![]()
SOCIETY AND SECURITY INSIGHTS
124 ʋ
$35H]QLN 6<X/\XELQ($9RLQRYD190HOHVKNR 1(.KDJXURYD 0RVFRZ
,QVWLWXWHRI6RFLRORJ\5XVVLDQ$FDGHP\RI6FLHQFHV
'HEHHYD 7% %DVKNXHYD (<X 6RVWR\DQLH ]GRURY¶\D L PHGLFLQVNRJR REVOX
-
]KLYDQLL XFKDVKFKHMV\D PRORGH]KL 5HVSXEOLNL %XU\DWL\D RVREHQQRVWL SUREOHP\ SXWL
VRYHUVKHQVWYRYDQL\D>7KHVWDWHRIKHDOWKDQGPHGLFDOFDUHIRUVWXGHQWVLQWKH5HSXEOLFRI
%XU\DWLDIHDWXUHVSUREOHPVZD\VWRLPSURYH@2LNXPHQD1R±
(IUHPRY$<X.UDVLNRYD$99OL\DQLHDONRJRO\DQDUD]YLWLHL]GRURY¶HSRGURVW
-
ND>7KHLQÀXHQFHRIDOFRKRORQWKHGHYHORSPHQWDQGKHDOWKRIDWHHQDJHU@6FLHQWL¿FUH
VHDUFKIURPWKHRU\WRSUDFWLFH1R±
=KXUDYOHYD,9=GRURY¶HSRGURVWNRYVRFLRORJLFKHVNLMDQDOL]>+HDOWKRIWHHQDJ-
HUVVRFLRORJLFDODQDO\VLV@0RVFRZ3XEOLVKLQJKRXVHRI,QVWLWXWHRI6RFLRORJ\RI5$6
=KXUDYOHYD,92WQRVKHQLHN]GRURY¶\XLQGLYLGDLREVKFKHVWYD>$WWLWXGHWRZDUGV
KHDOWKRIWKHLQGLYLGXDODQGVRFLHW\@0RVFRZ1DXND
=KXUDYOHYD,9/DNRPRYD196RFLDO¶QD\DSROLWLNDSRIRUPLURYDQL\XXPROR
GH]KLRWQRVKHQL\DN]GRURY¶\X>6RFLDOSROLF\RQIRUPDWLRQDW\RXWKRIWKHDWWLWXGHWRZDUGV
KHDOWK@8O\DQRYVN=HEUDSXEOLVKLQJKRXVH
=GRURY¶H PRORGH]KL VUDYQLWHO¶QRH LVVOHGRYDQLH 5RVVL\D %HODUXV¶ 3RO¶VKD (2016).
>+HDOWKRI\RXWKFRPSDUDWLYHUHVHDUFK5XVVLD%HODUXV3RODQG@0RVFRZ(NRQ,QIRUP
SXEOLVKLQJKRXVH
.XFKPD952KUDQD]GRURY¶\DGHWHMLSRGURVWNRYYQDFLRQDO¶QRMVWUDWHJLLGHMVWYLM
YLQWHUHVDKGHWHMQDJRG\>3URWHFWLQJWKHKHDOWKRIFKLOGUHQDQGDGROHVFHQWVLQ
WKHQDWLRQDODFWLRQVWUDWHJ\IRUFKLOGUHQIRU@4XHVWLRQVRIVFKRRODQGXQLYHUVLW\
PHGLFLQHDQGKHDOWK1R±
5\EDNRYD/1&KHNLQHYD790RGHOLSRWUHEOHQL\DDONRJRO\DYPRORGH]KQRM
VUHGH>7KH 0RGHO RIFRQVXPSWLRQ RI DOFRKRODPRQJ \RXQJ SHRSOH@6RFLDO DVSHFWV RI
KHDOWKRIWKHSRSXODWLRQ1R
6REROHYD696PLUQRYD1(&KXGD\HYD292VREHQQRVWLGLQDPLNL]DEROHYDH
-
PRVWLGHWHMLSRGURVWNRY6LELUVNRJRIHGHUDO¶QRJRRNUXJDYNRQWHNVWHURVVLMVNLKWHQGHQFLM
>)HDWXUHVRIG\QDPLFVRILQFLGHQFHRIFKLOGUHQDQGWHHQDJHUVRI6LEHULDQ)HGHUDO'LVWULFW
LQWKHFRQWH[WRIWKH5XVVLDQWUHQGV@7KH5HJLRQHFRQRP\ DQGVRFLRORJ\1R
±
)\RGRURY$,2WQRVKHQLHSRGURVWNRYN]GRURY¶\XVRFLRORJLFKHVNLMDQDOL]>$W
-
WLWXGHRIWHHQDJHUVWRZDUGVKHDOWKVRFLRORJLFDODQDO\VLV@6FLHQFHDQGHGXFDWLRQ No. 1
±
)\RGRURY$,3RYHGHQFKHVNLH IDNWRU\ ]GRURY¶\D SRGURVWNRYJHQGHUQ\M DVSHFW
>%HKDYLRXUDOIDFWRUV RIKHDOWKRI WHHQDJHUVJHQGHU DVSHFW@&KHO\DELQVN8UDO *8).
CHGNOC UrO RAO.
6KDQLQD7*)LONLQD 20.RFKHURYD2<X9RURE\HYD($3\NKWLQD/$
*HQGHUQ\HRVREHQQRVWLRWGHO¶Q\K SRND]DWHOHM]GRURY¶\DSRGURVWNRY OHW>*HQGHU
IHDWXUHVRILQGLYLGXDOLQGLFDWRUVRIKHDOWKRIDGROHVFHQWV\HDUVROG@6RFLDO¶Q\HDV
SHNW\]GRURY¶\DQDVHOHQL\D>6RFLDODVSHFWVRISXEOLFKHDOWK@1R