HORSE BURIALS IN CHAMBER 31 OF THE ARZHAN-1 MOUND (new data on cultural relations in the Eurasian steppes in the 8th – early 6th centuries BC)
Keywords:
Arzhan-1, Early Scythian Age, horse burial, boar task, horse bit with mouthpiece decorated with rectangular reliefs, North Caucasus
Abstract
The article presents the results of a study of finds from burial chamber No. 31 of the Arzhan-1 mound–ten horses buried with horse trappings. Next to horses No. 1, 6–10 lay the lower canine boars with drilled holes. The closest analogies to such finds are known in the south of the steppe zone of Central Asia, but most often on the sites of the 7th century. BC in Northern Caucasus and Ukrainian forest-steppe. In the mouth of the third horse, bronze two-part bits were found with a mouthpiece decorated with a two-row rectangular relief. Similar bits are found in the sets of the horse trappings of the classical Novocherkassk type and the early Zhabotin horizon of Eastern Europe connected from the end of the 8–7th c. BC. On the basic of the examination of the similar objects, the environment of the findings, we can establish, that burial chamber No. 31 was not dated earlier than the beginning of the 7th c. BC. According to the radiocarbon analyzes, the wooden construction of kurgan is dated back to the end of the 9th – beginning of the 8th c. BC. In the light of the new data, it is necessary to review the natural-scientific approach and a comprehensive analysis of archaeological materials dated from the 8th to the beginning of 6th c. BC.
Downloads
Download data is not yet available.
Metrics
Metrics Loading ...
References
Akishev K.A., Akishev A.K. Problema hronologii rannego etapa sakskoj kul’tury [The Problem of Chronology of the Early Stage of the Saka Culture]. Arheologicheskie pamyatniki Kazahstana [Archaeological Sites of Kazakhstan]. Alma-Ata : Nauka, 1978. Pp. 38–68.
Bokovenko N.A. Nachal’nyj etap kul’tury rannih kochevnikov Sayano-Altaya (po materialam konskogo snaryazheniya) : dis. ... kand. ist. nauk [The Initial Stage of the Culture of the Early Nomads of Sayano-Altai (based on horse equipment) : Dis. ... Cand. Hist. Sciences]. L., 1986. 241 p.
Bokovenko N.A. Formirovanie konskogo snaryazheniya rannih kochevnikov Central’noj Azii [The Formation of Horse Equipment of the Early Nomads of Central Asia]. Mir Bol’shogo Altaya [World of Big Altai]. 2018. №4 (1). Pp. 8–42.
Val’chak S.B. K voprosu o datirovke kompleksa iz Chernogorovskogo kurgana [On the Dating of a Complex from the Chernogorovsky Mound]. Rossijskaya arheologiya [Russian Archaeology]. 1994. №2. Pp. 131–134.
Val’chak S.B. Konskoe snaryazhenie v pervoj treti I-go tys. do n. e. na yuge Vostochnoj Evropy [Horse Equipment in the First Third of the 1st Millennium BC in the South of Eastern Europe]. M. : Taus, 2009. 291 p.
Val’chak S.B., P’yankov A.V., Hachaturova E.A., Erlih V.R. Kubanskij mogil’nik. Materialy raskopok N.V. Anfimova 1965 goda [Kuban Burial Ground. Excavation Materials of N.V. Anfimov in 1965]. M. : IA
RAN, 2016. 208 p.
Vishnevskaya O.A. Kul’tura sakskih plemyon nizov’ev Syrdar’i v VII–V vv. do n.e. (po materialam Ujgaraka) [Culture of the Saka Tribes of the Lower Syr Darya in the 7th – 5th Centuries BC (based on Uygarak)]. M. : Nauka, 1973. 163 p. (Trudy Horezmskoj Arheolo-etnograficheskoj ekspedicii. Т. VIII) [Proceedings of the Khorezm Archaeological and Ethnographic Expedition. Vol. VIII).
Galanina L.K. Ranneskifskie uzdechnye nabory po materialam Kelermesskih kurganov [Early Scythian Bridle Sets Based on the Materials of the Kelermes Mounds]. ASGE. 1983. Issue 24. Pp. 32–55.
Galanina L.K. Kelermesskie kurgany. «Carskie» pogrebeniya ranneskifskoj epohi [Celermes Mounds.“Royal” Burials of the Early Scythian Era]. Stepnye narody Evrazii. T. I [Steppe Peoples of Eurasia. Vol. I]. M. : Paleograf, 1997. 316 p.
Gryaznov M.P. Otchyot o raskopkah kurgana Arzhan v 1971–1972 g. [Report on the Excavation of the Arzhan Mound in 1971–1972]. Arhiv IA RAN [Archive of the IA RAS]. 1973. R-1. №4833.
Gryaznov M.P. Arzhan. Foto i chertezhi raskopok 1973 g. [Arzhan. Photo and Drawings of the Excavations of 1973]. Arhiv IA RAN [Archive of IA RAS]. 1974. R-1. №5579a.
Gryaznov M.P. Otchyot o raskopkah kurgana Arzhan v Tuve 1973–1974 gg. [Report on the Excavation of the Arzhan Mound in Tuva 1973–1974]. Arhiv IA RAN [Archive of the IA RAS]. 1975. R-1. №5579.
Gryaznov M.P. K voprosu o slozhenii kul’tur skifo-sibirskogo tipa v svyazi s otkrytiem kurgana Arzhan [To the Question of the Formation of Cultures of the Scythian-Siberian Type in Connection with the Discovery of the Arzhan Mound]. KSIA. 1978. №154. Pp. 9–18.
Gryaznov M.P. Arzhan – «carskij» kurgan ranneskifskogo vremeni [Arzhan – “Royal” Barrow of Early Scythian Time]. L. : Nauka, 1980. 62 p.
Gryaznov M.P. Nachal’naya faza razvitiya skifo-sibirskih kul’tur [The Initial Phase of the Development of Scythian-Siberian Cultures]. Arheologiya Yuzhnoj Sibiri. Vyp. 12 [Archaeology of Southern Siberia. Vol. 12]. Kemerovo : KemGU, 1983. Pp. 3–18.
Gryaznov M.P., Mannaj-ool M.H. Kurgan Arzhan – mogila «carya» ranneskifskogo vremeni [Kurgan Arzhan– the Tomb of the “King” of Early Scythian Time]. UZTNIYALI. Kyzyl : [B.i.], 1973. Issue XVI. Pp. 191–206.
Evraziya v skifskuyu epohu. Radiouglerodnaya i arheologicheskaya hronologiya [Eurasia in the Scythian Era. Radiocarbon and Archaeological Chronology]. SPb. : Teza, 2005. 290 p.
Zajceva G., Vasil’ev S.S., Marsadolov L.S., van der Pliht J., Semenov A.A., Degachev V.A., Lebedeva L.M. Radiouglerod i dendrohronologiya klyuchevyh pamyatnikov Sayano-Altaya: statichticheskij analiz [Radiocarbon and Dendrochronology of Key Sayano-Altai Sites: Statistical Analysis]. Radiouglerod i arheologiya. 1997. Vyp. 2 [Radiocarbon and Archaeology. 1997. Issue 2]. Pp. 36–43.
Zajceva G., Chugunov K.V., Alekseev A.Yu., Dergachev V.A., Vasil’ev S.S., Semencov A.A., Kuk G.T., Skott E.M., Van der Pliht H., Bokovenko N.A., Kul’kova M.A., Burova N.D., Lebedeva L.M., Yunger H., Sonninen E. Istoriya i rezul’taty radiouglerodnogo datirovaniya kurgana Arzhan [The History and Results of Radiocarbon Dating of the Arzhan Mound]. Radiouglerod v arheologicheskih i paleoekologicheskih issledovaniyah [Radiocarbon in Archaeological and Paleoecological Studies]. SPb. : IIMK RAN, 2007. Pp. 251–262.
Ismagilov R.B. Pogrebenie Bol’shogo Gumarovskogo kurgana v Yuzhnom Priural’e i problema proishozhdeniya skifskoj kul’tury [The Burial of the Great Gumarovsky Mound in the South Urals and the Problem of the Origin of the Scythian Cultur]. ASGE. 1988. Issue 29. Pp. 29–47.
Ismagilov R.B. Rannie skify i Central’naya Aziya : avtoref. dis. … kand. ist. nauk [Early Scythians and Central Asia : Synopsis of the Dis. ... Cand. of Hist. Sciences]. SPb., 1993. 20 p.
Kovalevskaya V.B. Kon’ i vsadnik, puti i sud’by. Po sledam ischeznuvshih kul’tur Vostoka [The Horse and the Rider, Ways and Destinies. Folllowing the Disappeared Cultures of the East]. M. : GRVL, 1977. 150 p.
Kovpanenko G.T. Kurgany ranneskifskogo vremeni v bassejne r. Ros’ [Early Scythian Mounds in the Ros River Basin]. Kiev : Naukova Dumka, 1981. 162 p.
Leskov A.M., Erlih V.R. Mogil’nik Fars/Klady. Pamyatnik perehoda ot epohi pozdnej bronzy k rannemu zheleznomu veku na Severo-Zapadnom Kavkaze [The Fars Burial Ground /Treasures. The Site of the Transition from the Late Bronze Age to the Early Iron Age in the Northwest Caucasus]. M. : Gos. Muzej Vostoka, 1999. 162 p.
Lozhkin M.N., Petrenko V.G. Uzdechnyj nabor iz Krasnodarskogo kraya [Bridle Set from the Krasnodar Krai]. KSIA. 1981. Issue 167. Pp. 70–73.
Marsadolov L.S. Tkani iz kurgana Arzhan v Centre Azii [Fabrics from the Arzhan Mound in Center of Asia]. Pyatуe istoricheskie chteniya pamyati M.P. Gryaznova [The Fifth Historical Readings in Memory of M.P. Gryaznov]. Omsk : OmGU, 2000. Pp. 72–75.
Marsadolov L.S. Rekonstrukciya olennogo kamnya iz kurgana Arzhan-1 [Reconstruction of Deer Stone from the Arzhan-1 Mound]. Vremya i kul’tura v arheologo-etnograficheskih issledovaniyah drevnih i sovremennyh obshhestv Zapadnoj Sibiri i sopredelnyh territorij: problemy interpretacii i rekonstrukcii [Time and Culture in Archaeological and Ethnographic Studies of Ancient and Modern Societies of Western Siberia and Adjacent Territories: Problems of Interpretation and Reconstruction]. Tomsk : Argaf-Press, 2008. Pp. 60–64.
Maslov V.E., Gej A.N., Andreeva M.V. Izobrazheniya solyarnyh znakov iz mogil’nika Dysh IV [Images of Solar Signs from the Dysh IV Burial Ground]. KSIA. 2019. Issue. 256. Pp. 153–171.
Nurmuhanbetov B.N. Kompleks rannesakskogo vremeni iz Zhetysu [The Early Saka Time Complex from Zhetysu]. Arheologicheskoe nasledie Central’nogo Kazahstana: izuchenie i sohranenie. T. 2 [Archaeological Heritage of Central Kazakhstan: Study and Preservation. T. 2]. Almaty : Begazy-Tasmola, 2017. Pp. 252–257.
Petrenko V.G. Krasnoznamenskij mogil’nik. Elitnye kurgany ranneskifskoj epohi na Severnom Kavkaze [The Krasnoznamensky Burial Ground. Elite Mounds of the Early Scythian Era in the North Caucasus]. Stepnye narody Evrazii. T. III [Steppe Peoples of Eurasia. Vol. III]. M.; Berlin; Bordo : Paleograf, 2006. 176 p.
Polos’mak N.V. Issledovaniya pamyatnikov skifskogo vremeni na Ukoke [Studies of Scythian Time Sites in Ukok]. ALTAICA. 1993. №3. Pp. 21–31.
Pogrebova M.N. Zakavkaz’e i ego svyazi s Perednej Aziej v skifskoe vremya [Transcaucasia and its Relations with Western Asia in Scythian Time]. M. : Nauka, 1984. 237 p.
Ryabkova T.V. Izobrazheniya rombovidnyh znakov kak svidetel’stvo migracij v epohu rannih kochevnikov [Images of Diamond-Shaped Signs as Evidence of Migrations in the Era of the Early Nomads]. Margulanovskie chteniya – 2011 [Margulanov Readings – 2011]. Astana : ENU im. L.N. Gumileva, 2011. Pp. 104–108.
Smirnov K.F. Arheologicheskie dannye o drevnih vsadnikah Povolzhsko-Ural’skih stepej [Archaeological Data on the Ancient Horsemen of the Volga-Ural Steppes]. Sovetskaya arheologiya [Soviet Archaeology]. 1961. №1. Pp. 46–72.
Smirnov N.Уu. Zapadnye komponenty v kul’turah rannih kochevnikov Sayano-Altajskogo nagor’ya v VIII–V vv. do n.e. : diss. … kand. ist. nauk [Western Components in the Cultures of the Early Nomads of the Sayan-Altai Highlands in the 8th – 5th Centuries. BC : Diss. ... Cand. of Hist. Sciences]. SPb. : IIMK RAN, 2012. 262 p.
Terenozhkin A.I. Kimmerijcy [Cimmerians]. Kiev : Naukova Dumka, 1976. 219 p.
Uvarova P.S. Mogil’niki Severnogo Kavkaza // MAK. 1900. T. VIII. 381 c.
Halikov A.H. Volgo-Kam’e v nachale epohi rannego zheleza (VIII–VI vv. do n.e.) [Volga-Kamye at
the Beginning of the Early Iron Age (the 8th – 6th Centuries BC)]. M. : Nauka, 1977. 262 p.
Chlenova N.L. Central’naya Aziya i skify I. Data kurgana Arzhan i ego mesto v sisteme kul’tur skifsogo mira [Central Asia and the Scythians I. The Date of the Arzhan Mound and its Place in the System of Cultures of the Scythian World. M. : IA RAN, 1997. 98 p.
Chugunov K.V. Arzhan-1 i Arzhan-2: sravnitel’nyj analiz [Arzhan-1 and Arzhan-2: Comparative Analysis]. Nasledie narodov Cental’noj Azii i sopredel’nyh territorij: izuchenie, sohranenie i ispol’zovanie. Ch. 1 [The Heritage of the Peoples of Central Asia and Adjacent Territories: Study, Conservation and Use. Part 1]. Kyzyl : KCO «Anyyak», 2009. Pp. 48–52.
Shul’ga P.I., Shul’ga D.P. Mogil’nik Saensai ranneskifskogo vremeni u g. Urumchi (Sin’czyan, Kitaj) [Saensai Burial Ground of the Early Scythian Time near the City of Urumqi (Xinjiang, China)]. TGE. LXXVII: Arheologiya bez granic: kollekcii, problemy, issledovaniya, gipotezy [TSE. LXXVII: Archaeology without Borders: Collections, Problems, Research, Hypotheses]. SPb. : Gosudarstvennyj Ermitazh, 2015. Pp. 512–533.
Erlih V.R. Bronzovye uzdechnye nabory i problema hronologii predskifsogo i ranneskifskogo vremeni [Bronze Bridle Sets and the Problem of Chronology of the Scythian and Early Scythian Times]. Drevnosti Severnogo Kavkaza i Prichernomor’ya [Antiquities of the North Caucasus and the Black Sea]. M. : [B.i.], 1991. Pp. 35–39.
Erlih V.R. U istokov ranneskifskogo kompleksa [At the Origins of the Early Scythian Complex]. M. : Gos. Muzej Vostoka, 1994. 148 p.
Erlih V.R. Severo-Zapadnyj Kavkaz v nachale zheleznogo veka [Northwest Caucasus at the Beginning of the Iron Age]. M. : Nauka, 2007a. 430 p.
Erlih V.R. Hronologicheskaya shema predskifskih drevnostej yuga Vostochnoj Evropy A.I. Terenozhkina i protomeotskaya gruppa pamyatnikov. Sovremennoe sostoyanie problemy [Chronological Scheme of the Pre-Scythian Antiquities of the South of Eastern Europe A.I. Terenozhkina and Protomeotskaya Group of Sites. The Current State of the Problem]. Rannіj zalіznij vіk Єvrazїі: do 100-rіchchya vіd narodzhennya Oleksіya Ivanovicha Terenozhkіna / Rannij zheleznyj vek Evrazii [Early Hall of Eurasia: up to 100 Days of the Birth of Oleksiy Ivanovich Terenozhkina / Early Iron Age of Eurasia]. Kiіv : Format, 2007b. Pp. 152–157.
Yablonskij L.T. Saki Yuzhnogo Priaral’ya (arheologiya i antropologiya mogil’nikov) [The Saks of the South Aral Sea Region (Archaeology and Anthropology of Burial Grounds)]. M. : [B.i.], 1996. 180 p.
Yablonskij L.T. Hronologiya drevnejshih pamyatnikov rannego zheleznogo veka Srednej Azii i Kazahstana (po materialam iz Priaral’ya) [The Chronology of the Most Ancient Sites of the Early Iron Age of Central Asia and Kazakhstan (based on materials from the Aral Sea region)]. Sarmatskie kul’tury Evrazii: problemy regional’noj hronologii [Sarmatian Cultures of Eurasia: Problems of Regional Chronology]. Krasnodar : [B.i.], 2004. Pp. 45–68.
Berezanskaja S.S., Kločko V.I. Das Gräberfeld von Hordeevka. Archäologien Eurasien 5. Rahden/ Westfalia : Verlag Marie Leidorf GmbH, 1998. 171 s.
Bokovenko N.A. The Origin of Horse Riding and the Development of Central Asian Nomadic Riding Harnesses // Kurgans, Ritual Sites and Settlements Eurasian Bronze and Iron Age. BAR International Series 890. Oxford : Archeopress, 2000. P. 304–310.
Gryaznov M.P. Der Großkurgan von Aržan in Tuva, Südsibirien. München : Verlag C.H. Beck, 1984. 90 s.
Horváth A. A vaszari és somlóvásárhelyi Hallstatt-kori halomsírok // VMMÉ 8. 1969. P. 109–134.
Horvath V. The Bronze Horse Bits from the Central Burial Chamber of the Kurgan Arzhan-1 // Vestnik SPbGU. 2018. T. 63. Vyp. 4. P. 1221–1237.
Miske K. A Velem Szt. Vidi őstelep I. Wien, 1907. 87 p.
Patek E. Westungarn in der Hallstattzeit. Acta Humaniora. Quellen und Forschungen zur prähistorischen und provinzialrömischen Archäologie. Bd 7. Weinheim, 1993. 167 s.
Potratz H.A. Das Pferd in der Frühzeit. Rostock : Hinstorff, 1938.
Bokovenko N.A. Nachal’nyj etap kul’tury rannih kochevnikov Sayano-Altaya (po materialam konskogo snaryazheniya) : dis. ... kand. ist. nauk [The Initial Stage of the Culture of the Early Nomads of Sayano-Altai (based on horse equipment) : Dis. ... Cand. Hist. Sciences]. L., 1986. 241 p.
Bokovenko N.A. Formirovanie konskogo snaryazheniya rannih kochevnikov Central’noj Azii [The Formation of Horse Equipment of the Early Nomads of Central Asia]. Mir Bol’shogo Altaya [World of Big Altai]. 2018. №4 (1). Pp. 8–42.
Val’chak S.B. K voprosu o datirovke kompleksa iz Chernogorovskogo kurgana [On the Dating of a Complex from the Chernogorovsky Mound]. Rossijskaya arheologiya [Russian Archaeology]. 1994. №2. Pp. 131–134.
Val’chak S.B. Konskoe snaryazhenie v pervoj treti I-go tys. do n. e. na yuge Vostochnoj Evropy [Horse Equipment in the First Third of the 1st Millennium BC in the South of Eastern Europe]. M. : Taus, 2009. 291 p.
Val’chak S.B., P’yankov A.V., Hachaturova E.A., Erlih V.R. Kubanskij mogil’nik. Materialy raskopok N.V. Anfimova 1965 goda [Kuban Burial Ground. Excavation Materials of N.V. Anfimov in 1965]. M. : IA
RAN, 2016. 208 p.
Vishnevskaya O.A. Kul’tura sakskih plemyon nizov’ev Syrdar’i v VII–V vv. do n.e. (po materialam Ujgaraka) [Culture of the Saka Tribes of the Lower Syr Darya in the 7th – 5th Centuries BC (based on Uygarak)]. M. : Nauka, 1973. 163 p. (Trudy Horezmskoj Arheolo-etnograficheskoj ekspedicii. Т. VIII) [Proceedings of the Khorezm Archaeological and Ethnographic Expedition. Vol. VIII).
Galanina L.K. Ranneskifskie uzdechnye nabory po materialam Kelermesskih kurganov [Early Scythian Bridle Sets Based on the Materials of the Kelermes Mounds]. ASGE. 1983. Issue 24. Pp. 32–55.
Galanina L.K. Kelermesskie kurgany. «Carskie» pogrebeniya ranneskifskoj epohi [Celermes Mounds.“Royal” Burials of the Early Scythian Era]. Stepnye narody Evrazii. T. I [Steppe Peoples of Eurasia. Vol. I]. M. : Paleograf, 1997. 316 p.
Gryaznov M.P. Otchyot o raskopkah kurgana Arzhan v 1971–1972 g. [Report on the Excavation of the Arzhan Mound in 1971–1972]. Arhiv IA RAN [Archive of the IA RAS]. 1973. R-1. №4833.
Gryaznov M.P. Arzhan. Foto i chertezhi raskopok 1973 g. [Arzhan. Photo and Drawings of the Excavations of 1973]. Arhiv IA RAN [Archive of IA RAS]. 1974. R-1. №5579a.
Gryaznov M.P. Otchyot o raskopkah kurgana Arzhan v Tuve 1973–1974 gg. [Report on the Excavation of the Arzhan Mound in Tuva 1973–1974]. Arhiv IA RAN [Archive of the IA RAS]. 1975. R-1. №5579.
Gryaznov M.P. K voprosu o slozhenii kul’tur skifo-sibirskogo tipa v svyazi s otkrytiem kurgana Arzhan [To the Question of the Formation of Cultures of the Scythian-Siberian Type in Connection with the Discovery of the Arzhan Mound]. KSIA. 1978. №154. Pp. 9–18.
Gryaznov M.P. Arzhan – «carskij» kurgan ranneskifskogo vremeni [Arzhan – “Royal” Barrow of Early Scythian Time]. L. : Nauka, 1980. 62 p.
Gryaznov M.P. Nachal’naya faza razvitiya skifo-sibirskih kul’tur [The Initial Phase of the Development of Scythian-Siberian Cultures]. Arheologiya Yuzhnoj Sibiri. Vyp. 12 [Archaeology of Southern Siberia. Vol. 12]. Kemerovo : KemGU, 1983. Pp. 3–18.
Gryaznov M.P., Mannaj-ool M.H. Kurgan Arzhan – mogila «carya» ranneskifskogo vremeni [Kurgan Arzhan– the Tomb of the “King” of Early Scythian Time]. UZTNIYALI. Kyzyl : [B.i.], 1973. Issue XVI. Pp. 191–206.
Evraziya v skifskuyu epohu. Radiouglerodnaya i arheologicheskaya hronologiya [Eurasia in the Scythian Era. Radiocarbon and Archaeological Chronology]. SPb. : Teza, 2005. 290 p.
Zajceva G., Vasil’ev S.S., Marsadolov L.S., van der Pliht J., Semenov A.A., Degachev V.A., Lebedeva L.M. Radiouglerod i dendrohronologiya klyuchevyh pamyatnikov Sayano-Altaya: statichticheskij analiz [Radiocarbon and Dendrochronology of Key Sayano-Altai Sites: Statistical Analysis]. Radiouglerod i arheologiya. 1997. Vyp. 2 [Radiocarbon and Archaeology. 1997. Issue 2]. Pp. 36–43.
Zajceva G., Chugunov K.V., Alekseev A.Yu., Dergachev V.A., Vasil’ev S.S., Semencov A.A., Kuk G.T., Skott E.M., Van der Pliht H., Bokovenko N.A., Kul’kova M.A., Burova N.D., Lebedeva L.M., Yunger H., Sonninen E. Istoriya i rezul’taty radiouglerodnogo datirovaniya kurgana Arzhan [The History and Results of Radiocarbon Dating of the Arzhan Mound]. Radiouglerod v arheologicheskih i paleoekologicheskih issledovaniyah [Radiocarbon in Archaeological and Paleoecological Studies]. SPb. : IIMK RAN, 2007. Pp. 251–262.
Ismagilov R.B. Pogrebenie Bol’shogo Gumarovskogo kurgana v Yuzhnom Priural’e i problema proishozhdeniya skifskoj kul’tury [The Burial of the Great Gumarovsky Mound in the South Urals and the Problem of the Origin of the Scythian Cultur]. ASGE. 1988. Issue 29. Pp. 29–47.
Ismagilov R.B. Rannie skify i Central’naya Aziya : avtoref. dis. … kand. ist. nauk [Early Scythians and Central Asia : Synopsis of the Dis. ... Cand. of Hist. Sciences]. SPb., 1993. 20 p.
Kovalevskaya V.B. Kon’ i vsadnik, puti i sud’by. Po sledam ischeznuvshih kul’tur Vostoka [The Horse and the Rider, Ways and Destinies. Folllowing the Disappeared Cultures of the East]. M. : GRVL, 1977. 150 p.
Kovpanenko G.T. Kurgany ranneskifskogo vremeni v bassejne r. Ros’ [Early Scythian Mounds in the Ros River Basin]. Kiev : Naukova Dumka, 1981. 162 p.
Leskov A.M., Erlih V.R. Mogil’nik Fars/Klady. Pamyatnik perehoda ot epohi pozdnej bronzy k rannemu zheleznomu veku na Severo-Zapadnom Kavkaze [The Fars Burial Ground /Treasures. The Site of the Transition from the Late Bronze Age to the Early Iron Age in the Northwest Caucasus]. M. : Gos. Muzej Vostoka, 1999. 162 p.
Lozhkin M.N., Petrenko V.G. Uzdechnyj nabor iz Krasnodarskogo kraya [Bridle Set from the Krasnodar Krai]. KSIA. 1981. Issue 167. Pp. 70–73.
Marsadolov L.S. Tkani iz kurgana Arzhan v Centre Azii [Fabrics from the Arzhan Mound in Center of Asia]. Pyatуe istoricheskie chteniya pamyati M.P. Gryaznova [The Fifth Historical Readings in Memory of M.P. Gryaznov]. Omsk : OmGU, 2000. Pp. 72–75.
Marsadolov L.S. Rekonstrukciya olennogo kamnya iz kurgana Arzhan-1 [Reconstruction of Deer Stone from the Arzhan-1 Mound]. Vremya i kul’tura v arheologo-etnograficheskih issledovaniyah drevnih i sovremennyh obshhestv Zapadnoj Sibiri i sopredelnyh territorij: problemy interpretacii i rekonstrukcii [Time and Culture in Archaeological and Ethnographic Studies of Ancient and Modern Societies of Western Siberia and Adjacent Territories: Problems of Interpretation and Reconstruction]. Tomsk : Argaf-Press, 2008. Pp. 60–64.
Maslov V.E., Gej A.N., Andreeva M.V. Izobrazheniya solyarnyh znakov iz mogil’nika Dysh IV [Images of Solar Signs from the Dysh IV Burial Ground]. KSIA. 2019. Issue. 256. Pp. 153–171.
Nurmuhanbetov B.N. Kompleks rannesakskogo vremeni iz Zhetysu [The Early Saka Time Complex from Zhetysu]. Arheologicheskoe nasledie Central’nogo Kazahstana: izuchenie i sohranenie. T. 2 [Archaeological Heritage of Central Kazakhstan: Study and Preservation. T. 2]. Almaty : Begazy-Tasmola, 2017. Pp. 252–257.
Petrenko V.G. Krasnoznamenskij mogil’nik. Elitnye kurgany ranneskifskoj epohi na Severnom Kavkaze [The Krasnoznamensky Burial Ground. Elite Mounds of the Early Scythian Era in the North Caucasus]. Stepnye narody Evrazii. T. III [Steppe Peoples of Eurasia. Vol. III]. M.; Berlin; Bordo : Paleograf, 2006. 176 p.
Polos’mak N.V. Issledovaniya pamyatnikov skifskogo vremeni na Ukoke [Studies of Scythian Time Sites in Ukok]. ALTAICA. 1993. №3. Pp. 21–31.
Pogrebova M.N. Zakavkaz’e i ego svyazi s Perednej Aziej v skifskoe vremya [Transcaucasia and its Relations with Western Asia in Scythian Time]. M. : Nauka, 1984. 237 p.
Ryabkova T.V. Izobrazheniya rombovidnyh znakov kak svidetel’stvo migracij v epohu rannih kochevnikov [Images of Diamond-Shaped Signs as Evidence of Migrations in the Era of the Early Nomads]. Margulanovskie chteniya – 2011 [Margulanov Readings – 2011]. Astana : ENU im. L.N. Gumileva, 2011. Pp. 104–108.
Smirnov K.F. Arheologicheskie dannye o drevnih vsadnikah Povolzhsko-Ural’skih stepej [Archaeological Data on the Ancient Horsemen of the Volga-Ural Steppes]. Sovetskaya arheologiya [Soviet Archaeology]. 1961. №1. Pp. 46–72.
Smirnov N.Уu. Zapadnye komponenty v kul’turah rannih kochevnikov Sayano-Altajskogo nagor’ya v VIII–V vv. do n.e. : diss. … kand. ist. nauk [Western Components in the Cultures of the Early Nomads of the Sayan-Altai Highlands in the 8th – 5th Centuries. BC : Diss. ... Cand. of Hist. Sciences]. SPb. : IIMK RAN, 2012. 262 p.
Terenozhkin A.I. Kimmerijcy [Cimmerians]. Kiev : Naukova Dumka, 1976. 219 p.
Uvarova P.S. Mogil’niki Severnogo Kavkaza // MAK. 1900. T. VIII. 381 c.
Halikov A.H. Volgo-Kam’e v nachale epohi rannego zheleza (VIII–VI vv. do n.e.) [Volga-Kamye at
the Beginning of the Early Iron Age (the 8th – 6th Centuries BC)]. M. : Nauka, 1977. 262 p.
Chlenova N.L. Central’naya Aziya i skify I. Data kurgana Arzhan i ego mesto v sisteme kul’tur skifsogo mira [Central Asia and the Scythians I. The Date of the Arzhan Mound and its Place in the System of Cultures of the Scythian World. M. : IA RAN, 1997. 98 p.
Chugunov K.V. Arzhan-1 i Arzhan-2: sravnitel’nyj analiz [Arzhan-1 and Arzhan-2: Comparative Analysis]. Nasledie narodov Cental’noj Azii i sopredel’nyh territorij: izuchenie, sohranenie i ispol’zovanie. Ch. 1 [The Heritage of the Peoples of Central Asia and Adjacent Territories: Study, Conservation and Use. Part 1]. Kyzyl : KCO «Anyyak», 2009. Pp. 48–52.
Shul’ga P.I., Shul’ga D.P. Mogil’nik Saensai ranneskifskogo vremeni u g. Urumchi (Sin’czyan, Kitaj) [Saensai Burial Ground of the Early Scythian Time near the City of Urumqi (Xinjiang, China)]. TGE. LXXVII: Arheologiya bez granic: kollekcii, problemy, issledovaniya, gipotezy [TSE. LXXVII: Archaeology without Borders: Collections, Problems, Research, Hypotheses]. SPb. : Gosudarstvennyj Ermitazh, 2015. Pp. 512–533.
Erlih V.R. Bronzovye uzdechnye nabory i problema hronologii predskifsogo i ranneskifskogo vremeni [Bronze Bridle Sets and the Problem of Chronology of the Scythian and Early Scythian Times]. Drevnosti Severnogo Kavkaza i Prichernomor’ya [Antiquities of the North Caucasus and the Black Sea]. M. : [B.i.], 1991. Pp. 35–39.
Erlih V.R. U istokov ranneskifskogo kompleksa [At the Origins of the Early Scythian Complex]. M. : Gos. Muzej Vostoka, 1994. 148 p.
Erlih V.R. Severo-Zapadnyj Kavkaz v nachale zheleznogo veka [Northwest Caucasus at the Beginning of the Iron Age]. M. : Nauka, 2007a. 430 p.
Erlih V.R. Hronologicheskaya shema predskifskih drevnostej yuga Vostochnoj Evropy A.I. Terenozhkina i protomeotskaya gruppa pamyatnikov. Sovremennoe sostoyanie problemy [Chronological Scheme of the Pre-Scythian Antiquities of the South of Eastern Europe A.I. Terenozhkina and Protomeotskaya Group of Sites. The Current State of the Problem]. Rannіj zalіznij vіk Єvrazїі: do 100-rіchchya vіd narodzhennya Oleksіya Ivanovicha Terenozhkіna / Rannij zheleznyj vek Evrazii [Early Hall of Eurasia: up to 100 Days of the Birth of Oleksiy Ivanovich Terenozhkina / Early Iron Age of Eurasia]. Kiіv : Format, 2007b. Pp. 152–157.
Yablonskij L.T. Saki Yuzhnogo Priaral’ya (arheologiya i antropologiya mogil’nikov) [The Saks of the South Aral Sea Region (Archaeology and Anthropology of Burial Grounds)]. M. : [B.i.], 1996. 180 p.
Yablonskij L.T. Hronologiya drevnejshih pamyatnikov rannego zheleznogo veka Srednej Azii i Kazahstana (po materialam iz Priaral’ya) [The Chronology of the Most Ancient Sites of the Early Iron Age of Central Asia and Kazakhstan (based on materials from the Aral Sea region)]. Sarmatskie kul’tury Evrazii: problemy regional’noj hronologii [Sarmatian Cultures of Eurasia: Problems of Regional Chronology]. Krasnodar : [B.i.], 2004. Pp. 45–68.
Berezanskaja S.S., Kločko V.I. Das Gräberfeld von Hordeevka. Archäologien Eurasien 5. Rahden/ Westfalia : Verlag Marie Leidorf GmbH, 1998. 171 s.
Bokovenko N.A. The Origin of Horse Riding and the Development of Central Asian Nomadic Riding Harnesses // Kurgans, Ritual Sites and Settlements Eurasian Bronze and Iron Age. BAR International Series 890. Oxford : Archeopress, 2000. P. 304–310.
Gryaznov M.P. Der Großkurgan von Aržan in Tuva, Südsibirien. München : Verlag C.H. Beck, 1984. 90 s.
Horváth A. A vaszari és somlóvásárhelyi Hallstatt-kori halomsírok // VMMÉ 8. 1969. P. 109–134.
Horvath V. The Bronze Horse Bits from the Central Burial Chamber of the Kurgan Arzhan-1 // Vestnik SPbGU. 2018. T. 63. Vyp. 4. P. 1221–1237.
Miske K. A Velem Szt. Vidi őstelep I. Wien, 1907. 87 p.
Patek E. Westungarn in der Hallstattzeit. Acta Humaniora. Quellen und Forschungen zur prähistorischen und provinzialrömischen Archäologie. Bd 7. Weinheim, 1993. 167 s.
Potratz H.A. Das Pferd in der Frühzeit. Rostock : Hinstorff, 1938.
Published
2020-09-02
How to Cite
Horvat V. HORSE BURIALS IN CHAMBER 31 OF THE ARZHAN-1 MOUND (new data on cultural relations in the Eurasian steppes in the 8th – early 6th centuries BC) // THEORY AND PRACTICE OF ARCHAEOLOGICAL RESEARCH, 2020. Vol. 31, № 3. P. 134-153 DOI: 10.14258/tpai(2020)3(31).-11. URL: http://journal.asu.ru/tpai/article/view/%2831%29.-11.
Issue
Section
MATERIAL ANALYSIS IN ARCHAEOLOGY
Theory and Practice of Archaeological Research is a golden publisher, as we allow self-archiving, but most importantly we are fully transparent about your rights.
Authors may present and discuss their findings ahead of publication: at biological or scientific conferences, on preprint servers, in public databases, and in blogs, wikis, tweets, and other informal communication channels.
Theory and Practice of Archaeological Research allows authors to deposit manuscripts (currently under review or those for intended submission to ABS) in non-commercial, pre-print servers such as ArXiv.
Authors who publish with this journal agree to the following terms:
- Authors retain copyright and grant the journal right of first publication with the work simultaneously licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY 4.0) that allows others to share the work with an acknowledgement of the work's authorship and initial publication in this journal.
- Authors are able to enter into separate, additional contractual arrangements for the non-exclusive distribution of the journal's published version of the work (e.g., post it to an institutional repository or publish it in a book), with an acknowledgement of its initial publication in this journal.
- Authors are permitted and encouraged to post their work online (e.g., in institutional repositories or on their website) prior to and during the submission process, as it can lead to productive exchanges, as well as earlier and greater citation of published work (See The Effect of Open Access).
2.jpg)
