ξšξšξš‹ξ˜ˆ,
ξ˜ξšƒξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξšξšξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξšˆ  ξšξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜Šξ˜†ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξš€ ξ˜‰ξ˜„ξ˜Œξš€ξ˜ξ˜‡ ξšξ˜ξšƒξ˜‹ξ˜Šξ˜ˆξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜Œ ξš„ξ˜Žξ˜Šξšξ˜Šξ˜‹ξ˜Œξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Š ξšξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜ξ˜ˆξ˜ξšξ˜Œξš€ ξ˜„ξš -
ξ˜ˆξ˜ξš‚ , ξ˜‚ξ˜‡ξ˜Š ξ˜Šξ˜‚ξ˜ξšξšˆ ξ˜‰ξ˜ξš‹ξšξ˜Š,ξšƒβ€” ξšξ˜ξšƒξ˜ƒξ˜Šξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξšˆ ξ˜Žξšƒξ˜ξ˜Šξšξ˜ˆξ˜ξšξ˜Œξš  ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‹ξšˆξ˜Œ ξ˜Œξšƒξ˜†ξ˜Šξš‹ξ˜ˆξ˜ξšξ˜Œξš  ξ˜ˆξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ξš‚.
ξš’ξ˜Š ξ˜‹ξšξ˜ξšξ˜Œξš  ξ˜†ξš€ξ˜ˆξ˜ ξ˜Œξ˜ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜ξš‚, ξ˜Œξ˜ξšξ˜Šξ˜„ξšˆξšξšξ˜ξ˜‹ξš†ξš‚ ξšξ˜Šξ˜Žξ˜ξšξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆ ξ˜ŠξšŠξ˜ξ˜ξšξ˜ξ˜‚ξ˜ξšξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œ
ξš‹ξ˜Œξ˜„ξšˆξ˜ξ˜‹ « ξšξ˜‚ξ˜Œξ˜‡ξš†ξ˜‰ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ ξ˜Žξ˜ξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜Š ξš‹ξ˜Œξ˜„ξšˆξš€, ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜Ž  ξ˜‰ξšƒ  ξšξ˜„ξ˜Šξš­ξ˜ξ˜ˆξšˆ ξš‹ξ˜Œξ˜„ξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Š 
ξ˜‰ξ˜Žξ˜„ξš ξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ξš€ ξ˜ξ˜‰ξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜Œξš‚ξšξ˜Šξ˜ ξ˜Œξšƒξšξ˜ξšŠξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜Šξšξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜ξšξšξ˜Šξ˜ ξš‹ξ˜Œξ˜„ξšˆξ˜, ξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ˜„ξš€ ξ˜Žξ˜Šξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Š ξ˜‰ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜Œξ˜Žξ˜ ξ˜‰ξšƒξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜Œξ˜Šξšξ˜ξ™Ώ
ξš‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜Š ξ˜Ÿξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜Žξ˜Β» (ξ˜›ξ˜Šξšξ˜ˆξ˜†ξ˜Œξšξ˜, 2ξš‰21: 115).  ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ξšˆ ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜ξš€ ξ˜ŠξšŠξ˜ξ˜ξšξ˜ξ˜‚ξ˜ξšξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξšˆ ξš‹ξ˜Œξ˜„ξšˆξ˜ξ˜‹
 ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜ˆξš†ξ˜‰ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ξš€  ξšŠξ˜Šξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜ ξšξ˜ξšŠξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜Šξšξ˜Šξ˜„ξšξ˜‚ξšξ˜Š, Β«ξ˜Œξšξ˜‹ξ˜ξšξ˜ξšξ˜Œξ˜ ξš‹ξ˜Œξ˜„ξ˜Œξš­ξšξ˜Šξš‚ ξ˜ŠξšŠξ˜ξ˜ξšξ˜ξ˜‚ξ˜ξš-
ξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œ ξšξ˜ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξš€ ξ˜‰ξšƒξš‡ξš–ξ˜— ξ˜ξšξš­ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜ξšξšξ˜Š ξšξ˜ξ˜‡ξšξšξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜Š ξ˜ˆξ˜Œξšξ˜ξ˜‹ξ˜Œξ˜Žξ˜ ξ˜‰ξšƒξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ˆξšξ˜ξ˜‹ ξ˜ˆξ˜„ξš€ ξ˜’ξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Œξ˜Œ,
ξ˜‚ξ˜‡ξ˜Š ξ˜ƒξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜Šξ˜†ξ˜Œξ˜‡ ξ˜Šξšƒξšξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξ˜Œ ξ˜Šξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜‰ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξš€ ξš‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜Š ξ˜Ÿξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜Žξ˜Β» (ξ˜›ξ˜Šξšξ˜ˆξ˜†ξ˜Œξšξ˜, 2ξš‰21: 115).
Государство, граТданскоС общСство ΠΈξ˜›ΡΡ‚Π°Π±ΠΈΠ»ΡŒΠ½ΠΎΡΡ‚ΡŒ 79
ξ˜’ξ˜Œξ˜ξšξšξ˜Šξ˜Ž 3ξšƒβ€” ξš‡ξ˜Šξ˜„ξš€ ξ˜ŠξšŠξš­ξ˜ξš‚ ξšξ˜„ξ˜Šξš­ξ˜ξ˜ˆξ˜Œ, ξ˜ŠξšŠξ˜Šξ˜†ξšξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜ξšξšξ˜Šξš‚ ξšŠξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜ξ˜‹ξ˜Œ ξ˜…ξ˜Œξ˜‰ξ˜Œξ˜„ξ˜Œξšξ˜ξ˜…ξ˜Œξ˜Œ, 2ξš‰22 ξ˜ƒ., %
Figure 3ξšƒβ€”  e share ofξšƒthe total area equipped with the beneξš™ ts ofξšƒcivilization, 2ξš‰22, %
ξ˜šξ˜ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜Œ ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜Žξš‹ξ˜ ξ˜Šξ˜‡ξ˜‹ξ˜ξ˜‚ξ˜ξš ξ˜‡, ξ˜‚ξ˜‡ξ˜Š Β«ξ˜ˆξ˜Šξšξ˜Šξ˜„ξšξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜Šξ˜ ξšξ˜Œξšξ˜ξšξ˜ξ˜Œξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξ˜ ξ˜†ξ˜-
ξ˜ƒξ˜Œξ˜Šξšξ˜Šξ˜‰ ξš‡ξš–ξ˜— ξ˜ξšƒ2ξš‰14 ξ˜ƒ. ξšξ˜ξšƒξ˜ξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜‡ ξ˜ƒξ˜Šξ˜ξšξ˜ˆξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜ξšξšξš†ξ™Ώ ξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜‹ξ˜‹  ξ˜Šξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξ˜„ξ˜Šξ˜ξšˆ ξšξ˜ξšƒξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜
ξš‹ξ˜Œξ˜„ξ˜Œξš­ξšξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Š  ξš‡ξš–ξ˜—, ξ˜Žξ˜Šξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜†ξš†ξš‚ ξšξ˜Šξšƒξšξ˜ˆξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξš†ξ˜‹ ξšξ˜Šξ˜Žξ˜ξšξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξš€ξ˜‹ ξ˜ŠξšŠξ˜ξ˜ξšξ˜ξ˜‚ξ˜ξšξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œ ξš‹ξ˜Œ-
ξ˜„ξšˆξ˜ξ˜‹ ξšξ˜Œξš‹ξ˜ ξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ˆξšξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Œξš‚ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Š ξšξ˜Šξ˜Žξ˜ξšξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξš€Β» (Π¨Π½Π΅ΠΉΠ΄Π΅Ρ€ΠΌΠ°Π½, 2023: 53). ξ˜’ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜Œξšξšξ˜ξ˜‹ξš†ξ˜
ξšξ˜ξ˜…ξ˜Œξ˜Šξšξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξš†ξ˜ ξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜‡ξš† « ξ˜ξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜ŠξšŠξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜Œ ξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξš ξ˜‰ξ˜Šξšξ˜‹ξ˜Šξš‹ξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ξš‚ ξ˜ˆξ˜„ξš€ ξšξ˜†ξ˜Œξ˜ŠξšŠξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜-
ξšξ˜Œξš€ ξš‹ξ˜Œξ˜„ξšˆξš€ ξ˜†ξš€ξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ˜‰ξš†ξ˜‹ξ˜Œ ξ˜ƒξ˜†ξ˜ξš‹ξ˜ˆξ˜ξšξ˜ξ˜‹ξ˜Œ,  ξšξ˜Šξ˜‰ξš†ξ˜ξ˜Œξ˜„ξ˜Œ ξšξ˜†ξ˜Œξ˜‰ξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξšˆ ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜Œξ˜Šξšξ˜ ξ˜ˆξ˜„ξš€
ξšξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜ξšξ˜…ξ˜ξ˜‰,  ξ˜ŠξšŠξ˜ξ˜ξšξ˜ξ˜‚ξ˜Œξ˜„ξ˜Œ ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜†ξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜†ξ˜Œξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξšξš  ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξšξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ˜‰ξšξš  ξ˜‹ξ˜ŠξšŠξ˜Œξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξšˆ ξ˜‰ξšƒξšξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ˆξ˜-
ξ˜„ξ˜ξ™Ώ ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜Œξ˜Šξšξ˜Β» (Π”ΡŒΡΡ‡Π΅Π½ΠΊΠΎ, 2022: 2010).
ξ˜ξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξš†ξ˜ ξšξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜Œξš€ ξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξš‹ξ˜Œξ˜‰ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξš€, ξšξ˜Œξšξ˜Žξ˜Œξš‚ ξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜ξšξšˆ ξš‹ξ˜Œξšξšξ˜Œ ξ˜Œξšƒξ˜Šξ˜‡ξ˜ξšξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜Œξ˜ ξšŠξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜Š-
ξšξ˜†ξ˜Œξš€ξ˜‡ξšξš†ξ™Ώ ξšξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜ξšξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜‡ξ˜Œξ˜‰ ξš€ξ˜‰ξ˜„ξš€ξš ξ˜‡ξ˜ξš€ ξ˜Šξ˜ξšξ˜Šξ˜‰ξšξš†ξ˜‹ξ˜Œ ξšξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ˆξšξ˜Šξ˜ξš†ξ˜„ξ˜Žξ˜ξ˜‹ξ˜Œ ξ˜ˆξ˜ξ˜‹ξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜†ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Š-
ξ˜ƒξ˜Š Β«ξ˜ξš‹ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œξš€Β» ξ˜‰ξšƒξ˜ˆξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜ξ˜‰ξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜‚ξšξš†ξ™Ώ ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜Œξ˜Šξšξ˜ξ™Ώ. ξ˜™ξšƒξšξ˜ξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜„ξš 2ξš‰23 ξ˜ƒ.  ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜ ξšξ˜ξ˜‹ξ˜ξ˜‡ξšξ˜Š
ξ˜‰ξš†ξ˜ξ˜Šξ˜Žξ˜Šξš‚ ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜ξšξšξ˜ξš€ ξšξšŠξš†ξ˜„ξšˆ ξšξ˜ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξš€, ξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Šξ˜„ξšˆξ˜Žξš ξ˜†ξ˜Šξš‹ξ˜ˆξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‹ξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξšˆ  ξ˜‰ξšƒξ˜ξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Šξš€ξšξ˜Œξ˜Œ
Β«ξšξ˜ŠξšŠξ˜ξ˜ˆξ˜Œξ˜‡ξšˆΒ» ξ˜ξ˜‹ξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜‡ξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξšˆ (ξ˜Œξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜„ξš ξ˜‚ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξ˜ ξ˜ξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜‰ξ˜„ξš€ξš ξ˜‡ ξ˜„ξ˜Œξš‘ξšˆ ξ˜’ξ˜ξ˜ξšξšξšŠξ˜„ξ˜Œξ˜Žξ˜ ξ˜ξ˜ξ™Ώξ˜ ξ˜Œξšƒξšžξšξ˜Žξ˜Šξ˜‡-
, ξ˜ƒξ˜ˆξ˜ ξ˜†ξ˜Šξš‹ξ˜ˆξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‹ξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξšˆ ξ˜‰ξš†ξš‘ξ˜ ξ˜ξ˜‹ξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜‡ξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œ), ξ˜ξšƒ ξ˜‹ξ˜Œξ˜ƒξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜…ξ˜Œξ˜Šξšξšξš†ξ˜‹ ξšξ˜†ξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜Žξ˜Šξ˜‹  ξšξ˜ˆξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ξš€
ξšξ˜Šξ˜Žξ˜†ξš†ξ˜‡ξšˆ ξ˜‰ξ˜Šξšξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ξš ξš­ξ˜Œξš‚ ξ˜Šξ˜‡ξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜Ž. ξ˜—ξ˜‚ξ˜ξšξšˆ ξ˜‰ξš†ξ˜ξ˜Šξ˜Žξ˜ ξ˜‹ξ˜Œξ˜ƒξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜…ξ˜Œξ˜Šξšξšξ˜ξš€ ξšξšŠξš†ξ˜„ξšˆ ξ˜‰ξšƒξ˜™ξ˜ξ˜‹ξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Šξ˜‹
Society andξ˜›Security Insights β„– 3 2024 80
ξ˜Žξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜, ξ˜žξ˜‰ξ˜†ξ˜ξš‚ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Šξš‚ ξ˜ξ˜‰ξ˜‡ξ˜Šξšξ˜Šξ˜‹ξšξ˜Šξš‚ ξ˜Œξšƒξ˜ξ˜ξ™Ώξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜Œξšξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Šξš‚ ξ˜ŠξšŠξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ξš€ξ™Ώξšƒβ€”  ξ˜‰ξšƒξ˜†ξ˜ξšξš† ξ˜‰ξš†ξš‘ξ˜ ξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ˆξšξ˜ξš‚
ξšξ˜Šξšƒξš‡ξš–ξ˜—. ξ˜ξ˜ξš‹ξ˜ˆξš ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜‹ ξšξ˜Šξ˜„ξ˜Šξš‹ξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξš†ξ˜‹ ξšξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜‹ ξš€ξ˜‰ξ˜„ξš€ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ξš€ ξ˜‡ξ˜Š, ξ˜‚ξ˜‡ξ˜Š ξ˜‰ξ˜Šξšƒξ˜‰ξ˜ξ˜ξ™Ώ ξ˜ˆξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜ξ˜‰ξ˜Š-
ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜‚ξšξš†ξ™Ώ ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜Œξ˜Šξšξ˜ξ™Ώ ξšξ˜ξšƒ2ξš‰22–2ξš‰23 ξ˜ƒξ˜ƒ. ξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜Œξšξ˜Šξš‘ξ˜„ξ˜Š ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξš‹ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξ˜ ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜ξšξšξ˜Šξš‚ ξšξšŠξš†ξ˜„ξ˜Œ -
ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξš€ (ξš’ξ˜Šξ˜„ξš€ξšξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜ξš€, 2ξš‰24: 74).
ξ˜Ÿξ˜ξš‹ξšξ˜ξš‚ξš‘ξ˜ξš‚ ξ™Ώξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜Œξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œξ˜Žξ˜Šξš‚ ξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξšξš€ ξš‹ξ˜Œξšξšξ˜Œ ξš€ξ˜‰ξ˜„ξš€ξš ξ˜‡ξ˜ξš€ ξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ˆξšξ˜ξ˜ˆξšξš‘ξ˜ξ˜‰ξš†ξ˜ -
ξšξ˜ξš‹ξšξš†ξ˜ ξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ™Ώξ˜Šξ˜ˆξš† (ξš‡ξ˜ξ˜‹ξ˜ξšξ˜‡ξšˆξ˜ξ˜‰ξ˜, 2ξš‰23), ξ˜Žξ˜Šξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜†ξš†ξ˜ ξ˜‰ξšƒξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜Œξ˜Šξšξ˜ξ™Ώ ξšξ˜ξ˜‹ξ˜ξ˜‡ξšξ˜Š ξ˜ˆξ˜Œξšξšξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜ξšξ˜…ξ˜Œξ˜†ξ˜Š-
ξ˜‰ξ˜ξšξš† (ξ˜†ξ˜Œξ˜. 4).
ξ˜’ξ˜Œξ˜ξšξšξ˜Šξ˜Ž 4ξšƒβ€” ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜ˆξ˜Œξ˜ξšξšξš†ξš‚ ξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ˆξšξ˜ξ˜ˆξšξš‘ξ˜ξ˜‰ξ˜Šξš‚ ξ˜ˆξ˜ξšξ˜ξš‹ξšξš†ξš‚ ξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ™Ώξ˜Šξ˜ˆ ξšξ˜ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξš€, 2ξš‰22 ξ˜ƒ., ξ˜‡ξš†ξ˜. ξ˜†ξšξšŠ. ξ˜‰ξšƒξ˜‹ξ˜ξ˜ξš€ξ˜…
Figure 4ξšƒβ€”  e median per capita monetary income ofξšƒthe population, 2ξš‰22, thousand rubles per month
, ξ˜‹ξ˜ξ˜ˆξ˜Œξ˜ξšξšξš†ξš‚ ξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ˆξšξ˜ξ˜ˆξšξš‘ξ˜ξ˜‰ξ˜Šξš‚ ξ˜ˆξ˜ξšξ˜ξš‹ξšξš†ξš‚ ξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ™Ώξ˜Šξ˜ˆ ξšξ˜ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξš€ ξšξ˜Šξ˜ˆξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜ξ˜†ξš‹ξ˜ˆξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡,
ξ˜‚ξ˜‡ξ˜Š ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‹ξš†ξ˜‹ξ˜Œ ξšξ˜†ξ˜ŠξšŠξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜‹ξšξš†ξ˜‹ξ˜Œ ξ˜ξšƒξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜‚ξ˜Žξ˜Œ ξšξ˜†ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξš€ ξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξšξš€ ξš‹ξ˜Œξšξšξ˜Œ ξšξ˜ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξš€ ξš€ξ˜‰ξ˜„ξš€ξš ξ˜‡ξ˜ξš€ ξ˜žξ˜‰-
ξ˜†ξ˜ξš‚ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜ξš€ ξ˜ξ˜‰ξ˜‡ξ˜Šξšξ˜Šξ˜‹ξšξ˜ξš€ ξ˜ŠξšŠξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ξšˆ, ξ˜•ξ˜ξšŠξ˜ξš‚ξ˜Žξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Œξš‚ ξ˜Žξ˜†ξ˜ξš‚ ξ˜Œξšƒξ˜’ξ˜ξ˜ξšξšξšŠξ˜„ξ˜Œξ˜Žξ˜ ξš…ξšξ˜†ξš€ξ˜‡ξ˜Œξš€. ξš›ξ˜‡ξ˜Œ ξ˜†ξ˜-
ξ˜ƒξ˜Œξ˜Šξšξš† ξ˜Œξ˜‹ξ˜ξš ξ˜‡ ξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ˆξšξ˜Œξ˜ ξ˜ˆξ˜ξšξ˜ξš‹ξšξš†ξ˜ ξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ™Ώξ˜Šξ˜ˆξš† ξ˜‰ξšƒξ˜ŠξšŠξššξ˜ξ˜‹ξ˜ξ™Ώ ξšξ˜ξ˜‹ξ˜ξ˜‡ξšξ˜Š ξšξ˜Œξš‹ξ˜ ξ˜ŠξšŠξš­ξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Œξš‚ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Š-
ξ˜ƒξ˜Š ξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξšξš€. ξš›ξ˜‡ξ˜Œ ξš‹ξ˜ ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜Œ ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜Œξ˜Šξšξ˜ ξ˜‰ξš†ξ˜ˆξ˜ξ˜„ξš€ξš ξ˜‡ξ˜ξš€ ξšξ˜ξ˜‹ξ˜ξ˜‡ξšξ˜Š ξ˜‰ξš†ξ˜ξ˜Šξ˜Žξ˜Œξ˜‹ ξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξšξ˜ξ˜‹ ξšŠξ˜ξ˜ˆξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œ
ξšξ˜ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξš€ ξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ˆξ˜Œ ξ˜‰ξ˜ξ˜ξ™Ώ ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜Œξ˜Šξšξ˜Šξ˜‰ ξš‡ξš–ξ˜— (ξš’ξ˜Šξ˜„ξš€ξšξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜ξš€, 2ξš‰24: 77). ξš’ξ˜†ξ˜Œξ˜‚ξ˜Œξš ξš„ξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜‹ξš ξ˜‹ξšξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Š:
ξ˜Œξšƒξšξ˜ξ˜‰ξš†ξ˜ξ˜Šξ˜Žξ˜Œξš‚ ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ξšξ˜†ξ˜ξšξš†ξš‚ ξšξ˜Šξ˜‡ξ˜ξšξ˜…ξ˜Œξ˜ξ˜„, ξ˜Œξšƒξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜ŠξšŠξ˜ξšξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œ ξ˜Šξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜‰ξ˜Šξš‚ ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξšξ˜Žξ˜‡ξšξ˜†ξš† ξš„ξ˜Žξ˜Šξšξ˜Š-
ξ˜‹ξ˜Œξ˜Žξ˜Œ, ξ˜Œξšƒξšξ˜Œξšξ˜Žξ˜Šξ˜ ξ˜Žξ˜ξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜Š ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜Œξ˜Šξšξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Š ξ˜‹ξ˜ξšξ˜ξ˜ˆξš‹ξ˜‹ξ˜ξšξ˜‡ξ˜, ξ˜Œξšƒξ˜†ξš€ξ˜ˆ ξ˜ˆξ˜†ξšξ˜ƒξ˜Œξ™Ώ ξšξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜‰.
ξ˜Ÿξš†ξ˜ξ˜Šξ˜Ž ξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜ξšξšˆ ξ˜ξ˜Šξ˜…ξ˜Œξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜Šξš‚ ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜ξ˜…ξ˜Œξ˜Œ ξ˜‰ξšƒξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜Œξ˜Šξšξ˜ξ™Ώ (ξ˜‡ξ˜ξšŠξ˜„. 5).
 ξ˜’ξ˜ξ˜ξšξšξšŠξ˜„ξ˜Œξ˜Žξ˜ ξš…ξšξ˜†ξš€ξ˜‡ξ˜Œξš€, ξ˜•ξ˜ξšŠξ˜ξš‚ξ˜Žξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Šξ˜‹ ξ˜Žξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ ξ˜Œξšƒξ˜žξ˜‰ξ˜†ξ˜ξš‚ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Šξš‚ ξ˜ξ˜‰ξ˜‡ξ˜Šξšξ˜Šξ˜‹ξšξ˜Šξš‚ ξ˜ŠξšŠξ˜„ξ˜-
ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œ ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜Šξš‹ξ˜Œξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜ξšˆ ξšξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜‰ξš†ξš‘ξ˜ξš ξš­ξ˜ξš€ ξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ˆξšξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Œξš‚ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Œξš‚ ξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜ξšξšˆ ξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ˜„ξš€ ξšξ˜ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξš€, ξ˜Œξ˜‹ξ˜ξš -
ξš­ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜Š ξ˜Žξ˜†ξ˜ξš‚ξšξ˜  ξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ˆξšξ˜ξ˜ˆξšξš‘ξ˜ξ˜‰ξš†ξ˜ ξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ™Ώξ˜Šξ˜ˆξš† (ξ˜Šξ˜‡ 7 ξ˜ˆξ˜Šξšƒ19 ξ˜‡ξš†ξ˜. ξ˜†ξšξšŠ. ξ˜‰ξšƒξ˜‹ξ˜ξ˜ξš€ξ˜…). ξ˜œξ˜ξ˜Žξš‹ξ˜
ξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ˜„ξš€ ξšξ˜ξ˜ŒξšŠξ˜Šξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜ ξ˜Œξ˜‹ξšξš­ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜ξšξšξ˜Š ξ˜ŠξšŠξ˜ξ˜ξšξ˜ξ˜‚ξ˜ξšξšξš†ξ™Ώ ξ˜ƒξ˜†ξ˜ξš‹ξ˜ˆξ˜ξš ( ξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ™Ώξ˜Šξ˜ˆξ˜ξ˜‹ξ˜Œ ξ˜ξ˜‰ξš†ξš‘ξ˜ 6ξš‰ ξ˜‡ξš†ξ˜.
Государство, граТданскоС общСство ΠΈξ˜›ΡΡ‚Π°Π±ΠΈΠ»ΡŒΠ½ΠΎΡΡ‚ΡŒ 81
ξ˜†ξšξšŠ. ξ˜‰ξšƒξ˜‹ξ˜ξ˜ξš€ξ˜…) ξ˜‰ξšƒξš„ξ˜‡ξ˜Œξ™Ώ ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜ξ™Ώ ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜Œξ˜Šξšξ˜ξ™Ώ ξ˜ξšξš­ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜ξšξšξ˜Š ξšξ˜Œξš‹ξ˜, ξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜‹ ξ˜‰ξšƒξ˜ˆξ˜†ξšξ˜ƒξ˜Œξ™Ώ ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜Œξ˜Šξšξ˜ξ™Ώ ξš‡ξš–ξ˜—
ξ˜Œξšƒξ˜‰ξšƒξ˜…ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜Šξ˜‹ ξšξ˜Šξšƒξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜ξšξ˜. ξš›ξ˜‡ξ˜Š ξ˜ξ˜‰ξ˜Œξ˜ˆξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξšξ˜ξ˜‡ ξ˜‰ξšƒξ˜…ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜Šξ˜‹ ξ˜Šξšƒξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜‰ξšξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜Š ξšŠξ˜Šξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜ ξšξ˜Œξšξ˜Žξ˜Šξ˜‹
ξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξšξ˜ ξš‹ξ˜Œξšξšξ˜Œ ξ˜‰ξšƒξš„ξ˜‡ξ˜Œξ™Ώ ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜ξ™Ώ ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜Œξ˜Šξšξ˜ξ™Ώ.
ξ˜œξ˜ξšŠξ˜„ξ˜Œξ˜…ξ˜ 5.
ξ˜’ξ˜ξ˜ξšξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ˆξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξ˜ ξ˜‚ξ˜Œξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜ξšξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œ ξšξ˜ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξš€ ξšξ˜Šξšƒξ˜‰ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜Œξ˜‚ξ˜Œξšξ˜
ξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ˆξšξ˜ξ˜ˆξšξš‘ξ˜ξ˜‰ξš†ξ™Ώ ξ˜ˆξ˜ξšξ˜ξš‹ξšξš†ξ™Ώ ξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ™Ώξ˜Šξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ˜‰, 2ξš‰22 ξ˜ƒ.
Table 5.
Distribution ofξšƒthe population by per capita monetary income, 2ξš‰22
Π Π΅Π³ΠΈΠΎΠ½Ρ‹
Π’Π΅Π»ΠΈΡ‡ΠΈΠ½Π° ΡΡ€Π΅Π΄Π½Π΅Π΄ΡƒΡˆΠ΅Π²Ρ‹Ρ… Π΄Π΅Π½Π΅ΠΆΠ½Ρ‹Ρ… Π΄ΠΎΡ…ΠΎΠ΄ΠΎΠ², тыс.Ρ€ΡƒΠ±.
Π²ξ˜ŸΠΌΠ΅ΡΡΡ†
≀ 7,0
7,1 ≀10,0
10,1 ≀14,0
14,1 ≀19,0
19,1 ≀27,0
27,1 ≀45,0
45,1 ≀60,0
β‰₯
60,1
ξ˜’ξ˜ξ˜ξšξšξšŠξ˜„ξ˜Œξ˜Žξ˜ ξš…ξšξ˜†ξš€ξ˜‡ξ˜Œξš€ 2,0 4,6 9,6 14,2 20,8 28,2 10,3 10,3
ξ˜’ξ˜ξ˜ξšξšξšŠξ˜„ξ˜Œξ˜Žξ˜ ξ˜ξ˜ξ™Ώξ˜ (ξš£ξ˜Žξšξ˜‡ξ˜Œξš€) 0,7 1,7 3,9 6,8 12,6 25,6 14,9 33,8
ξ˜•ξ˜ξšŠξ˜ξš‚ξ˜Žξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Œξš‚ ξ˜Žξ˜†ξ˜ξš‚ 1,4 3,6 8,2 13,1 20,5 29,8 11,5 11,9
ξ˜™ξ˜ξ˜‹ξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Œξš‚ ξ˜Žξ˜†ξ˜ξš‚ 0,1 0,5 1,6 3,8 9,3 24,8 17,2 42,7
ξš’ξ˜†ξ˜Œξ˜‹ξ˜Šξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Œξš‚ ξ˜Žξ˜†ξ˜ξš‚ 0,6 1,9 4,8 8,8 16,3 30,1 15,0 22,5
ξ˜”ξ˜ξšŠξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Œξš‚ ξ˜Žξ˜†ξ˜ξš‚ 0,3 1,1 3,5 7,1 14,6 30,4 16,5 26,5
ξ˜˜ξ˜‹ξšξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜ξš€ ξ˜ŠξšŠξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ξšˆ 1,2 2,8 6,1 9,8 16,5 28,2 13,7 21,7
ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜ξ˜ˆξ˜ξšξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜ξš€ ξ˜ŠξšŠξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ξšˆ 0,1 0,3 1,0 2,3 5,7 17,3 14,2 59,1
ξ˜ξ˜ξ™Ώξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜Œξšξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜ξš€ ξ˜ŠξšŠξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ξšˆ 0,2 0,7 2,1 4,2 9,3 22,9 15,7 44,9
ξ˜žξ˜‰ξ˜†ξ˜ξš‚ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜ξš€ ξ˜ξ˜‰ξ˜‡ξ˜Šξšξ˜Šξ˜‹ξšξ˜ξš€ -
ξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ξšˆ 0,5 2,1 6,4 12,4 22,2 33,9 12,3 10,2
ξšžξšξ˜Žξ˜Šξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Œξš‚ ξ˜ξ˜‰ξ˜‡ξ˜Šξšξ˜Šξ˜‹ξšξš†ξš‚ ξ˜Šξ˜Žξ˜†ξšξ˜ƒ 0,1 0,2 0,7 1,7 4,5 14,3 12,5 66,0
ξ˜’ξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Œξš‚ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜ξš€ ξš–ξ˜ξ˜ˆξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜…ξ˜Œξš€ 1,4 3,0 6,2 9,7 16,1 27,4 13,5 22,7
ξ˜— ξ˜Žξ˜†ξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜Œξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Œ ξ˜‰ξš†ξ˜ξ˜Šξ˜Žξ˜Šξ˜‹ ξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξšξ˜ ξšŠξ˜ξ˜ˆξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œ ξš‹ξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜ξš‚ ξš…ξšξ˜†ξš€ξ˜‡ξ˜Œξ˜Œ, ξ˜•ξ˜ξšŠξ˜ξš‚ξ˜Žξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Š
ξ˜Žξ˜†ξ˜ξš€ ξ˜Œξšƒξ˜žξ˜‰ξ˜†ξ˜ξš‚ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Šξš‚ ξ˜ξ˜‰ξ˜‡ξ˜Šξšξ˜Šξ˜‹ξšξ˜Šξš‚ ξ˜ŠξšŠξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œ ξ˜ξ˜‰ξ˜Œξ˜ˆξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξšξš ξ˜‡ ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜Žξš‹ξ˜ ξšξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜‹ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξš† ξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ˆ-
ξšξ˜ξ˜ˆξšξš‘ξ˜ξ˜‰ξš†ξ™Ώ ξšξ˜Šξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜ξšŠξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Œξ™Ώ ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ξ™Ώξ˜Šξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ˜‰ (ξ˜†ξ˜Œξ˜. 5). ξš¨ξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜Œ ξš„ξ˜‡ξ˜Œξ™Ώ ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜ξ™Ώ ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜Œξ˜Šξšξ˜Šξ˜‰ ξ˜‰ξšƒξšξšξ˜-
ξ˜‚ξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜Š ξ˜‹ξ˜ξšξšˆξš‘ξ˜ξš‚ ξ˜‹ξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜, ξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜‹ ξ˜‰ξšƒξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξš†ξ™Ώ ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜Œξ˜Šξšξ˜ξ™Ώ ξš‡ξš–ξ˜— ξ˜Œξšƒξ˜‰ξšƒξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ˆξšξ˜ξ˜‹ ξšξ˜Šξšƒξ˜’ξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Œξ˜Œ,
ξ˜Œξ˜‹ξ˜ξš ξ˜‡ ξ˜‰ξ˜Šξšξ˜‹ξ˜Šξš‹ξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œ ξšξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜Šξ˜†ξš€ξ˜‡ξšˆ ξ˜ξ˜‰ξ˜Šξ˜Œ ξšξ˜Šξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜ξšŠξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Œξ˜ ξšξ˜ξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜ξš†, ξšξ˜†ξ˜Œξ˜ŠξšŠξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜‡ξšˆ
ξ˜‰ξ˜ξš‹ξšξš†ξ˜ ξš‹ξ˜Œξšξšξ˜ξšξšξš†ξ˜ ξšŠξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜. , ξšξ˜Šξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜ξšŠξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Œξ˜ ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ξ™Ώξ˜Šξ˜ˆξš† ξš‹ξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜ξš‚ ξ˜žξ˜‰ξ˜†ξ˜ξš‚ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Šξš‚ ξ˜ξ˜‰-
ξ˜‡ξ˜Šξšξ˜Šξ˜‹ξšξ˜Šξš‚ ξ˜ŠξšŠξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œ ξ˜Œξšƒξ˜•ξ˜ξšŠξ˜ξš‚ξ˜Žξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Š ξ˜Žξ˜†ξ˜ξš€ ξ˜‰ξšƒ2 ξ˜†ξ˜ξšξ˜ ξšξ˜Œξš‹ξ˜, ξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜‹ ξ˜‰ξšƒξ˜ξ˜ξ™Ώξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜Œξšξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Šξš‚ ξ˜ŠξšŠξ˜„ξ˜-
ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œ, ξ˜Œξšƒξšξ˜Šξ˜‚ξ˜‡ξ˜Œ ξšξ˜ξšƒ3ξš‰% ξšξ˜Œξš‹ξ˜ ξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ˆξšξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Œξš‚ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Œξ™Ώ.
ξ˜ξšξš­ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜ξšξšξ˜ξš€ ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜ξ˜…ξ˜Œξš€ ξšξ˜Šξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜ξšŠξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Œξ™Ώ ξ˜‰ξ˜Šξšξ˜‹ξ˜Šξš‹ξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ξš‚ ξšξ˜ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξš€ ξ˜‰ξ˜Šξšƒξ˜‹ξšξ˜Š-
ξ˜ƒξ˜Šξ˜‹ ξ˜ŠξšŠξšξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜„ξ˜ξšξ˜ ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ξ™Ώξ˜Šξš‹ξ˜ˆξ˜ξšξ˜Œξš€ξ˜‹ξ˜Œ ξ˜‰ξšƒξ˜Šξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜‰ξ˜Šξš‚ ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξšξ˜Žξ˜‡ξšξ˜†ξ˜ ξ˜Ÿξ˜’ξš’, ξ˜Œξšξ˜‰ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œξ˜…ξ˜Œξš€ξ™Ώ ξ˜‰ξšƒξ˜Šξ˜ξšξ˜Šξ˜‰-
ξšξ˜Šξš‚ ξ˜Žξ˜ξšξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„ ξ˜Œξšƒξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜Œξšξ˜‰ξ˜Šξ˜ˆξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œ ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξšξ˜ˆξ˜. ξš›ξ˜‡ξ˜Œξ˜‹ ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜Žξš‹ξ˜ ξ˜Šξšξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ˆξ˜ξ˜„ξš€ξš ξ˜‡ξ˜ξš€ ξ˜Œξšƒξšξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜‹ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξš†
Society andξ˜›Security Insights β„– 3 2024 82
ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ξ™Ώξ˜Šξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ˜‰ ξšξ˜ξšƒξšξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξ˜:  ξšξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜‰ξ˜Œξ˜„ξ˜Š, ξ˜‰ξšƒξšŠξ˜ξ˜ˆξšξš†ξ™Ώ ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜Œξ˜Šξšξ˜ξ™Ώ ξ˜‰ξšƒξšŠξš ξ˜ˆξš‹ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ ξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ˆξšξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œξ˜‚ξ˜-
ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Š ξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ˜‹ξ˜Šξ™Ώξ˜Šξšξš€ξš‚ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜ ξ˜‰ξš†ξ˜ξ˜Šξ˜Žξ˜ ξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ˜„ξš€ ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ξ™Ώξ˜Šξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ˜‰ ξšξ˜ξšƒξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜Šξ˜„ξšˆξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜ξšξšξš†ξ˜ ξšξšξš‹ξ˜ˆξš† (ξ˜†ξ˜Œξ˜. 6).
ξ˜’ξ˜Œξ˜ξšξšξ˜Šξ˜Ž 5ξšƒβ€” ξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ˆξšξ˜ξ˜ˆξšξš‘ξ˜ξ˜‰ξš†ξ˜ ξšξ˜Šξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜ξšŠξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Œξ˜ ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ξ™Ώξ˜Šξ˜ˆξš†, 2ξš‰22 ξ˜ƒ., ξ˜‡ξš†ξ˜. ξ˜†ξšξšŠ. ξ˜‰ξšƒξ˜‹ξ˜ξ˜ξš€ξ˜…
Figure 5ξšƒβ€” Average per capita consumer spending, 2ξš‰22, thousand rubles per month
ξ˜’ξ˜Œξ˜ξšξšξ˜Šξ˜Ž 6ξšƒβ€” ξš‡ξ˜Šξ˜„ξš€ ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ξ™Ώξ˜Šξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ˜‰ ξšŠξš ξ˜ˆξš‹ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ ξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ˜‹ξ˜Šξ™Ώξ˜Šξšξš€ξš‚ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ ξšξ˜ξšƒξšξ˜Šξ˜Žξšξšξ˜Žξš ξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜ˆξšξ˜Žξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜‰ ξšξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξš€, 2ξš‰22 ξ˜ƒ., %
Figure 6ξšƒβ€”  e share ofξšƒhousehold budget expenditures on food purchases, 2ξš‰22, %
Государство, граТданскоС общСство ΠΈξ˜›ΡΡ‚Π°Π±ΠΈΠ»ΡŒΠ½ΠΎΡΡ‚ΡŒ 83
 ξ˜‹ξšξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Œξ™Ώ ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜Œξ˜Šξšξ˜ξ™Ώ ξš‡ξš–ξ˜— ξ˜‰ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜Œξ˜Žξ˜ ξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ˜„ξš€ ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ξ™Ώξ˜Šξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ˜‰ ξšŠξš ξ˜ˆξš‹ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜‰ ξšξ˜ξšƒ ξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜Šξ˜„ξšˆ-
ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜Œξ˜ (ξ˜Šξ˜Žξ˜Šξ˜„ξ˜Š 4ξš‰%), ξ˜‚ξ˜‡ξ˜Š ξ˜‰ξšƒξ˜‹ξ˜Œξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜Šξš‚ ξšξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜‡ξ˜Œξ˜Žξ˜ ξš€ξ˜‰ξ˜„ξš€ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ξš€ ξšξ˜†ξ˜Œξšξšξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Šξ˜‹ ξ˜‰ξš†ξ˜ξ˜Šξ˜Žξ˜Šξš‚ -
ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œ ξ˜Œξšƒξ˜Žξ˜†ξ˜ξš‚ξšξ˜ ξšξ˜Œξšξ˜Žξ˜Šξš‚ ξš„ξ˜Žξ˜Šξšξ˜Šξ˜‹ξ˜Œξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Šξš‚ ξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξšξšξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œ ξ˜Šξ˜ξšξ˜Šξ˜‰ξšξš†ξ™Ώ ξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜ˆξšξ˜Žξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜‰ ξšξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξš€.
ξ˜—ξšŠξššξ˜ξ˜‹ ξ˜ˆξ˜ξšξ˜ξš‹ξšξš†ξ™Ώ ξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ™Ώξ˜Šξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ˜‰ ξ˜Œξšƒξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‹ξ˜ξš‚ξšξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Š ξšŠξš ξ˜ˆξš‹ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ ξ˜ξšξš­ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜ξšξšξ˜Š ξ˜‰ξ˜„ξ˜Œξš€ξ˜ξ˜‡ ξšξ˜ξšƒ ξ˜ξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜‰
ξ˜Œξšƒ ξšξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜‹ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξš† ξšξ˜Šξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜ξšŠξ˜„ξš€ξ˜ξ˜‹ξš†ξ™Ώ ξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜ˆξšξ˜Žξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜‰ ξšξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξš€. ξš’ξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξ˜ ξšξ˜ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξš€ ξšŠξ˜Šξ˜„ξšˆξš‘ξ˜Œξš-
ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜ ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜Œξ˜Šξšξ˜Šξ˜‰ ξš‡ξš–ξ˜—  ξš€ξ˜‰ξ˜„ξš€ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ξš€ ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜…ξ˜Œξ˜Šξšξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξš†ξ˜‹ ξ˜ξšƒξ˜‹ξ˜ξ˜ˆξ˜Œξ˜…ξ˜Œξšξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Šξš‚ ξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜‚ξ˜Žξ˜Œ ξšξ˜†ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξš€. -
ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜Œ ξ˜‰ξ˜ξ˜ξ™Ώ ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜Œξ˜Šξšξ˜Šξ˜‰ ξšξšξ˜ξ˜‚ξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜Š ξšξ˜ξ˜ˆξ˜Šξšξ˜Šξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜ξšŠξ˜„ξš€ξš ξ˜‡ ξ˜‹ξ˜Šξ˜„ξ˜Šξ˜‚ξšξš†ξ˜ ξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜ˆξšξ˜Žξ˜‡ξš†, ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜Šξš­ξ˜ξšŠξ˜ξ™Ώ-
ξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜‰ξš†ξ˜ ξšξ˜†ξ˜Œ ξ˜ξšξš­ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜ξšξšξ˜Šξ˜‹ ξšξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜ˆξ˜ξšξ˜Œξ˜Œ ξ™Ώξ˜„ξ˜ξšŠξ˜ ξ˜Œξšƒξ˜ξ˜ξ™Ώξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜ (ξš’ξ˜Šξ˜„ξš€ξšξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜ξš€, 2ξš‰24: 79).
 ξ˜†ξš€ξ˜ˆξ˜ ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜Œξ˜Šξšξ˜Šξ˜‰, ξ˜‰ξšƒξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜‹ ξ˜‚ξ˜Œξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜ ξ˜‰ξ˜‰ξ˜Œξ˜ˆξš ξ˜…ξ˜ξšξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜Šξš‚ ξšξ˜ξš„ξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œξ˜‚ξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œ ξ˜ξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜ ξšξ˜ξšƒξšξ˜†ξ˜Š-
ξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜Šξ˜„ξšˆξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜Œξ˜, ξ˜…ξ˜ξšξš† ξšξ˜ξšƒξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜ˆξšξ˜Žξ˜‡ξš† ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜Šξš‹ξ˜Œξ˜„ξ˜Œξ˜ξšˆ ξ˜Šξ˜‚ξ˜ξšξšˆ ξ˜‰ξš†ξ˜ξ˜Šξ˜Žξ˜Œξ˜, ξšξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Šξ˜†ξ˜ξšξ˜‹ξ˜ξ˜†ξšξš†ξ˜ ξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ™Ώξ˜Š-
ξ˜ˆξ˜ξ˜‹, ξšξ˜Šξ˜„ξšξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‹ξš†ξ˜‹ ξ˜‹ξšξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Œξ˜‹ξ˜Œ ξ˜Œξ™Ώ ξš‹ξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξš€ξ˜‹ξ˜Œ (ξ˜‡ξ˜ξšŠξ˜„. 6).
ξ˜œξ˜ξšŠξ˜„ξ˜Œξ˜…ξ˜ 6.
ξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ˆξšξ˜Œξ˜ ξšξ˜Šξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜ξšŠξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Œξ˜ ξ˜…ξ˜ξšξš† ξšξ˜ξšƒξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜ˆξšξ˜Žξ˜‡ξš† ξšξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξš€, ξ˜†ξšξšŠ./ξ˜Žξ˜ƒ*
Table 6.
Average consumer prices for food, RUB/kg
Π Π΅Π³ΠΈΠΎΠ½Ρ‹
Говядина
Π½Π°ξ˜ŸΠΊΠΎΡΡ‚ΠΈ
Π Ρ‹Π±Π° ΠΌΠΎΡ€ΠΎΠΆΠ΅-
ная
Молоко пастС-
Ρ€ΠΈΠ·ΠΎΠ²Π°Π½Π½ΠΎΠ΅
Π―ΠΉΡ†ΠΎ ΠΊΡƒΡ€ΠΈΠ½ΠΎΠ΅
(10 ΡˆΡ‚.)
Π₯Π»Π΅Π±
ΠšΠ°Ρ€Ρ‚ΠΎΡ„Π΅Π»ΡŒ
ΠœΠΎΡ€ΠΊΠΎΠ²ΡŒ
ΠžΠ³ΡƒΡ€Ρ†Ρ‹
Π’ΠΎΠΌΠ°Ρ‚Ρ‹
Π—Π΅Π»Π΅Π½ΡŒ свСТая
Π―Π±Π»ΠΎΠΊΠΈ
Π›ΠΈΠΌΠΎΠ½Ρ‹
ξ˜’ξ˜ξ˜ξšξšξšŠξ˜„ξ˜Œξ˜Žξ˜
ξš…ξšξ˜†ξš€ξ˜‡ξ˜Œξš€ 511 203 92 144 91 38 84 245 326 886 196 218
ξ˜’ξ˜ξ˜ξšξšξšŠξ˜„ξ˜Œξ˜Žξ˜ ξ˜ξ˜ξ™Ώξ˜ 657 277 138 151 128 88 142 377 425 816 249 390
ξ˜•ξ˜ξšŠξ˜ξš‚ξ˜Žξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Œξš‚
ξ˜Žξ˜†ξ˜ξš‚ 490 261 110 133 115 46 98 242 301 995 206 272
ξ˜™ξ˜ξ˜‹ξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Œξš‚ ξ˜Žξ˜†ξ˜ξš‚ 824 304 115 156 128 70 95 599 673 720 297 282
ξš’ξ˜†ξ˜Œξ˜‹ξ˜Šξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Œξš‚
ξ˜Žξ˜†ξ˜ξš‚ 636 164 120 158 128 67 75 230 230 620 199 201
ξ˜”ξ˜ξšŠξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Œξš‚
ξ˜Žξ˜†ξ˜ξš‚ 624 168 116 136 118 55 77 234 233 1032 216 198
ξ˜˜ξ˜‹ξšξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜ξš€
ξ˜ŠξšŠξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ξšˆ 538 183 90 163 95 50 84 239 259 501 198 222
ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜ξ˜ˆξ˜ξšξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜ξš€
ξ˜ŠξšŠξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ξšˆ 784 121 165 179 156 96 107 770 733 1038 311 301
ξ˜ξ˜ξ™Ώξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜Œξšξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜ξš€
ξ˜ŠξšŠξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ξšˆ 651 140 113 173 126 77 84 229 299 981 272 318
ξ˜žξ˜‰ξ˜†ξ˜ξš‚ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜ξš€
ξ˜ξ˜‰ξ˜‡ξ˜Šξšξ˜Šξ˜‹ξšξ˜ξš€
ξ˜ŠξšŠξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ξšˆ
690 127 119 146 108 50 71 201 217 587 205 204
ξšžξšξ˜Žξ˜Šξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Œξš‚
ξ˜ξ˜‰ξ˜‡ξ˜Šξšξ˜Šξ˜‹ξšξš†ξš‚
ξ˜Šξ˜Žξ˜†ξšξ˜ƒ
827 321 161 240 220 189 264 852 735 1048 500 805
Society andξ˜›Security Insights β„– 3 2024 84
Π Π΅Π³ΠΈΠΎΠ½Ρ‹
Говядина
Π½Π°ξ˜ŸΠΊΠΎΡΡ‚ΠΈ
Π Ρ‹Π±Π° ΠΌΠΎΡ€ΠΎΠΆΠ΅-
ная
Молоко пастС-
Ρ€ΠΈΠ·ΠΎΠ²Π°Π½Π½ΠΎΠ΅
Π―ΠΉΡ†ΠΎ ΠΊΡƒΡ€ΠΈΠ½ΠΎΠ΅
(10 ΡˆΡ‚.)
Π₯Π»Π΅Π±
ΠšΠ°Ρ€Ρ‚ΠΎΡ„Π΅Π»ΡŒ
ΠœΠΎΡ€ΠΊΠΎΠ²ΡŒ
ΠžΠ³ΡƒΡ€Ρ†Ρ‹
Π’ΠΎΠΌΠ°Ρ‚Ρ‹
Π—Π΅Π»Π΅Π½ΡŒ свСТая
Π―Π±Π»ΠΎΠΊΠΈ
Π›ΠΈΠΌΠΎΠ½Ρ‹
ξ˜’ξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Œξš‚ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜ξš€
ξš–ξ˜ξ˜ˆξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜…ξ˜Œξš€ 550 240 78 124 79 31 54 187 268 813 136 152
ξ˜ξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜ξš€
ξ˜ŠξšŠξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ξšˆ 622 288 82 125 79 24 54 199 283 954 137 133
*Π’ Π°ΠΏΡ€Π΅Π»Π΅ 2024 Π³. БоставлСно ΠΏΠΎξ˜›Π΄Π°Π½Π½Ρ‹ΠΌ Росстата 1
ξ˜’ξ˜Œξ˜ξšξšξ˜Šξ˜Ž 7ξšƒβ€”  ξšξ˜Šξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜ξšŠξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Œξ™Ώ ξ˜…ξ˜ξš ξšξ˜ξšƒξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜Šξ˜„ξšˆξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜ξšξšξš†ξ˜
ξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜ξ˜†ξš†, ξ˜‰ξšƒξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜…ξ˜ξšξ˜‡ξ˜ξ™Ώ ξ˜Žξšƒξšξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ˆξš†ξ˜ˆξšξš­ξ˜ξ˜‹ξš ξ˜‹ξ˜ξ˜ξš€ξ˜…ξš
Figure 7ξšƒβ€” Consumer price index for food products, as a percentage ofξšƒthe previous month
ξš’ξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜ˆξšξ˜Žξ˜‡ξš† ξšξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξš€ ξšξ˜Šξšƒξšξ˜†ξ˜Œξ˜‚ξ˜Œξšξ˜ ξ˜Œξ™Ώ ξš‹ξ˜Œξšξšξ˜ξšξšξ˜Šξš‚ ξšξšξ˜ξ˜‚ξ˜Œξ˜‹ξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œ ξ˜ˆξ˜„ξš€ ξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜ ξ˜‰ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜ˆξ˜
ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ξšŠξ˜Œξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜Š ξ˜‰ξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜ξšŠξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜ξšξš† ξšξ˜Šξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜ξšŠξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξš€ξ˜‹ξ˜Œ, ,  ξ˜„ξš ξšŠξ˜Šξ˜ ξšŠξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜Š, ξ˜Œξ™Ώ ξ˜‹ξ˜Šξš‹ξšξ˜Š ξ˜Šξ™Ώξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜‡ξ˜-
ξ˜†ξ˜Œξšξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜ξ˜‡ξšˆ ξšξ˜Œξšξ˜Œξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Šξš‚ ξ˜Œξšƒ ξš„ξ˜Žξ˜Šξšξ˜Šξ˜‹ξ˜Œξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Šξš‚ ξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξšξšξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξšˆξš . ξš’ξ˜†ξ˜Œ ξš„ξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜‹, ξ˜‚ξ˜‡ξ˜ŠξšŠξš† ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜Œξšξ˜Š-
ξ˜‰ξ˜ξ˜‡ξšˆ ξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξšξšξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξšˆ ξš„ξ˜Žξ˜Šξšξ˜Šξ˜‹ξ˜Œξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Žξšξš  (ξ˜ξ˜‰ξš€ξšξ˜ξšξšξšξš  ξ˜ξšƒξšξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ξš‹ξ˜ξ˜ξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜ŠξšŠξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξšˆξš  ξšξ˜Šξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜ξšŠξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜-
ξ˜„ξ˜ξš‚), ξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ˜„ξš‹ξšξ˜ ξšŠξš†ξ˜‡ξšˆ ξ˜ŠξšŠξ˜ξ˜ξšξ˜ξ˜‚ξ˜ξšξ˜ ξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξšξšξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξšˆ ξšξ˜Œξšξ˜Œξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜ξš€ξšƒβ€” ξš„ξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜‹ξ˜ξšξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜†ξšξ˜Šξ˜ ξšξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜Œξ˜‚ξ˜Œξ˜
ξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜ˆξšξ˜Žξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜‰ ξ˜‰ξšƒξ˜Šξ˜†ξ˜ƒξ˜ξšξ˜Œξšξ˜ξ˜…ξ˜Œξš€ξ™Ώ ξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜†ξ˜ƒξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜„ξ˜Œ. ξ˜Ÿξšƒξ˜ξ˜‰ξš€ξšξ˜Œ ξ˜ξšƒξš„ξ˜Žξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜‹ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξšˆξš  ξšξ˜†ξ˜Œξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜ˆξšξ˜Š-ξ˜Žξ˜„ξ˜Œ-
ξ˜‹ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Œξ™Ώ ξšξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜Œξš‚ ξ˜‹ξšξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Œξ˜ ξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜ˆξšξ˜Žξ˜‡ξš† ξšξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξš€  ξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜Œξšξ˜‰ξ˜Šξ˜ˆξš€ξ˜‡ξ˜ξš€ ξ˜‰ξšƒξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜Œξ˜Šξšξ˜ξ™Ώ, ξ˜ξšƒξ˜Œξš-
ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜ξšŠξ˜Šξ˜†ξ˜ξšξ˜‰ξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜Šξš‚ ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜ξšξ˜ξšξ˜Šξ˜†ξ˜‡ξšξ˜Š-ξ˜„ξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Œξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Šξš‚ ξ˜Œξšξšξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξšξ˜Žξ˜‡ξšξ˜†ξš† ξ˜ξšξš­ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜ξšξšξ˜Š ξšξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ˜†ξ˜Š-
ξš‹ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ξš€ ξ˜Œξ™Ώ ξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜‰ξ˜Žξ˜ ξ˜‰ξšƒξ˜‹ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ ξšξ˜Šξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜ξšŠξ˜„ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξš€, ξ˜‚ξ˜‡ξ˜Š ξšξšξ˜ξ˜‚ξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜Š ξ˜‰ξ˜„ξ˜Œξš€ξ˜ξ˜‡ ξšξ˜ξšƒξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜ξšξšˆ ξ˜†ξ˜Šξš-
ξšξ˜Œξ˜‚ξšξš†ξ™Ώ ξšξ˜Šξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜ξšŠξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Œξ™Ώ ξ˜…ξ˜ξš. ξ˜Ÿξ˜‹ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ ξ˜ξšƒξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜‹ ξ˜‰ξšƒξ˜Šξ˜‡ξ˜ˆξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξš†ξ˜ ξšξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜Œξ˜Šξ˜ˆξš† ξ˜‰ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜‹ξ˜ξšξ˜Œ ξ˜‹ξšξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Œξ˜
1 https://rosstat.gov.ru/statistics/price (Π΄Π°Ρ‚Π° обращСния: 09.06.2024)
Государство, граТданскоС общСство ΠΈξ˜›ΡΡ‚Π°Π±ΠΈΠ»ΡŒΠ½ΠΎΡΡ‚ΡŒ 85
ξ˜‰ξ˜‰ξ˜Šξšξ˜Œξ˜‹ξš†ξ˜ ξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜ˆξšξ˜Žξ˜‡ξš† ( ξšξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜‰ξ˜Œξ˜„ξ˜Š, ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Šξ˜†ξ˜Šξšξ˜Šξ˜†ξ˜‡ξš€ξš­ξ˜Œξ˜ξ˜ξš€ ξ˜Œξšƒ ξ˜‹ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜Šξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜ξšξ˜ξšξ˜Šξ˜†ξ˜‡ξ˜ξšŠξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξš†ξ˜)
ξšŠξš†ξ˜‰ξ˜ξš ξ˜‡ ξšξ˜Œξšξ˜Œξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Œ ξšξ˜ξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξšξšξšξš† ξ˜‰ξšƒξšξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Šξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜†ξš†ξ™Ώ ξšξ˜ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜ξšξšξš†ξ™Ώ ξšξšξšξ˜Žξ˜‡ξ˜ξ™Ώ ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜Œξ˜Šξšξ˜Šξ˜‰ ξš‡ξš–ξ˜—.
ξ˜›ξ˜Š ξ˜Œξšƒξšξ˜†ξ˜Œ ξšξ˜Œξšξ˜Œξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Šξš‚ ξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξšξšξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œ ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜Šξš­ξ˜Œ, ξšξ˜†ξšξ˜Žξ˜‡ξš†, ξšξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜ξšξšˆ, ξ˜Žξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜‡ξ˜Šξšξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆ, ξ˜ξšƒξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜Žξš‹ξ˜ ξ˜‹ξ˜Š-
ξ˜„ξ˜Šξ˜Žξ˜Š ξ˜Œξšƒξ˜‹ξš€ξ˜ξ˜Š ξ˜‰ξšƒξšŠξ˜Šξ˜„ξšˆξš‘ξ˜Œξšξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜ ξ˜ˆξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜ξ˜‰ξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜‚ξšξš†ξ™Ώ ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜Œξ˜Šξšξ˜Šξ˜‰ ξšξ˜ξšξ˜Šξ˜‹ξ˜ξ˜†ξšξ˜Š ξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Œ,  ξš„ξ˜Žξ˜Š-
ξšξ˜Šξ˜‹ξ˜Œξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Œ ξšξ˜ξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξšξšξšξš† ξ˜‹ξšξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Œξ˜‹ ξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ˜‹ξ˜Šξ™Ώξ˜Šξšξš€ξš‚ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜ξ˜‹,  ξšξ˜ξšξ˜ξ˜Œξ˜Šξšξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜‹ ξ˜Œξšƒ ξ˜‹ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜Š-
ξ˜ŠξšŠξ˜ξ˜ξšξ˜ξ˜‚ξ˜ξšξšξš†ξ˜‹ ξ˜ƒξ˜†ξ˜ξš‹ξ˜ˆξ˜ξšξ˜ξ˜‹. ξ˜Ÿξšƒ2ξš‰24 ξ˜ƒ. ξš€ξšξ˜‰ξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Œξš‚  ξšξ˜Šξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜ξšŠξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Œξ™Ώ ξ˜…ξ˜ξš ξ˜‰ξšƒξ˜†ξš€ξ˜ˆξ˜
ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜Œξ˜Šξšξ˜Šξ˜‰ ξšξ˜ξ˜‹ξ˜ξ˜‡ξšξ˜Š ξšξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜‰ξš†ξ˜ξ˜Œξ˜„ ξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξš‘ξ˜„ξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Šξ˜ˆξšξ˜ξ˜ ξšξšξ˜ξ˜‚ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξ˜ (ξ˜†ξ˜Œξ˜. 7).
ξ˜’ξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ ξ˜…ξ˜ξš ξšξ˜ξšƒξ˜Šξ˜ξšξ˜Šξ˜‰ξšξš†ξ˜ ξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜ˆξšξ˜Žξ˜‡ξš† ξšξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξš€ ξ˜‰ξšƒξ˜†ξš€ξ˜ˆξ˜ ξ˜ˆξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜ξ˜‰ξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜‚ξšξš†ξ™Ώ ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜Œξ˜Šξšξ˜Šξ˜‰
ξ˜ξšξš­ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜ξšξšξ˜Š ξ˜‰ξš†ξš‘ξ˜ ξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ˆξšξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Œξš‚ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Šξš‚ ξ˜ˆξ˜Œξšξ˜ξ˜‹ξ˜Œξ˜Žξ˜Œ. ξ˜Ÿξšƒξ˜…ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜Šξ˜‹ ξšξ˜Šξšƒξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜ξšξ˜,  ξ˜Šξ˜‡ξ˜‹ξ˜ξ˜‚ξ˜-
ξš ξ˜‡ ξ˜Œξ˜ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜Œ (ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜ξ™Ώξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜, 2ξš‰23), ξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ™Ώξ˜Šξ˜ˆξš† ξšξ˜ξ˜Œξ˜‹ξ˜ξšξ˜ξ˜ ξ˜ŠξšŠξ˜ξ˜ξšξ˜ξ˜‚ξ˜ξšξšξš†ξ™Ώ ξ˜ƒξ˜†ξ˜ξš‹ξ˜ˆξ˜ξš ξ˜†ξ˜-
ξ˜ξ˜‡ξšξ˜‡ ξ˜‰ξšƒξšξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ˆξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜ξ™Ώ ξ˜Œξšξšξ˜„ξš€ξ˜…ξ˜Œξ˜Œ, ξ˜ξšƒξ˜‰ξšƒξšξ˜Šξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜ξšŠξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Šξ˜‹ ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜‹ξ˜ξšξ˜‡ξ˜ ξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ ξ˜…ξ˜ξš  ξšξ˜ξ˜‹ξ˜ξ˜‡ξšξ˜Š
ξ˜‰ξš†ξš‘ξ˜, ξ˜‰ξšƒξ˜ξ˜‰ξš€ξšξ˜Œ ξ˜ξšƒξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜‹ ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξš‹ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ξš€ ξšξ˜Šξ˜Žξšξšξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜ξš€ ξ˜ξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜ŠξšŠξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξšˆ ξ˜Œξšƒξ˜ξ˜Šξ™Ώξ˜†ξ˜ξšξš€ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ξš€ ξ˜‡ξ˜ξšξ˜ˆξ˜ξš-
ξ˜…ξ˜Œξš€ ξ˜Žξšƒξ˜ξšξ˜ξ˜ˆξš ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξš†ξ™Ώ ξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ™Ώξ˜Šξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ˜‰ ξšξ˜ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξš€ ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜Œξ˜Šξšξ˜Šξ˜‰.
ξ˜œξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Œξ˜‹ ξ˜ŠξšŠξ˜†ξ˜ξšξ˜Šξ˜‹, ξšξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Šξ˜†ξ˜Œξ˜‰ξš‘ξ˜ξš€ξ˜ξš€ ξ˜‰ξšƒξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜ˆξšξ˜Œξ˜ ξ˜‹ξ˜ξ˜ξš€ξ˜…ξš† ξ˜Œξšξšξ˜„ξš€ξ˜…ξ˜Œξš€ ξ˜ξššξ˜ξ˜ˆξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ ξšξšξ˜ξ˜‚ξ˜Œ-
ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξšξš  ξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ξšˆ ξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ™Ώξ˜Šξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ˜‰ ξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ˜‹ξ˜Šξ™Ώξ˜Šξšξš€ξš‚ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰, ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξš‹ξ˜ξš€ ξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜ξšξšˆ ξš‹ξ˜Œξšξšξ˜Œ. ξ˜›ξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜…ξ˜Œξ˜Šξšξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξšˆ
ξšξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξš€ - ξšξ˜ξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξšξšξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œ ξš‹ξ˜Œξšξšξ˜ξšξšξ˜Š ξ˜‰ξ˜ξš‹ξšξš†ξ™Ώ ξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜ˆξšξ˜Žξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜‰ ξ˜ˆξ˜„ξš€ ξ˜‹ξšξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Œξ™Ώ ξ˜ƒξ˜†ξ˜ξš‹ξ˜ˆξ˜ξš
ξ˜ξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜ŠξšŠξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξšξ˜ξ˜‡ ξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξš ξšξ˜ξšŠξ˜Šξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜‰ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‹ξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œ ξ˜Œξšƒξšξ™Ώξšξ˜ˆξš‘ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξš  ξšξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξšˆξš€ ξ˜ŠξšŠξš­ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜ (ξš’ξ˜Šξ˜„ξš€ξšξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜ξš€,
2ξš‰24: 78).  ξšξ˜Šξ˜„ξ˜Šξš‹ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξ˜ ξ˜ˆξ˜ξ˜„ ξ˜‹ξ˜Šξš‹ξ˜ξ˜‡ ξ˜‰ξš†ξ˜ξ˜‡ξšξšξ˜ξ˜‡ξšˆ  ξšŠξ˜Šξ˜‹ξšŠξ˜ ξšξ˜ξ˜‹ξ˜ξ˜ˆξ˜„ξ˜ξšξšξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Š ξ˜ˆξ˜ξš‚-
ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜Œξš€, ξ˜Žξ˜Šξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜†ξ˜ξš€ ξšξ˜†ξ˜Œξ˜‰ξ˜ξ˜ˆξ˜ξ˜‡ ξ˜Žξšƒξ˜ξš­ξ˜ ξšŠξ˜Šξ˜„ξšˆξš‘ξ˜ξ˜‹ξš ξ˜Œξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Šξš­ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξš  ξ˜ŒξšƒΒ«ξ˜ξš‹ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œξš Β» ξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜ξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Š
ξ˜Žξ˜ξšξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜. ξ˜›ξ˜ξ˜ŠξšŠξ™Ώξ˜Šξ˜ˆξ˜Œξ˜‹ξš† ξ˜Žξ˜Šξ˜‹ξšξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜ξšξš†ξ˜ ξ˜‹ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜†ξ˜Šξš„ξ˜Žξ˜Šξšξ˜Šξ˜‹ξ˜Œξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Œξ˜ ξ˜‹ξ˜ξ˜†ξš†, ξšξ˜ξšξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜‰ξ˜„ξ˜ξšξšξš†ξ˜
ξšξ˜ξšƒξšξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ƒξšξ˜„ξ˜Œξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξ˜ ξ˜ξ˜Šξ˜…ξ˜Œξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜Š-ξš„ξ˜Žξ˜Šξšξ˜Šξ˜‹ξ˜Œξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Œξ™Ώ ξ˜ˆξ˜Œξ˜ξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξšξ˜Šξ˜†ξ˜…ξ˜Œξš‚ ξ˜Œξšƒξ˜‰ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‹ξ˜ξ˜†ξšξ˜Šξ˜ ξšξ˜Šξ˜‰ξš†-
ξš‘ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξ˜ ξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξšξš€ ξš‹ξ˜Œξšξšξ˜Œ ξ˜„ξš ξ˜ˆξ˜ξš‚.
ΠšΠΎΠ½Ρ†Π΅ΠΏΡ‚ΡƒΠ°Π»ΡŒΠ½Ρ‹Π΅ направлСния ΠΏΠΎΠ²Ρ‹ΡˆΠ΅Π½ΠΈΡ уровня ΠΆΠΈΠ·Π½ΠΈ Π³Ρ€Π°ΠΆΠ΄Π°Π½
ξš›ξ˜Žξ˜Šξšξ˜Šξ˜‹ξ˜Œξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Žξšξš  ξ˜Šξ˜ξšξ˜Šξ˜‰ξš ξšξ˜Šξ˜†ξ˜‹ξ˜Œξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξš€ ξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξšξš€ ξš‹ξ˜Œξšξšξ˜Œ ξ˜ξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜‰ξ˜„ξš€ξ˜ξ˜‡ ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξšξ˜ˆ ξ˜Œξšƒξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜Š
ξ˜†ξ˜ξšξšξ˜„ξšˆξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œξ˜‰ξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξšˆ (ξ˜Šξ˜‡ξ˜ˆξ˜ξ˜‚ξ˜). ξš’ξ˜Šξš„ξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜‹ξš ξ˜‰ξšƒξšξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜‰ξšξš  ξ˜Šξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ˆξšˆ ξšξšξš‹ξšξš† ξ˜‹ξ˜ξ˜†ξš†, ξšξ˜ξ˜…ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜ξšξšξš†ξ˜
ξšξ˜ξšƒξšξ˜Šξ˜‰ξš†ξš‘ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξ˜ ξ˜ŠξšŠξš­ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜ξšξšξ˜Šξš‚ ξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜Œξšξ˜‰ξ˜Šξ˜ˆξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œ ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξšξ˜ˆξ˜, ξ˜‚ξ˜‡ξ˜Š ξšξ˜Šξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜ξšŠξšξ˜ξ˜‡ -
ξ˜‚ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξš€ ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ™Ώξšξ˜Šξ˜„ξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Œξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Šξš‚ ξ˜‹ξ˜Šξ˜ˆξ˜ξ˜†ξšξ˜Œξšξ˜ξ˜…ξ˜Œξ˜Œ ξ˜Œξšƒξšξ˜Šξšξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜Šξ˜Šξ˜†ξšξš‹ξ˜ξšξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œ. ξš’ξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜Œξšξ˜‰ξ˜Šξ˜ˆξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆ-
ξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξšˆ ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξšξ˜ˆξ˜ ξ˜Œξšƒξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜ξšξšˆ ξ˜ξ˜Šξ˜…ξ˜Œξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜Š-ξš„ξ˜Žξ˜Šξšξ˜Šξ˜‹ξ˜Œξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Š ξ˜†ξ˜ξšξ˜‰ξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜Œξš€ ξ˜‰ξ˜Šξšƒξ˜‹ξšξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Šξ˜‹ ξ˜ŠξšŠξšξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜Šξ˜‰-
ξ˜„ξ˜ξšξš† ξ˜ξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Šξš€ξšξ˜Œξ˜ξ˜‹ ξ˜Œξšƒ ξš„ξšξšξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜‡ξ˜Œξ˜‰ξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξšˆξš  ξ˜Œξ˜‹ξ˜ξš ξš­ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜Šξ˜ξš€ ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ξšξ˜†ξ˜ξšξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Š ξšξ˜Šξ˜‡ξ˜ξšξ˜…ξ˜Œξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜, 
ξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜Œξšξ˜‰ξ˜Šξ˜ˆξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜ξšξšξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Š, ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜Ž ξ˜Œξšƒξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜ξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Š, ξš€ξ˜‰ξ˜„ξš€ξš ξš­ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜Šξ˜ξš€ ξ˜Šξ˜ξšξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜Šξš‚ ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξšξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ˜‰ξš†ξ™Ώ ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ξšξ˜†-
ξ˜ξ˜Šξ˜‰. ξš‡ξ˜„ξš€ ξšξ˜Šξ˜‰ξš†ξš‘ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξš€ ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξšξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ˜Šξ˜‡ξ˜ˆξ˜ξ˜‚ξ˜Œ ξšξ˜ξ˜ŠξšŠξ™Ώξ˜Šξ˜ˆξ˜Œξ˜‹ ξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ ξ˜Œξšξ˜‰ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œξ˜…ξ˜Œξš‚ ξ˜‰ξšƒξ˜Šξ˜ξšξ˜Šξ˜‰ξšξ˜Šξš‚ -
ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„, ξ˜ξ˜Šξ˜Šξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜ξšξšξ˜Š ξšξ˜ξ˜ŒξšξšŠξ˜ξš‹ξšξ˜Š ξšξ˜‰ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜Œξ˜‚ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξ˜ ξšξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜†ξšξšξ˜Žξ˜Œ ξšξ˜ξšƒξ˜ƒξ˜Šξ˜ξšξ˜ˆξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜ξšξšξš†ξš‚ ξ˜Œξšƒξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡-
ξšξš†ξ˜ ξšŠξš ξ˜ˆξš‹ξ˜ξ˜‡ξš† ξ˜„ξ˜ŒξšŠξ˜Š ξšξšξš‹ξšξš† ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξšξ˜Žξ˜‡ξšξ˜†ξšξš†ξ˜ ξ˜ξ˜ˆξ˜‰ξ˜Œξ˜ƒξ˜Œ ξ˜‰ξšƒξšξ˜Œξ™Ώ.
ξ˜›ξ˜ξ˜ŠξšŠξ™Ώξ˜Šξ˜ˆξ˜Œξ˜‹ξš† ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜Žξš‹ξ˜ ξ˜‹ξ˜Šξ˜‡ξ˜Œξ˜‰ξ˜ξ˜…ξ˜Œξ˜Šξšξšξš†ξ˜ ξ˜‹ξ˜ξ˜†ξš†. ξ˜’ξ˜ξšξ˜‰ξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜Œξ˜ ξ˜…ξ˜ξšξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξšξš†ξ™Ώ ξšξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ξšξ˜Š-
ξ˜‰ξ˜Šξ˜Ž, ξšξ˜Œξšξ˜ξšξ˜ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜Š-ξš„ξ˜Žξ˜Šξšξ˜Šξ˜‹ξ˜Œξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Œξ™Ώ ξšξšξ˜ξšξ˜Œξš‚ ξ˜Œξšƒ ξšξ˜ξšξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜†ξš†ξ˜‰ξšξ˜Šξ˜ (ξ˜‰ ξ˜‡.ξ˜‚. ξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξšξ˜ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Œξ˜Šξšξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆ-
) ξ˜ŠξšŠξ˜†ξ˜ξšξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξ˜ ξ˜ƒξ˜†ξ˜ξš‹ξ˜ˆξ˜ξš ξšŠξšξ˜ˆξšξ˜‡ ξ˜ξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜ŠξšŠξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜ξ˜‡ξšˆ ξšξ˜Šξ˜†ξ˜‹ξ˜Œξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξš  ξ™Ώξ˜Šξšξš€ξš‚ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜ξšξšξš†ξ™Ώ
ξ˜Žξ˜Šξ˜‹ξšξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ξšξ˜…ξ˜Œξš‚, ξ˜ˆξ˜Œξ˜ξ˜…ξ˜Œξšξ˜„ξ˜Œξšξ˜Œξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜ξšξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œ, ξ˜Šξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜ξšξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œ, ξšξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ˆξšξ˜†ξ˜Œξ˜Œξ˜‹ξ˜‚ξ˜Œξ˜‰ξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œ
ξ˜Œξšƒξšξ˜Šξšξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜Œξ˜‰ξšξ˜Šξš‚ ξ˜ƒξ˜†ξ˜ξš‹ξ˜ˆξ˜ξšξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Šξš‚ ξšξ˜Šξšξ˜Œξ˜…ξ˜Œξ˜Œ, ξ˜‚ξ˜‡ξ˜Š ξ˜‰ξ˜Žξšξšξ˜ ξ˜ξšƒξšξ˜Šξ˜‰ξš†ξš‘ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξ˜ξ˜‹ ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ™Ώξšξ˜Œξ˜Žξ˜Š-ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ™Ώξšξ˜Šξ˜„ξ˜Š-
ξ˜ƒξ˜Œξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Šξš‚ ξ˜‰ξ˜Šξ˜Šξ˜†ξšξš‹ξ˜ξšξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œ ξšξ˜Šξšξ˜‰ξ˜Šξ˜„ξ˜Œξ˜‡ ξšξšξ˜ξ˜‚ξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜Š ξšξ˜Šξ˜‰ξš†ξ˜ξ˜Œξ˜‡ξšˆ ξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜Œξšξ˜‰ξ˜Šξ˜ˆξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξšˆ
ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξšξ˜ˆξ˜ ξ˜‰ξšƒξ˜Šξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜„ξš€ξ™Ώ ξš„ξ˜Žξ˜Šξšξ˜Šξ˜‹ξ˜Œξ˜Žξ˜Œ. ξ˜•ξ˜ˆξ˜ξ˜ξšˆ ξ˜…ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Šξ˜ŠξšŠξ˜†ξ˜ξšξšξ˜Š ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜‡ξ˜Œξ˜‰ξšξ˜Š ξ˜Œξ˜ξšξ˜Šξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜ξ˜‡ξšˆ ξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ˆξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜
ξ˜‹ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜Šξš‚ ξ˜Œξšξšξ˜Šξ˜†ξ˜‹ξ˜ξ˜…ξ˜Œξ˜Œξšƒβ€” ξ˜ˆξ˜„ξš€ ξ˜ξ˜Šξ˜…ξ˜Œξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜Šξš‚ ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜‹ξš†; ξ˜Œξšξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜†ξšξ˜ξ˜‡ ξ˜Œξšƒξ˜†ξ˜ξšξ˜„ξ˜Œξ˜‚ξšξš†ξ˜ -
ξ˜Žξ˜Šξ˜‹ξ˜‹ξšξšξ˜Œξ˜Žξ˜ξ˜…ξ˜Œξ˜Šξšξšξš†ξ˜ ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ™Ώξšξ˜Šξ˜„ξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Œξ˜Œξšƒβ€” ξ˜ˆξ˜„ξš€ ξ˜ŠξšŠξšξ˜‚ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξš€, ξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξšξ˜ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Œξ˜Šξšξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜Šξš‚ ξšξ˜Šξ˜ˆξ˜ƒξ˜Šξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜Žξ˜Œ
Society andξ˜›Security Insights β„– 3 2024 86
ξ˜Œξšƒξšξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜ξšξ˜Šξ˜ˆξ˜ƒξ˜Šξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜Žξ˜Œ ξ˜Žξ˜ξ˜ˆξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜‰, ξ˜ˆξ˜„ξš€ ξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜ξ˜ˆξ˜ξšξ˜Œξš€ ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξšξ˜ƒξ˜Šξ˜‰ ξ˜Œξšƒξ˜‹ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜†-ξ˜Žξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Šξ˜‰. ξ˜›ξšξš‹ξšξ˜
ξ˜…ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜ξšξ˜ξšξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜‰ξ˜„ξ˜ξšξšξ˜ξš€ ξ˜ξ˜Œξšξ™Ώξ˜†ξ˜Šξšξ˜Œξšξ˜Œξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜ξšξšξ˜ξš€ ξšξ˜Šξ˜„ξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜Œξ˜Žξ˜ ξ˜‰ξšƒξš„ξ˜‡ξ˜Šξš‚ ξ˜ŠξšŠξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œ. ξ˜šξšƒξ˜ξš­ξ˜, ξšξ˜Šξ˜ˆξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜†-
ξ˜Žξšξ˜ξ˜‹, ξšξšξš‹ξšξš† ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜…ξ˜Œξ˜Šξšξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξš†ξ˜ ξ˜‰ξ˜„ξ˜Šξš‹ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξš€ ξ˜‰ξšƒξ˜‡ξ˜ξ™Ώξšξ˜Œξ˜Žξ˜Š-ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ™Ώξšξ˜Šξ˜„ξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Œξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Šξ˜ ξ˜†ξ˜ξšξ˜‰ξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜Œξ˜.
ξ˜›ξ˜ ξ˜ˆξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜ξ˜‰ξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜‚ξšξš†ξ˜ ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜Œξ˜Šξšξš†, ξšξ˜†ξ˜Œξšξšξ˜ξšξšξš†ξ˜ ξ˜ƒξ˜ξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜Œξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Œξ˜‹ξ˜Œ ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜†ξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜†ξ˜Œ-
ξš€ξ˜‹ξ˜Œ ξ˜’ξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Œξ˜Œ, ξ˜‰ξ˜Šξšξ˜„ξ˜Šξš‹ξ˜ξšξš† ξ˜‹ξ˜ξ˜ξš‘ξ˜‡ξ˜ξšŠξšξš†ξ˜ ξšξ˜ξ˜ˆξ˜ξ˜‚ξ˜Œ ξšξ˜Šξšƒξ˜‹ξšξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Œξ˜‹ ξšξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜ξšξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜‡ξ˜Œξ˜‰ξšξš†ξ˜‹ ξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜‹
(ξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‰ξ˜Šξ˜ξšξ˜Œξ˜ ξ˜Œξšƒξ˜†ξ˜ξšξ˜‰ξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜Œξ˜ ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‰ξ˜ξ˜†ξšξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Š ξ˜‹ξ˜Šξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Š ξšξšξ˜‡ξ˜Œ ξ˜Œξšƒξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜Žξ˜‡ξ˜Œξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Š ξš‘ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜, ξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‰ξ˜Šξ˜ξšξ˜Œξ˜
ξšξšξ˜Œξ˜Žξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξš†ξ™Ώ ξšξ˜†ξ˜Œξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜ˆξšξš†ξ™Ώ ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ξšξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜Šξ˜‰, ξ˜Œξ˜ξšξ˜Šξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξ˜ ξ˜Žξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‚ξ˜ξš‚ξš‘ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜Š ξšξšξ˜‡ξ˜Œ ξ˜‹ξ˜ξš‹ξ˜ˆξš ξ˜žξ˜‰ξ˜†ξ˜Š-
ξšξ˜Šξš‚ ξ˜Œξšƒξ˜˜ξšξ˜Œξ˜ξš‚)1. ξš’ξ˜Šξš„ξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜‹ξš ξ˜‰ξšƒξšξ˜ξ˜Šξ˜‡ξ˜„ξ˜Šξš‹ξšξ˜Šξ˜‹ ξšξ˜Šξ˜†ξš€ξ˜ˆξ˜Žξ˜ ξšξ˜ξ˜ŠξšŠξ™Ώξ˜Šξ˜ˆξ˜Œξ˜‹ξ˜Š ξ˜ŠξšŠξ˜ξ˜ξšξ˜ξ˜‚ξ˜Œξ˜‡ξšˆ 
ξšξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ˆξšξ˜Šξ˜ξš†ξ˜„ξ˜Šξ˜Ž, ξ˜Žξ˜Šξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜†ξš†ξ˜ ξšŠξšξ˜ˆξšξ˜‡ ξ˜ξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜ŠξšŠξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜ξ˜‡ξšˆ ξšξ˜ξšξ˜ξš‘ξšξ˜Šξ˜‹ξš ξ˜†ξ˜ξš‘ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξš  ξš„ξ˜‡ξ˜Œξ™Ώ ξ˜‹ξ˜ξ˜ξš‘ξ˜‡ξ˜ξšŠ-
ξšξš†ξ™Ώ ξšξ˜ξ˜ˆξ˜ξ˜‚. ξ˜Ÿξ˜ξš‹ξšξ˜Š ξšξ˜ξ˜Œξ˜„ξ˜Œξ˜‡ξšˆ ξ˜†ξ˜ξšŠξ˜Šξ˜‡ξš ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Œξ™Ώ ξ˜Œξšξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξšξ˜‹ξ˜ξšξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜‰ ξ˜ƒξ˜Šξ˜ξšξ˜ˆξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜ξšξšξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Š ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ƒξšξ˜„ξ˜Œ-
ξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξš€,  ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜Œξšξš† ξšξ˜ξšƒξš„ξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜Šξš„ξšξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜ƒξ˜Œξš  ξ˜ˆξ˜„ξš€ ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Š ξ™Ώξ˜Šξšξš€ξš‚ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜ ξ˜Œξšƒξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜‹ξš†ξš‘ξ˜„ξ˜ξš-
ξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œ, ξ˜…ξ˜ξšξš† ξšξ˜ξšƒξš‹ξ˜Œξšξšξ˜ξšξšξ˜Š ξ˜‰ξ˜ξš‹ξšξš†ξ˜ ξšξ˜Šξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜ξšŠξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Œξ˜ ξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜ξ˜†ξš†,  ξšξ˜ξšƒξ˜†ξ˜ξšξ˜‰ξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜Œξ˜
ξ˜ξ˜Šξ˜…ξ˜Œξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜Šξš‚ ξ˜Œξšξšξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξšξ˜Žξ˜‡ξšξ˜†ξš†, ξ˜‰ξ˜ξšξ˜‚ξšξ˜†ξšξš†ξ˜ ξ˜Œξšξ˜‰ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œξ˜…ξ˜Œξ˜Œ ξ˜Œξšƒξ˜ˆξ˜†. ξš‡ξ˜„ξš€ ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œξ˜‹ξšξ˜„ξ˜Œξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξš€
ξ˜Œξšξ˜‰ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œξ˜…ξ˜Œξ˜Šξšξšξ˜Šξš‚ ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜‡ξ˜Œξ˜‰ξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œ ξ˜‰ξšƒξ˜…ξ˜ξšξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜ξ™Ώ ξš„ξ˜Žξ˜Šξšξ˜Šξ˜‹ξ˜Œξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Š ξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ ξš‡ξš–ξ˜— ξšξ˜ξ˜ŠξšŠξ™Ώξ˜Šξ˜ˆξ˜Œξ˜‹ξ˜Š
 ξ˜Œξšƒξšξ˜Šξ˜ˆξšξ˜ξ˜ˆξšξ˜Šξ˜†ξšξ˜Šξ˜ ξ˜†ξ˜ξšξ˜‰ξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜Œξ˜ ξšξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜‰ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξš†ξ™Ώ ξ˜Œξšƒ ξš„ξ˜Žξ˜Šξšξ˜Šξ˜‹ξ˜Œξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Œξ™Ώ ξ˜Œξšξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œξ˜‡ξšξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜‰, ξ˜ƒξ˜-
ξ˜†ξ˜ξšξ˜‡ξ˜Œξ˜†ξšξš ξš­ξ˜Œξ™Ώ ξšξ˜ξš­ξ˜Œξ˜‡ξš ξ˜Œξ˜‹ξšξš­ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜ξšξšξš†ξ™Ώ ξ˜Œξšξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Šξ˜‰ ξ˜†ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξ˜ˆξ˜ξšξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜‰ ξ˜œξ˜—ξ˜’ ξ˜Œξšƒξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Šξ˜ -
ξšŠξ˜„ξš ξ˜ˆξ˜ξšξ˜Œξ˜ ξšξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Šξšξ˜Šξ˜ˆξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜ ξ˜’ξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Œξš‚ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Šξš‚ ξš–ξ˜ξ˜ˆξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜…ξ˜Œξ˜Œ.
 ξ˜ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜‹ξ˜ξšξšξ˜Šξš‚ ξ˜†ξš†ξšξ˜Šξ˜‚ξšξ˜Šξš‚ ξš„ξ˜Žξ˜Šξšξ˜Šξ˜‹ξ˜Œξ˜Žξ˜ ξšξ˜ξšƒ ξ˜ƒξ˜Šξ˜ξšξ˜ˆξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜Š,  ξ˜Šξ˜ξšξ˜Šξ˜‰ξšξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Š «-
ξ˜†ξ˜Œξš‹ξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜Β», ξ˜‰ξ˜Šξšξ˜„ξ˜Šξš‹ξ˜ξšξš† ξšξ˜ξ˜ˆξ˜ξ˜‚ξ˜Œ ξšξ˜Šξšƒ ξ˜Šξ˜†ξ˜ƒξ˜ξšξ˜Œξšξ˜ξ˜…ξ˜Œξ˜Œ ξ˜Œξšƒξ˜Žξ˜Šξšξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜„ξ˜Œξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξš  ξ˜ˆξ˜ξš€ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œ
ξ˜Œξšξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œξ˜‡ξšξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜‰, ξšξ˜ξšξ˜Œξ˜‹ξ˜ξš ξš­ξ˜Œξ™Ώξ˜ξš€ ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ƒξšξ˜„ξ˜Œξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξ˜ξ˜‹ ξ˜ˆξ˜Œξ˜ξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξšξ˜Šξ˜†ξ˜…ξ˜Œξš‚ ξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜ξšξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜ξšξšξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Š
ξ˜Œξšƒ ξ˜Šξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜‰ξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Š ξ˜†ξ˜ξšξ˜‰ξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜Œξš€, ξ˜ξšƒ ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜Žξš‹ξ˜ ξšξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜‹ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜‰ ξ˜ŠξšŠξ˜ξ˜ξšξ˜ξ˜‚ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξš€ ξ˜‰ξ˜ξ˜ξ™Ώ ξ˜ƒξ˜†ξ˜ξš‹ξ˜ˆξ˜ξš ξšŠξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜Š-
ξšξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜ξšξšξš†ξ˜‹ ξš‹ξ˜Œξ˜„ξšˆξ˜ξ˜‹, ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜…ξ˜Œξ˜Šξšξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜Šξš‚ ξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜ˆξšξ˜Žξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜Šξš‚ ξ˜Žξ˜Šξ˜†ξšξ˜Œξšξ˜Šξš‚ ξ˜Œξšƒξ˜ˆξ˜†ξšξ˜ƒξ˜Œξ˜‹ξ˜Œ ξš‹ξ˜Œξšξšξ˜ξšξšξ˜Š
ξ˜‰ξ˜ξš‹ξšξš†ξ˜‹ξ˜Œ ξšŠξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜ξ˜‹ξ˜Œ.
Π’Ρ‹Π²ΠΎΠ΄Ρ‹
 ξšξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜Œξš€ξ™Ώ ξ˜ƒξ˜ξ˜Šξšξ˜Šξ˜„ξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜Œξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Šξš‚ ξšξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ξšŠξ˜Œξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œ ξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜ˆξšξ˜Œξ™Ώ ξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜‡ ξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜ξ˜ˆξ˜ξšξ˜Œξš 
ξ˜ξšŠξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜ξšξ˜ξ˜Œξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜ξšξšξ˜Šξš‚ ξ˜‰ξšξšξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜ξšξšξ˜ξš‚ ξ˜ξ˜Šξ˜…ξ˜Œξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜Š-ξš„ξ˜Žξ˜Šξšξ˜Šξ˜‹ξ˜Œξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Šξš‚ ξšξ˜Šξ˜„ξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜Œξ˜Žξ˜Œ ξšξ˜ˆξ˜ξ˜„ξš€ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ξš€
ξšξ˜ξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜‚ξšξ˜Š ξ˜‰ξšξ˜Œξ˜‹ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξš€ ξ˜Œξšƒξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ξšξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜Šξ˜‰. ξ˜Ÿξ˜‹ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ ξ˜ξšƒξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜‹ ξ˜ŠξšŠξ˜ξ˜ξšξ˜ξ˜‚ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξ˜ ξ˜‰ξš†ξ˜ξ˜Šξ˜Žξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Š ξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξšξš€
ξš‹ξ˜Œξšξšξ˜Œ ξ˜ƒξ˜†ξ˜ξš‹ξ˜ˆξ˜ξš ξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ˜„ξš‹ξšξ˜Š ξšŠξš†ξ˜‡ξšˆ ξ˜Šξ˜‡ξšξ˜ξ˜ξ˜ξšξ˜Š ξ˜Žξšƒξšξ˜†ξ˜Œξ˜Šξ˜†ξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜‡ξšξš†ξ˜‹ ξšξ˜ξšξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜‰ξ˜„ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξš€ξ˜‹ ξ˜†ξ˜ξšξ˜‰ξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜Œξš€
ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜ξšξš†  ξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜„ξšˆξ˜Žξ˜Š ξšξ˜Šξ˜†ξ˜‹ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜Š-ξšξ˜Šξ˜‹ξ˜Œξšξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜Š (ξ˜Œξ˜„ξ˜Œ,  ξ˜ƒξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜Šξ˜†ξš€ξ˜‡, «-ξš ξ˜†ξ˜Β»),  ξ˜Œξšƒξ˜†ξ˜-
ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜Š, ξ˜‰ξšƒξ˜ˆξ˜ξš‚ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œ («-ξšξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜‡ξ˜ŠΒ»). ξ˜›ξ˜ξ˜ŠξšŠξ™Ώξ˜Šξ˜ˆξ˜Œξ˜‹ξš† ξ˜Žξ˜Šξ˜‹ξšξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜ξšξš†ξ˜ ξ˜‹ξ˜ξ˜†ξš† ξ˜‰ξšƒξ˜ŠξšŠξ˜„ξ˜-
ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œ ξ˜‰ξš†ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜‰ξšξ˜Œξ˜‰ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξš€ ξ˜ˆξ˜Œξ˜ξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξšξ˜Šξ˜†ξ˜…ξ˜Œξš‚ ξ˜Šξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜‰ξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Š ξ˜Œξšƒ ξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜ξšξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜ξšξšξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Š ξ˜†ξ˜ξšξ˜‰ξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜Œξš€,
ξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ ξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜Œξšξ˜‰ξ˜Šξ˜ˆξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œ ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξšξ˜ˆξ˜, ξšξ˜Šξ˜‰ξš†ξš‘ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξš€ ξ˜ŠξšŠξ˜ξ˜ξšξ˜ξ˜‚ξ˜ξšξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œ ξ˜ƒξ˜†ξ˜ξš‹ξ˜ˆξ˜ξš ξš‹ξ˜Œξ˜„ξšˆξ˜ξ˜‹
ξ˜Œξšƒ ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜Š ξšŠξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜Šξšξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜ξšξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œ, ξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξš†ξ™Ώ ξ˜ˆξ˜ξšξ˜ξš‹ξšξš†ξ™Ώ ξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ™Ώξ˜Šξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ˜‰, ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξš‹ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξš€ ξ˜ξ˜Šξ˜…ξ˜Œ-
ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜Šξš‚ ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜ξ˜…ξ˜Œξ˜Œ, ξ˜†ξ˜ξš‘ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξš€ ξšξ˜†ξ˜ŠξšŠξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜‹ ξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξšξšξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œ ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜…ξ˜Œξ˜Šξšξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜Šξš‚ ξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜ˆξšξ˜Žξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜Šξš‚
ξ˜Žξ˜Šξ˜†ξšξ˜Œξšξš† ξ˜ˆξ˜„ξš€ ξ˜‰ξ˜ξ˜ξ™Ώ ξ˜Žξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜Šξ˜†ξ˜Œξš‚ ξšξ˜ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξš€. ξš’ξ˜†ξ˜Œ ξšξ˜ξ˜Šξšξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ˆξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜ξšξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œ ξ˜Œξšƒξ˜‰ξš†ξ˜ξ˜Šξ˜Žξ˜Šξš‚ ξ˜Œξšξšξ˜„ξš€-
ξ˜…ξ˜Œξ˜Œ  ξ˜‰ξ˜ξš‹ξšξ˜ ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ƒξšξ˜„ξ˜Œξ˜†ξšξš ξš­ξ˜ξš€ ξšξšξšξ˜Žξ˜…ξ˜Œξš€ ξ˜ƒξ˜Šξ˜ξšξ˜ˆξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜ ξ˜‰ξšƒξ˜ξšξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜ ξ˜‹ξ˜Šξšξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜†ξ˜Œξšξ˜ƒξ˜
ξ˜Œξšƒξ˜Žξ˜Šξšξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜„ξš€ ξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξšξš€ ξ˜…ξ˜ξš ξšξ˜ξšƒξ˜ξ˜Šξ˜…ξ˜Œξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜Š, ξš‹ξ˜Œξšξšξ˜ξšξšξ˜Š ξšξšξ˜ξ˜‚ξ˜Œξ˜‹ξš†ξ˜ ξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜ξ˜†ξš†. ξ˜™ξ˜†ξ˜ξš‚ξšξ˜ ξ˜‰ξ˜ξš‹ξšξ˜Š
ξšŠξ˜ξšξ˜Šξ˜‡ξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜Š ξ˜†ξ˜ξš‘ξ˜Œξ˜‡ξšˆ ξšξ˜†ξ˜ŠξšŠξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜‹ξš† ξ˜Žξ˜†ξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜Œξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Œ ξšξ˜Œξšξ˜Žξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Š ξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξšξš€ ξš‹ξ˜Œξšξšξ˜Œ ξšξšξ˜ξ˜‚ξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆ-
1 ΠΠ°Ρ†ΠΈΠΎΠ½Π°Π»ΡŒΠ½Π°Ρ ΠΏΡ€ΠΎΠ³Ρ€Π°ΠΌΠΌΠ° ΡΠΎΡ†ΠΈΠ°Π»ΡŒΠ½ΠΎ-экономичСского развития Π”Π°Π»ΡŒΠ½Π΅Π³ΠΎ Востока Π½Π°ξ˜›ΠΏΠ΅Ρ€ΠΈ-
ΠΎΠ΄ Π΄ΠΎξ˜›2024 Π³ΠΎΠ΄Π° ΠΈξ˜›Π½Π° пСрспСктиву Π΄ΠΎξ˜›2035 Π³ΠΎΠ΄Π°. URL: http://static.government.ru/media/files/NAlS
PJ8QMRZUPd9LIMWJoeVhn1l6eGqD.pdf (Π΄Π°Ρ‚Π° обращСния: 25.08.24).
Государство, граТданскоС общСство ΠΈξ˜›ΡΡ‚Π°Π±ΠΈΠ»ΡŒΠ½ΠΎΡΡ‚ΡŒ 87
ξšξ˜Šξš‚ ξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œ ξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξš‹ξ˜Œξ˜‰ξ˜ξš ξš­ξ˜Œξ™Ώ  ξ˜„ξš ξ˜ˆξ˜ξš‚, ξ˜Œξšξ˜ξ˜‚ξ˜ ξ˜‰ξšƒξšξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜ξšξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜‡ξ˜Œξ˜‰ξ˜ ξ˜‰ξ˜ξ˜ ξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξš†ξ˜ ξ˜‰ξ˜Šξšξ˜†ξ˜Š-
ξ˜ξš† ξ˜†ξ˜ξš‘ξ˜Œξ˜‡ξšˆ ξšŠξšξ˜ˆξ˜ξ˜‡ ξ˜Šξ˜‚ξ˜ξšξšˆ ξšξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξšξ˜ˆξšξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜Š , ξ˜‰ξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜Šξš€ξ˜‡ξšξ˜Š, ξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Š ξšξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Šξ˜‹ξš.
БПИБОК Π˜Π‘Π’ΠžΠ§ΠΠ˜ΠšΠžΠ’
ξš‡ξ˜ξ˜‹ξ˜ξšξ˜‡ξšˆξ˜ξ˜‰ξ˜ . ξ˜›. ξš’ξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜Šξ˜„ξšˆξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜ξšξšξ˜Šξ˜ ξšŠξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜Šξšξ˜Šξ˜„ξšξ˜‚ξ˜Œξ˜ ξš‹ξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜ξš‚ ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜Œξ˜Šξšξ˜ ξ˜‰ξšƒξ˜Žξ˜Šξšξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜Ž-
ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ ξ˜ŠξšŠξ˜ξ˜ξšξ˜ξ˜‚ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξš€ ξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜Šξ˜„ξšˆξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜ξšξšξ˜Šξš‚ ξšŠξ˜ξšξ˜Šξšξ˜ξ˜ξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œ // Society andξšƒSecurity Insights.
2ξš‰23. . 6, ξš— 2. . 99–115. doi: 1ξš‰.14258/ssi(2ξš‰23)2-ξš‰7
ξš‡ξšˆξš€ξ˜‚ξ˜ξšξ˜Žξ˜Š . ξ˜›., ξšŽξ˜ξšξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜‰ξ˜ . . ξ˜Ÿξ˜„ξ˜Œξš€ξšξ˜Œξ˜ ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜Œξšξ˜ξ˜…ξ˜Œξ˜Œ ξšξ˜ξ˜…ξ˜Œξ˜Šξšξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξš†ξ™Ώ ξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜‰
ξšξ˜ξšƒξšξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜Œξš€ ξ˜Œξšƒξ˜Žξ˜ξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜Š ξš‹ξ˜Œξšξšξ˜Œ ξšξ˜ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξš€ ξš‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜Š ξ˜Ÿξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜Žξ˜ ( ξšξ˜†ξ˜Œξ˜‹ξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜ ξ˜˜ξ˜‹ξšξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Šξš‚
ξ˜ŠξšŠξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œ) // ξ˜’ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜Œξ˜Šξšξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜ξš€ ξš„ξ˜Žξ˜Šξšξ˜Šξ˜‹ξ˜Œξ˜Žξ˜: ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜Šξ˜†ξ˜Œξš€ ξ˜Œξšƒξšξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜‡ξ˜Œξ˜Žξ˜. 2ξš‰22. . 2ξš‰, ξš—ξšƒ11ξšƒ(5ξš‰6).
.ξšƒ2ξš‰1ξš‰β€“2ξš‰3ξš‰.
ξ˜™ξ˜Šξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜ ξ˜—. ξ˜—. ξ˜œξ˜ξ™Ώξšξ˜Šξ˜„ξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Œξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Šξ˜ ξ˜†ξ˜ξšξ˜‰ξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜Œξ˜ ξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜‹ξš†ξš‘ξ˜„ξ˜ξšξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œ ξšξ˜ξšƒξ˜Šξ˜ξšξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜ ξ˜Œξšξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜†ξ˜-
ξ˜…ξ˜Œξ˜Œ ,  ξ˜Œξšƒξ˜ƒξ˜Šξ˜ξšξ˜ˆξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜ // ξ˜Ÿξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‡ξšξ˜Œξ˜Ž ξ˜’ξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Œξš‚ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Š ξš„ξ˜Žξ˜Šξšξ˜Šξ˜‹ξ˜Œξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Š -
ξ˜‰ξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ ξ˜Œξ˜‹ξ˜ξšξ˜Œ ξ˜‘. . ξš’ξ˜„ξ˜ξ™Ώξ˜ξšξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜. 2ξš‰24. . 21, ξš—ξšƒ2. . 55–64.
ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜ξ™Ώξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜ . . ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜ƒξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‰ξ˜ ξ˜›. ., ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜ˆξš†ξ™Ώ . ., ξš’ξ˜ξ˜†ξšˆξ˜Žξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜ . . ξš’ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξš†ξš‘ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξ˜ ξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξšξš€
ξš‹ξ˜Œξšξšξ˜Œ  ξšξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜† ξ˜ξ˜Šξ˜…ξ˜Œξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜Š-ξš„ξ˜Žξ˜Šξšξ˜Šξ˜‹ξ˜Œξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Šξš‚ ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ξšŠξ˜Œξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œ ξ˜’ξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Œξ˜Œ // ξ˜˜ξšξ˜Œξ˜‹ξšξ˜‡
ξšξ˜ξšξ˜‚ξšξš†ξ™Ώ ξ˜Œξ˜ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξš‚: ξš„ξ˜Žξ˜Šξšξ˜Šξ˜‹ξ˜Œξ˜Žξ˜ ξ˜Œξšƒξšξšξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜‰ξ˜„ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξ˜. 2ξš‰23. . 12, ξš— 2. . 49–53. DOI:
1ξš‰.57145/27128482_2ξš‰23_12_ξš‰2_1ξš‰
ξ˜›ξ˜Šξšξ˜ˆξ˜†ξ˜Œξšξ˜ ξ˜›. ξ˜›., ξ˜ξ˜Œξšξ˜‚ξ˜ξšξ˜Žξ˜Š . ., ξš£ξšξ˜Žξ˜Šξ˜‰ ξ˜™. . ξ˜˜ξšξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜Œξš ξ˜ξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Šξš€ξšξ˜Œξš€ ξš‹ξ˜Œξ˜„ξ˜Œξš­ξšξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Š -
 ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜Œξ˜Šξšξ˜Šξ˜‰ ξš‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜Š ξ˜Ÿξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜Žξ˜ // ξš’ξ˜†ξ˜ŠξšŠξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜‹ξš† ξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜ƒξšξ˜Šξšξ˜Œξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξš€. 2ξš‰21. ξš— 5. .ξšƒ111–
123. DOI: 1ξš‰.47711/ξš‰868-6351-188- 111-123
ξš’ξ˜Šξ˜„ξš€ξšξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜ξš€ ξ˜›. . ξ˜’ξ˜ξšξ˜‰ξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜Œξ˜ ξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜ξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Š ξ˜Žξ˜ξšξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜ ξšξ˜†ξ˜Œξ˜Šξ˜†ξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜‡ξšξš†ξ™Ώ ξ˜ƒξ˜ξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜Œξ˜‚ξ˜-
ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Œξ™Ώ ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜†ξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜†ξ˜Œξš‚   ξ˜ξ˜Šξ˜…ξ˜Œξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜Š-ξš„ξ˜Žξ˜Šξšξ˜Šξ˜‹ξ˜Œξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Šξš‚ ξšŠξ˜ξšξ˜Šξšξ˜ξ˜ξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œ ξ˜ƒξ˜Šξ˜ξšξ˜ˆξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜
// Society andξšƒSecurity Insights. 2ξš‰24. . 7, ξš— 1. . 66–86. doi: 1ξš‰.14258/ssi(2ξš‰24)1-ξš‰5
ξ˜’ξ˜Šξ˜ˆξšξ˜Œξšξ˜ ξ˜›. . ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Šξ˜ ξ™Ώξ˜Šξšξš€ξš‚ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜Š  ξ˜Šξ˜ξšξ˜Šξ˜‰ξšξ˜Šξš‚ ξšξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜† ξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜Šξ˜„ξšˆξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜ξšξšξ˜Šξš‚ -
ξšξ˜ξ˜ξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œ ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜‰ξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜Š-ξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜Žξ˜‡ξ˜Œξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Š ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜Œξ˜Šξšξ˜ // ξ˜˜ξš’ξ˜™: ξš„ξ˜Žξ˜Šξšξ˜Šξ˜‹ξ˜Œξ˜Žξ˜, ξšξšξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜‰ξ˜„ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξ˜. 2ξš‰23. ξš—ξšƒ1.
. 5–14.
ξ˜œξ˜†ξ˜Šξšξ˜Œξ˜‹ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜ ξ˜›. . ξ˜ξ˜Šξ˜…ξ˜Œξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜Š-ξš„ξ˜Žξ˜Šξšξ˜Šξ˜‹ξ˜Œξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Šξ˜ ξ˜†ξ˜ξšξ˜‰ξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜Œξ˜ ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜Œξ˜Šξšξ˜Šξ˜‰ ξ˜’ξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Œξš‚ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Šξš‚ ξš–ξ˜-
ξ˜ˆξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜…ξ˜Œξ˜Œ: ξ˜‡ξ˜ξšξ˜ˆξ˜ξšξ˜…ξ˜Œξ˜Œ ξ˜Œξšƒξšξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜ξšξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜‡ξ˜Œξ˜‰ξš† // ξ˜‘ξ˜ξ˜Šξšξ˜Šξ˜„ξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜Œξ˜Žξ˜ ξ˜Œξšƒξš„ξ˜Žξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜ξ˜Šξ˜ˆξ˜Œξšξ˜ξ˜‹ξ˜Œξ˜Žξ˜ ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜Œξ˜Šξšξ˜Šξ˜‰.
2ξš‰23. . 9, ξš—ξšƒ4. . 37–45.
ξšžξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜ξšξ˜ξšξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜ . ., ξ˜ξ˜ξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξšξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜ . ., ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜ξ˜Œξ˜‹ξ˜Šξ˜‰ . ξš…., ξ˜šξ˜„ξš ξš‘ξšξ˜Œξ˜Žξ˜Šξ˜‰ ξ˜™. ξ˜™. ξ˜ξ˜Šξ˜…ξ˜Œξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆ-
-ξš„ξ˜Žξ˜Šξšξ˜Šξ˜‹ξ˜Œξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Œξ˜ ξšξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜Œξš€ ξšξšξšξ˜Žξ˜…ξ˜Œξ˜Šξšξ˜Œξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜ξšξ˜Œξš€ ξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜ξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Š ξ˜Žξ˜ξšξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜ ξ˜‰ξšƒξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜Œξ˜Š-
ξšξ˜ξ™Ώ ξ˜’ξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Œξ˜Œ // Society andξšƒSecurity Insights. 2ξš‰21. . 4, ξš—ξšƒ4. . 31–43.
ξšŒξšξ˜ξš‚ξ˜ˆξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜‹ξ˜ξš . ., ξš£ξ˜†ξ˜ξš‘ξ˜ξ˜‰ξ˜ . ., ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜ξ˜† . . ξ˜—ξšŠξ˜ξ˜ξšξ˜ξ˜‚ξ˜ξšξšξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξšˆ ξš‹ξ˜Œξ˜„ξšˆξ˜ξ˜‹ ξš‹ξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜ξš‚
ξš‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξšξ˜ξ˜ƒξ˜Š ξ˜Ÿξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Šξ˜Žξ˜: ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œξ˜‚ξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Œξš‚ ξ˜ξšξ˜ξ˜„ξ˜Œξš // ξ˜Ÿξ˜Šξšξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜ξš† ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜Œξ˜Žξ˜Œ. 2ξš‰23. . 3ξš‰, ξš—ξšƒ3.
. 53–63.
REFERENCES
Dementieva, I. N. (2ξš‰23). Food well-being ofξšƒthe inhabitants ofξšƒthe region inξšƒthe con-
text ofξšƒensuring food security. Society andSecurity Insights, 6(2), 99–115. doi: 1ξš‰.14258/
ssi(2ξš‰23)2-ξš‰7 (InξšƒRuss.).
Society andξ˜›Security Insights β„– 3 2024 88
Dyachenko, V. N., Lazareva, V. V. (2ξš‰22). e impact ofξšƒthe implementation ofξšƒnation-
al projects on the conditions andξšƒquality ofξšƒlife ofξšƒthe population ofξšƒthe Far East (on
the example ofξšƒthe Amur Region). Regional’naya ekonomika: teoriya i praktika, 20(11),
2ξš‰1ξš‰β€“2ξš‰3ξš‰ (InξšƒRuss.).
Kochetova, O. O. (2ξš‰24). Technological development ofξšƒindustry based on the integra-
tion ofξšƒscience, business andξšƒthe state. Vestnik Rossijskogo ekonomicheskogo universiteta
imeni G. V. Plehanova, 21(2), 55–64 (InξšƒRuss.).
Malakhova, S. V. Sergeeva, N. M., Sedykh, T. A., Perkova, E. Yu. (2ξš‰23). Raising the stand-
ard ofξšƒliving as a factor ofξšƒsocio-economic stability inξšƒRussia. Azimut nauchnyh issledo-
vanij: ekonomika i upravlenie, 12(2), 49–53. DOI: 1ξš‰.57145/27128482_2ξš‰23_12_ξš‰2_1ξš‰
(InξšƒRuss.).
Nozdrina, N.N., Minchenko, M.M., Yankov, K.V. (2ξš‰21). Analysis ofξšƒthe state ofξšƒ the
housing stock ofξšƒthe regions ofξšƒ the Far East. Problemy prognozirovaniya, 5, 111–123.
DOI: 1ξš‰.47711/ξš‰868-6351-188- 111-123 (InξšƒRuss.).
Polyanskaya, N. M. (2ξš‰24). Human capital development ofξšƒpriority geostrategic territo-
ries as a basis for socio-economic security ofξšƒthe state. Society andSecurity Insights, 7(1),
66–86. doi: 1ξš‰.14258/ssi(2ξš‰24)1-ξš‰5 (InξšƒRuss.).
Rodnina, N. V. (2ξš‰23). Agriculture as the main factor ofξšƒfood security inξšƒthe North Arc-
tic region. APK: ekonomika, upravlenie, 1, 5–14 (InξšƒRuss.).
Troξš™mova, N. V. (2ξš‰23). Socio-economic development ofξšƒ the regions ofξšƒ the Russian
Federation: trends andξšƒ prospects. Geopolitika i ekogeodinamika regionov, 9(4), 37–45
(InξšƒRuss.).
Cherepanova, M. I., Safronova, E. Yu., Maksimov, M. B., Ilyushnikov, K. K. (2ξš‰21). So-
cio-economic conditions ofξšƒhuman capital functioning inξšƒthe regions ofξšƒRussia. Society
andSecurity Insights, 4(4), 31–43 (InξšƒRuss.).
Schneiderman, I.M., Yarasheva, A.V., Makar S.V. (2ξš‰23). Housing security for residents
ofξšƒthe Far East: statistical analysis. Voprosy statistiki, 30(3), 53–63 (InξšƒRuss.).
ИНЀОРМАЦИЯ ΠžΠ‘ ΠΠ’Π’ΠžΠ Π• / INFORMATION ABOUT THE AUTHOR
ξ˜›ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜„ξšˆξš€ ξ˜ξ˜Œξ™Ώξ˜ξš‚ξ˜„ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξšξ˜ ξš’ξ˜Šξ˜„ξš€ξšξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜ξš€ξšƒ β€” . ξš„ξ˜Žξ˜Šξš. , ξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ˜…ξ˜ξšξ˜‡, ξ˜ˆξ˜Šξ˜…ξ˜ξšξ˜‡ ξ˜Žξ˜ξšξ˜ξ˜ˆξ˜†ξš†
ξšξ˜†ξ˜Œξ˜Žξ˜„ξ˜ξ˜ˆξšξ˜Šξš‚ ξš„ξ˜Žξ˜Šξšξ˜Šξ˜‹ξ˜Œξ˜Žξ˜Œ ξš…ξšξ˜†ξš€ξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜Žξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Š ξ˜ƒξ˜Šξ˜ξšξ˜ˆξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜‰ξ˜ξšξšξ˜Šξ˜ƒξ˜Š ξšξšξ˜Œξ˜‰ξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜ξ˜Œξ˜‡ξ˜ξ˜‡ξ˜ ξ˜Œξ˜‹. ξš‡ξ˜Šξ˜†ξš‹ξ˜Œ
ξš…ξ˜ξšξšξ˜ξ˜†ξ˜Šξ˜‰ξ˜, ξ˜ƒ. ξ˜“ξ˜„ξ˜ξš-ξ˜“ξ˜ˆξš„, ξ˜’ξ˜Šξ˜ξ˜ξ˜Œξš€.
Natalya M. Polyanskayaξšƒβ€” Cand. Sci. (Economics), Associate Professor ofξšƒthe Depart-
ment ofξšƒApplied Economics, Banzarov Buryat State University, Ulan-Ude, Russia.
Π‘Ρ‚Π°Ρ‚ΡŒΡ поступила Π²ξ˜›Ρ€Π΅Π΄Π°ΠΊΡ†ΠΈΡŽ 12.06.2024;
ΠΎΠ΄ΠΎΠ±Ρ€Π΅Π½Π° послС рСцСнзирования 25.08.2024;
принята ΠΊξ˜›ΠΏΡƒΠ±Π»ΠΈΠΊΠ°Ρ†ΠΈΠΈ 25.08.2024.
The article was submitted 12.06.2024;
approved after reviewing 25.08.2024;
accepted for publication 25.08.2024.